MTG Cardsmith Community Forums

Visit MTG Cardsmith→

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Register

Animist

About

Username: Animist
Joined: September 2015
Visits: 7,881
Last Active: October 2022
Roles: Member

Comments

@Faiths_Guide - cool, I've gone with 3/1 any target for now.

in Vampires Comment by Animist May 2019
@Faiths_Guide - it's difficult without playtesting. The thing is that first time round it'll be a more-difficult-to-cast uncommon Vizkopa Vampire, which perhaps is a little too weak? Perhaps a middle ground might be 3/1 but it can deal damage to any…

in Vampires Comment by Animist May 2019
@Faiths_Guide - Possibly? I don't know. The first one you play won't trigger so you'll have to wait for it to die and then get your second before you can do any ETB shenanigans. Would that be worth it to kill an x/3 in the midgame?

in Vampires Comment by Animist May 2019
in Vampires Comment by Animist May 2019
@Faiths_Guide I guess it depends on whether WotC have a rule that Monarch can't apply to standard. Perhaps an Arthurian set would be a good place to try the mechanic in standard?

in The Arthurian Legend Challenge — *Circuit Challenge* Comment by Animist May 2019
-->

in The Arthurian Legend Challenge — *Circuit Challenge* Comment by Animist May 2019
@Ranshi922 - yup, that's the one!

in Where are y'all from? Comment by Animist May 2019
a) London b) London c) A few years ago d) Dark Confidant or Bitterblossom e) That blue spy card @Chairforce made that I can't remember the name of now. f) @TenebrisNemo, @Temurzoa, @bnew07, @Tomigon and @Beeswax

in Where are y'all from? Comment by Animist May 2019
-->

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
--> So instead of your creature throwing this and you catching it, instead they'll catch it... unless they don't and it ends up chopping off a few of their fingers instead.

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@envyreaper I would second what's been said above about being clearer around the requirements. For example, I took the challenge to mean that each side had to be a different colour and so I figured colourless would be okay since each side would be…

in Multicolor Transformations **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
-->

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
in Multicolor Transformations **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
Old entry:

in Multicolor Transformations **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@The_Jam_Man - Hi and welcome! Hope you have fun here! No, talking about the process isn't frowned upon. In fact, I think more of us should do it.

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@Faiths_Guide - That's an elegant suggestion, thanks! I had intended on giving it flying to start with before I ran out of room!

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
-->

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
in Face Down **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
in Face Down **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
Old entry

in Reactivation Challenge #49 **For The King** Comment by Animist April 2019
--> Using exile instead of sacrifice to represent the entire woodland coming to life as one. Decided to go down the legendary route because I realised there wouldn't be much point in playing a second copy if you already have one on the battlefi…

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
in Face Down **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@KorandAngels - Yup, that was my intent. It's meant to represent the need for a precise headshot rather than just trying to bludgeon it to death.

in Reactivation Challenge #49 **For The King** Comment by Animist April 2019
Simple entry: -->

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@Faiths_Guide

in Reactivation Challenge #49 **For The King** Comment by Animist April 2019
Intended to be a zombie that only goes down with a headshot.

in Reactivation Challenge #49 **For The King** Comment by Animist April 2019
@EnvyReaper Well, sorinjace's rules say: "recreate the card to be a better card than it actually is" so I've just chosen to interpret that literally. If that's not the spirit of the challenge, I'm sure he'll judge accordingly. No worries

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
Remake of an older card, so feel free to count this as an old entry Mostly just reimagining what a card with this name might do.

in MAGIC'S WORST CARDS MAKEOVER CONTEST!! **Circuit Challenge** Comment by Animist April 2019
@pjbear2005 - Thanks for the synopsis! Really well written and very useful for people like me who have no idea about MTG lore!!

in War of the Spark Comment by Animist April 2019
in Liliana's Contest Comment by Animist April 2019