MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Animist
About
- Username
- Animist
- Joined
- Visits
- 7,881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Beydin13 Annihilator isn't a mechanic that's ever likely to return so that might be something to consider but it's up to you. Wording-wise, I'm guessing it's meant to be if you cast another creature this turn. If not, casting a 5/6 annihilator 2 f…
-
@modnation675 - "I think the card is well balanced if it weren't for the cost" That's a slightly odd comment. Cost is pretty much what determines balance! What do you mean? And, yeah, Urbis Protector isn't a great card.
-
@Faiths_Guide @modnation675 @Hergusbergus This is probably more comparable with Urbis Protector: http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Card/Details.aspx?multiverseid=366415 But either way, yeah, I guess it does need to be {4}{w}{w}. Bit weak but hopef…
-
@Hergusbergus - so {4}{w}{w}? Doesn't that seem really expensive?
-
Hope this doesn't seem overcosted. 5 mana for a total of 5/5, one with flying and one with promote felt right to me.
-
-
@Class - the links to your cards don't seem to be working.
-
@TenebrisNemo - Sure **Attention Please!** The deadline is now the following Sunday, 23rd April. If you haven't entered yet, there's plenty of time to do so and, if you have, there's plenty of time to remake or replace your entries if you want!
-
-
@Jyagaimasu - I just wanted to check that that was what you intended. It's your design!
-
@saveria201 - thanks for the entry! It's great to see an interpretation from an 'enemy' point of view. @pstmdrn - just a couple of tweaks. Words after colons are capitalised, so "Add {g} to your mana pool." And the last ability would be "Activate t…
-
@Jyagaimasu - I don't like to comment too much on the entries until I judge but just to let you know that, when the first ability on Brand of Fire triggers and you discard a card, it'll trigger again because you discarded a card. It basically allows…
-
@Credius - noted!
-
@pstmdrn - hopefully lots of people are inspired to make entries. Looking forward to seeing more cards everyone!
-
@sanjaya666 - only one entry per character please. Both of yours are for Bjeldor. You can also make a card for each of the other characters.
-
@Odogom - Go with whatever feels good to you! I like your use of 'Tsoth Moran'.
-
@Faiths_Guide - Pelavor is the name of the entire plane and Krovmir is just Volkir's bit of it. Depends which of those best suits the design you're going for.
-
@Odogom - Please can you post a link to your card? At the moment it's just the picture. Thanks.
-
@Faiths_Guide - I know. It was just in case people noted your explanation about the synergy and thought it might be required. Glad you're enjoying the contest!
-
@Faiths_Guide - Thanks for the entry! @everyone - Just to be clear, it's not required that your entries synergise ability-wise with any of the cards that I've linked above. It's cool if they do but the thematic connection is more important. You're…
-
@Faiths_Guide - awesome!
-
@Nwk234 - Thanks for your entry but can you fix the link for your card so that it links to the card page rather than just the picture?
-
@Gelectrode - Thanks for the entry! The only issue is that the rules state that Thavra's name should either appear in the name of the card or in the flavour text (or both). There might not be much room for the latter but if there's another name for …
-
Sorry @ThyMaster - it has to be one of the six characters listed above.
-
Thanks for the cool entries so far!
-
@Faiths_Guide @Gelectrode - Thank you! Congrats to everyone.
-
Hi Dylan and welcome to MTGCardsmith. @Corwinnn can answer your question better than I but as far as I know there isn't a way to re-upload cards that you've already created before you had an account. I think you may have to re-create them. I may b…
-
-
This is a card that I've gushed over in the past, but just in case our newer members haven't seen it: Planeswalkers are really difficult to design but I love the way this one's come together. Unfortunately @milanaarz isn't around much these days…
-
@strongbelieves - that's very flattering, thank you!