MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Animist
About
- Username
- Animist
- Joined
- Visits
- 7,881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@zizick123 Sorry, but that entry doesn't qualify. There is no in-built ability or condition to be met that allows me to put The Oinodaemon from my hand onto the battlefield. If Loxodon Smiter is in my hand and someone plays a discard spell, I can p…
-
@Corwinnn Dang, I thought I'd managed to get away with it. Okay, I'll put on my rubber gloves and go digging for challenges...
-
@t4llaR - It's essentially buyback 0 which you've had to make up for by dramatically overcosting the spell. Splitting the cost between CMC and buyback is better since you're allowing the player a choice between whether to pay a lot or a little. Taki…
-
I'm hoping the wording is right here. Basically a random player is chosen for each of the permanents - it's not that one random player gets all the permanents.
-
@Gelectrode - isn't it a bit of a win-win situation? I'd probably only target 3/3s or less which means I either take it or kill it. Also I'm not sure if we'd ever see fight on an Izzet card but you never know.
-
Updated version of this card
-
@IanLowenthal - Yeah, it's a premium feature.
-
Made this for the reactivation challenge. I could only find a couple of cards that do things 'secretly' (Stalking Leonin and Menacing Ogre) and I've tried to stick to their wording as much as possible. Hopefully it makes sense!
-
@TheClayKnight - Thank you for the kind words
-
These are some of the cards I'm happiest about:
-
@Djayhero - It's not a criticism, just a heads up! But the Gatherer is really useful for checking existing Magic cards.
-
@Djayhero - just so you know, Doomed Necromancer is already a card: http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=129880 It's an absolute beast in my Olivia deck! (No, not that Olivia, the other Olivia).
-
Congrats everyone!
-
An entry for non-counter and another for both counter and non-counter:
-
@sanjaya666 - I have absolutely no idea what you're talking about...
-
-
@Credius - Assaulting Knights goes infinite with itself since Rally will be triggered when the tokens are created and so on. You can circumvent that by triggering only when a non-token ally enters the battlefield, but I don't think that's technicall…
-
@serptentail Thanks. Yeah, the white one is the sort of thing you might see in pillow fort decks which are always annoying but it does force you to be a total pacifist so there's some drawback. Quick comments on your cards - You probably won't se…
-
These were meant to be entries for the paladin contest, trying to do something with oaths. Unlike the Gatewatch oaths, these are oaths made by you, and you can choose to stick with them or break them. Not sure if the balancing needs work so I'd be …
-
I've probably gone a bit off tangent here but I decided to do something around oaths that was a bit different to the planeswalker oaths from Gatewatch. Basically these are meant to be oaths you make and if you break the oath they're gone.
-
I've been in the same position as you and wrote a farewell message like this and since then I keep leaving the site and then returning to it. My point is that things have a way of working themselves out. Reality doesn't need to crush your hobbies. I…
-
@Credius Cool, thanks. A little lategame abuse might not be so bad - hopefully the 'first time each turn' clause stops the worst of it.
-
Any feedback, particularly on balance, appreciated!
-
@NokiSkaur Yeah, I'll admit I didn't read through the forum. Personally I wouldn't make this mono-white though since white isn't a colour that copies and clones things - it really ought to be part blue. But if multicoloured legendaries aren't what …
-
Something I threw together for equipments - not sure if it's what you're looking for