Mana Management Challenge

Each turn, you present some land cards the next player must use to create cards, and rate the last person's last non-land cards for 5 judging parameters, 1-10(12 high):

Originality
Graphics
Realism
Budget
Intrigue

image
Total: 5

Let the designing begin! (I cannot as I'm the first... but notice I gave some land to use)

Comments

  • Can we create nonbasic lands for the next person?
  • edited November 27
    yes. The ONLY limitation is using the lands.
  • My card for mono-green beat down.

    image

    Lands for the next cardsmith to use, to their will. :)

    imageimageimage
  • Note: There's no limit to the number of the cards. Just a limit to the total manna.
  • edited November 28
    Originality 6
    Graphics 8
    Realism 10
    Budget 3
    Intrigue 8

    image

    image

    For my lands, here:

    image

    Total: 5


  • edited November 28
    Originality: 2
    Graphics: 1
    Realism: 0
    Budget: 5
    Intrigue: 3

    I'm sorry, but it's just true, this does not in any way resemble a magic card. I might give you some more constructive criticism if you wanted, so you can improve in the future.

    Here's mine:

    image

    And the lands for the next person:
    image
    image
    image
    You have two of each. Let's get some Mardu action in here!
  • edited November 30
    Originality: 3
    Graphics: 7
    Realism: 8
    Budget: 4 (overshot by 1)
    Intrigue: 5

    image

    For my lands, these emerge this time:

    image

    Total: 3

    image

    Total: 2

    This should get interesting...

  • Bumping because I should rate my own cards...
This discussion has been closed.