MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Astrophibian
About
- Username
- Astrophibian
- Joined
- Visits
- 175
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Ai art generator
-
-
@FireOfGolden We use proxy prints. It worked fine. I appreciate the reinforcement, but it works for what it was intended to be used for. We're brainstorming other ideas now. Thank you ?
-
@Ilmarinen Appreciate the opinion, but it actually functions perfectly for what we needed it for. Thank you.
-
@Globert-the-Martian Generic ai google art
-
Ai art
-
Awesome. ?
-
@FireOfGolden https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/esia-fae-sanctuary-2 I still think keeping it as permanents is fine to instants and sorceries. I upped the cost by 1 on the sack ability ans specified nontoken perms and upped the cost for activayion b…
-
@FireOfGolden Ah, so that way the opponent can still target with creature abilities. Thank you for clarifying. I also coyld have sworn there are tribal enchantments out there. Edit: I can also increase activation from three to maybe five nontoke…
-
@StuffnSuch I think I like the outright uncertainty of Spellfracture Prism. I like that the drawback is that it can all be towards your creatures. My only thing is how do we determine this randomness? Do we roll a dice or flip a coin. I think that…
-
@cadstar369 Only thing I agree with is possibly making it legendary. Also, this is an update to a previous feedback. Not really a new one. There are plenty things opponents can do to interact with creatures. Exile, destroy, deal damage. All instan…
-
@FireOfGolden I took some of your advice. Let me know how you feel about this one. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/esia-fae-sanctuary-1
-
@Floodkiller45 Water in the Water. I like the theme, but I think the theme "deathstare" makes me think of....well, death lol. Perhaps something like "Aura of Atrophy" or something with decay or withering definitions would be better. Overall, thoug…
-
@Jadefire Your card is has too much sneakiness and I love it
-
@Robo_Kitty Thanks for the feedback, but things that you compared it to like Armaggedon. It only destroys lands. That's why ol' Arma is just 4. Natural Obliteration destroys only nonbasic lands, but since so many people use them, it's more of a b…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blastfire-pup
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/natural-obliteration
-
@bramboy99 Yeah, the U ability was to kind of counter scry. I think minus 1 on the cost would make this more feasible. Thanks.
-
@bramboy99 This is good. I might add something like "unless opponent taps". Something for them to think when cards like this hit the field. Looks good otherwise. Also the flavor text is shunted in a weird way. Might just be the website. Anywho, …
-
@Floodkiller45 Seems mostly good, but I'd drop the cost by 1. The drawbacks and benefits balance each other out IMHO. It definitely makes the player choose to either have it on their creature or keep an opponent from defending maybe with a powrfu…
-
@FireOfGolden I took some of your advice. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/herf-tyrannical-duke Let me know what you think
-
@cadstar369 The issue is how *strong* each one is, but apparently something like this has mixed reviews, pros and cons. The issue is the cost to abilities given. You can so much for so little cost. The most common I get from sharing this is to ad…
-
@FireOfGolden Ok. Thanks for the help. I'll make updates.
-
@FireOfGolden That's also why I asked if it was homebrewed. Which you confirmed it is.
-
@FireOfGolden Are forgotten creatures a new thing or something homebrewed?
-
@cadstar369 That was the point. They are legendary and yours does 3x more than they do for much less of a cost. One has the same cost. Does less. Is legendary. One costs a tiny bit more. Still does less albeit with a drawback as well. You lack t…
-
@FireOfGolden So I'm still not understanding. I thought the theme this week is to *break* the color pie by adding things they normally can't do while trying to balance it with the gameplay formula(s).
-
@FireOfGolden I am a bit confused. It sounded like the third ability was bad but then it sounded workable? I guess it's just based on what the discard does. I don't remember seeing alot of greens do disard, but I also haven't played in 10 years. …
-
@cadstar369 Sorry. I guess I thought it was obvious. Disabling opponent lifegain, making your creatures basically unblockable *and* giving all of these creatures wither on a 2 drop is alot. It's not even legendary. These are a couple examples I…
-
If I recall, discarding cards is kinda black and sometimes blue pie abilities. What if green had some? https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/herf-maplegrove-tyrant