@Animist I found my old reminder text: "..must attack or block together." This means that if you wish to attack a player or planeswalker, it must be legal for both and must be declared simultaneously. If you wish to block a creature, it must be legal for both and declared simultaneously.
@Faiths_Guide - ah, yes, that was in response to AustinSmith's comment. It was just the bit about soulbond representing a mount that I thought was a cool idea. But I think you've taken that to mean I was asking you to make a set! Not that it really matters either way.
More to the point - how do you find old Disqus comments!?
I wanted to try a couple things here that I need your thoughts and feedback on: 1) Make a defender version of intimidate (why can't a dude that's a defender be intimidating?) So I made this thing like a creature glaring back at you: A "Daunting" sight. 2) I wanted to give a blue creature the ability to add blue mana to a mana pool... but only because it's big enough a dude to be an island. Not sure if this fits blues identity.
@TenebrisNemo, I like the +1. I think the -4 could be just red mana, but it still works, cuz Raistlin is a planeswalker. The -5, though it synergizes well, isn't as unique as the first two abilities. (It's a simple red identity ability.)
Comments
We can hope. There were some funny conversations I'm sad to see missing.
I found my old reminder text:
"..must attack or block together."
This means that if you wish to attack a player or planeswalker, it must be legal for both and must be declared simultaneously. If you wish to block a creature, it must be legal for both and declared simultaneously.
Hey, I found one of the comments from 2 years ago:
Discussion on MTG Cardsmith 4 comments
Saddle Elk by Faiths_Guide
Faiths_Guide
Faiths_Guide Guest 2 years ago
Thanks!
This was the original Saddle Boar I was asked to make a set by @Animist, @saveria201, and @AustinSmith.
Hey!
https://disqus.com/home/discussion/mtgcardsmith/saddle_boar_by_faiths_guide_mtg_cardsmith/
More to the point - how do you find old Disqus comments!?
Yup, that could be. Either way, I was happy for the recognition 2 years ago. XD
Oh and here's the shortcut I discovered for looking up old Disqus comments:
http://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/3358/how-to-look-up-old-disqus-comments
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/keyword-soup
So this is Konotori, Disciple of Konda. I tried to not make it overpowered: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/konotori-disciple-of-konda
Still like those saddle creatures a lot, want to make more cards but lately I'm so busy
Crazy right?
Ya, super busy!
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/thibble-of-the-izmagnus
Thibble is starting to get on my nerves XD
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/mort-fizzlewit-pyro-chemist
That would be super cool, except in a two-player game.
Ooh, more innovating, fun!
Thoughts?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/swordplay
Thoughts? Under or over costed?
@Faiths_Guide, one more?
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/struck-by-inspiration
1) Make a defender version of intimidate (why can't a dude that's a defender be intimidating?) So I made this thing like a creature glaring back at you: A "Daunting" sight.
2) I wanted to give a blue creature the ability to add blue mana to a mana pool... but only because it's big enough a dude to be an island. Not sure if this fits blues identity.
Kinda cool!
Check out the discussion.
I think the mana was any color to get around the outdated Planeswalker editor.
Thoughts? I think it can be worded better.
Thoughts on my card (the one on the left)? It was designed to be an infinite combo with Quicksmith Genius. More info on the Disqus comments.
Edit: changed Treasure tokens to Gold tokens. Felt it was more flavorful.