Animist
About
- Username
- Animist
- Joined
- Visits
- 7,881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@crawdadswelcome - I personally think bending the colour pie is fine for counterspells that are limited to something specific like this. Absolutely beautiful drawing!
-
Can't go trick-or-treating without a costume!
-
@LordTachanka123 - I can't center my cards properly so I probably shouldn't comment but you might want to fix that one up! Thanks for getting the ball rolling!
-
@jaceberlin - My first thought is that the Split mechanic is somewhat complex. What if I have a Glorius Anthem out and this is a 7/7? What is 7 divided by 3? Does it need to be rounded down or rounded up? It's important to keep every possibility in …
-
Thought I'd have a go at a Zombie horde. Hopefully this is Halloween-ey enough!
-
@TenebrisNemo - Neat!
-
@MemoryHead - Nice!
-
@fire12 - Nice but it's essentially a Vampire Lacerator. That said, it has a relevant enough creature type to stand on its own. Very printable. https://scryfall.com/card/a25/114/vampire-lacerator
-
3rd entry
-
@RandomFandom - Sorry, I misunderstood. If you only want a one-time effect the easiest way to do it is "The next time you would gain life this turn, instead target opponent loses that much life." If you want to affect every lifegain ability / spell…
-
@RandomFandom - If you cast another Revitalize this same turn, then, yes, the opponent will still lose life. The effect in my wording lasts the whole turn. You only need to cast Energy Inversion once and then, every time you would gain life for the …
-
@RandomFandom - An aura is a type of enchantment that attaches to a permanent (or enchants a player in the case of curses). Instants don't attach to anything or enchant anything so an Instant can't be an Aura (unless there's some modal cardtype stuf…
-
@RandomFandom - Sorry it's taken a while to get round to your cards. Dangerous Crusade: Remember to add "until end of turn" for instants like this. I think it's actually pretty weak. You can find +2/+2 until EOT and lifegain on Moment of Triumph wh…
-
@FireOfGolden - Your art always brings a smile to my face. I think your cards are all great, except Infected Stickman perhaps ought to be a 2/1. It has two extra power compared to Doomed Dissenter but only costs one extra mana. Also, Onman's Adva…
-
Hi @RandomFandom - Please could you post links to those cards? Thanks!
-
2nd entry (notes in comments)
-
@zizick123 - Yeah, I've thought about something like that and it's a bit tricky. Like you said, you'd have to stipulate that all lands are tapped and the mana pool is empty. I suppose you could just go with that, though ideally you want mechanics to…
-
@Ral1000: Thanks for the entry. At that mana cost it's not particularly OP or anything but it does have quite a few moving parts for a common. It's like a mini Elder Gargaroth. There's nothing particularly wrong with it but simpler cards are always …
-
@zizick123 - No problem. It's always good to discuss cards! I'm not sure I understand the point about having to play a one mana card first on turn three. If I have three lands, I can just tap them all without playing anything and then cast the card…
-
Remake/rebalanace of an old card [https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dismiss-interruption?list=user] inspired by a discussion with @Suicidal_Deity about one of their recent cards [https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tame-4
-
Accompanying notes are in the comments.
-
@zizick123 - Thanks for your card! Interesting. A mechanic that rewards fair magic rather than keeping mana up for counterspells and shenanigans. This card, though, is a strictly better Tormenting Voice. Usually when a card has a higher ceiling com…
-
@Izzybean - Thanks for the cards! Here are my thoughts: Nightburn Cavalier: IMO, this is too powerful and is doing a little too much to be a common. Here are some creatures that have a very simple ETB fight ability: https://scryfall.com/car…
-
Hope no-one minds if I post cards here as well.
-
@FireOfGolden - Looking through the whole set, I actually really like your drawings!
-
@FireOfGolden Well, I'm not sure I understand the flavour behind the set but then again that doesn't really matter. A few comments on the cards: Loyal Bomber: Damage always needs to have a source, so you'd need to word this as " When ~ dies, it …
-
Dang, ninja'd by @MemoryHead @jicklemania2 - basically what @MemoryHead said.
-
I've been a bit lax in commenting on some of these so: @Ranshi @The-DM @shadow123, @Faiths_Guide, @TenebrisNemo, @Tomigon @Izzybean - all awesome. @jicklemania2 - The thing about spontaneous is it's so close to Miracle. I'm not sure the differenc…
-
2nd new entry:
-
1st new entry