I've underestimated my time this weekend, as it's my Birthday Weekend, so as soon as I get a few moments away from my annoying family members (just kidding!) I'll get this moving again!
@AbzanCompany - This guy is quite the dreaded pirate! I like that they become Zombie Horrors to prevent them from being sac'd if he bounces in and out. I think you've made a fair attempt to balance him out, but I think I might have liked to see him as a Legendary Creature, for Flavor, if nothing else.
@sanjaya666 - Fun flavor Pirate here! I think for the CMC and flavor of a negotiator, it should be more of an Artifact exchange than a full on Shanghai of creatures.
@Brainifyer - Them be some looters! I like it, but it feels like it puts itself at odds with it's useful ability, and it's uncontrolled desire to get itself killed!
@IanLowenthal - Four Pirates with some fun elements. I think the Dinosaur Pirate, and the Innovative Raider are the two I like best of the four.
@Tenebris Nemo - This guy might be a bit strong, but he's got a little balance and Flavor to him that I like!
Awesome! Alright, the next challenge is about creating cards with...
Champion an (object) (When this enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you exile another (object) you control. When this leaves the battlefield, that card returns to the battlefield.)
@AbzanCompany - Dark Bloodsworn: A man who eats his enemies for breakfast. Maybe a bit too cheap, but epic nevertheless!
@DragonSage - Discovery Mangrove: A sweet card which could fit in any deck which uses energy counters. I think it should be Treefolk instead of Golem, but I still love it!
@IanLowenthal - Cities: As i said earlier, these enchantments have amazing concepts, yet the abilities in them are kinda OP compared to their CMCs. Kinda reminds me of Fortification artifacts from Future Sight. Good work!
@jazipa - Prince of Blacksteel: We need more Demon Knights, and this guy is a good specimen. Its abilities give it a good flavor which I like!
@sanjaya666 - Vali, Frost Berserker: When you get this guy into your side, opponents will certainly back off and stay defensive. Fantastic artwork and flavor!
Comments
Happy Birthday! I hope you have a great time this weekend.
Have a great weekend Squirrel-lord!
Happy Birthday! May the squirrels congregate to pay homage to you, O Supreme Sciuridae!
Now let the judging begin!
@TigerSol - Arr! Arr! Arr!
@AbzanCompany - This guy is quite the dreaded pirate! I like that they become Zombie Horrors to prevent them from being sac'd if he bounces in and out. I think you've made a fair attempt to balance him out, but I think I might have liked to see him as a Legendary Creature, for Flavor, if nothing else.
@sanjaya666 - Fun flavor Pirate here! I think for the CMC and flavor of a negotiator, it should be more of an Artifact exchange than a full on Shanghai of creatures.
@Brainifyer - Them be some looters! I like it, but it feels like it puts itself at odds with it's useful ability, and it's uncontrolled desire to get itself killed!
@IanLowenthal - Four Pirates with some fun elements. I think the Dinosaur Pirate, and the Innovative Raider are the two I like best of the four.
@Tenebris Nemo - This guy might be a bit strong, but he's got a little balance and Flavor to him that I like!
The winner of this round is...
@TenebrisNemo
Champion an (object) (When this enters the battlefield, sacrifice it unless you exile another (object) you control. When this leaves the battlefield, that card returns to the battlefield.)
Examples:
Here goes nothing
https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/IanLowenthal/sets/22475
@IanLowenthal - Those cards are amazing! Nice work, dude!
Edit: I like the concept but they appear to be kinda OP. I still like them!
@Faths_Guide - Spiral Stair: The flavor, the artwork and the theme in this card fit together in a magical way as if it's from a story. I like it!
@Brainifyer - Utopian Wilderness: Awesome design! Progenitus would be proud!
@AbzanCompany - Dark Bloodsworn: A man who eats his enemies for breakfast. Maybe a bit too cheap, but epic nevertheless!
@DragonSage - Discovery Mangrove: A sweet card which could fit in any deck which uses energy counters. I think it should be Treefolk instead of Golem, but I still love it!
@IanLowenthal - Cities: As i said earlier, these enchantments have amazing concepts, yet the abilities in them are kinda OP compared to their CMCs. Kinda reminds me of Fortification artifacts from Future Sight. Good work!
@jazipa - Prince of Blacksteel: We need more Demon Knights, and this guy is a good specimen. Its abilities give it a good flavor which I like!
@sanjaya666 - Vali, Frost Berserker: When you get this guy into your side, opponents will certainly back off and stay defensive. Fantastic artwork and flavor!
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
And now, the winner of this challenge is...
@sanjaya666's Vali, Frost Berserker!
Alright, apparently I win this again lol. Nevermind.
The next challenge is about to create DINOSAUR cards since we just already had pirates some time ago because why not then?
So, is anyone against it?
I have been working on various versions of "mounts" for a while now. How is the dinosaur version compared to the old?