MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Animist
About
- Username
- Animist
- Joined
- Visits
- 7,881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@SNAPcreator7 - I wasn't really suggesting changing the card, just the mana cost. If it was {b}{b}, I think it would be great.
-
@SNAPcreator7 - No problem. You might also want to consider making it cost 2 mana (at least). Check out these two cards and see how yours compares, particularly since yours has flash: https://scryfall.com/card/mbs/58/blisterstick-shaman https:/…
-
@SNAPcreator7 - Also, it's worth posting a link to the card or making the image clickable so that people can comment on / favourite it if they like.
-
@SNAPcreator7 - Thanks for the entry! Perhaps that would be more suited to black? Also, it's a small formatting point, but Flash would go at the top of the text box.
-
Mercy, those are some hella generous prizes! Here's my entry, telling the story of a squire who becomes a knight and gets their own squire:
-
Three official old entries:
-
@IronCrusher - Hey, glad you're enjoying it! And, yes, batches are fine!
-
@Temurzoa - Thanks for the entry! I'm guessing that should be Riposte rather than Riptose? Also, should we be wary of commons referring to the stack even in reminder text? I feel like this mechanic is a wee bit complicated. Is it obvious to a ne…
-
@Ranshi @CassZero - Let's stick with new.
-
@Ranshi - Made on or after the date I started this thread, so 12 September 2020.
-
@MemoryHead - These are all excellent.
-
@IronCrusher - Very nice. Pollination Sprite is particularly fun! @SpellPiper2213 - Neat! Really like the Paladin and the Wanderer. @TenebrisNemo - I would expect nothing less than legendary cards from you!
-
@TenebrisNemo - I really like the card but if I'm being honest I'm a bit torn about keywording a mechanic that, by definition, relegates pretty much every card its on to the sideboard. When I think of keywords, I think of something I can build aroun…
-
@JMGreer41 Just my opinion but I feel like a Bruce Banner card would probably work best as a transform card like the werewolves from Innistrad. At the moment, with it just being a sac ability, it's lacking any flavour of what turns him into the H…
-
Realistic one mana creature. I'll try to think of a green and black one too!
-
Hi!! :::waves back:::
-
Three old cards.
-
I'll follow @Faiths_Guide cue: 78th?
-
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 - It turns out Steve Argyle has publicly asked that that piece of art not be used by anyone, which is fair enough.
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa - oops, sorry, I didn't read the rules properly. I made Venerated Sadist for this challenge so I'll pick that as my final submission. Thanks!
-
-
-
@EnvyReaper - sorry, but just saying "no..." isn't very helpful feedback! Can you try again? Does it seem balanced? Is it OP? Thoughts on utility? Any rules text errors? Thanks.
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 - I've commented on your card. Next:
-
-
I think it's fine either way. I just wanted it to be different to Ob Nixilis, the Fallen.
-
-
A couple of simple limited bombs: