MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
BT9154
About
- Username
- BT9154
- Joined
- Visits
- 62
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@cadstar369 Right, she is a bit too powerful giving the ability to generate treasures basically as a passive free starting bonus. The incentives and disincentives to play her how I want needs to be overhauled. I still like the concept of some kind o…
-
@StuffnSuch the safe way is non-token but it'll just be a run of the mill zombie synergy deck. Non-Zombie is more interesting to get the most is to make lots of non-zombie tokens, but for black the next best would be rats, if you want to swarm other…
-
@cadstar369 Thanks for taking a look at Kronii a few pages back, quite some interesting interactions you found. Suppose only returning spell you don't control should solve much shenanigans, it was my intent to be delaying your opponent's stuff to be…
-
@LvB Demonblood Skinflayer - The wording should be following magic's templates and phrasing to avoid ruling confusion. It would probably be like this: When Demonblood Skinflayer enters the battlefield, you may pay up to 3 life, if you do, put a…
-
@LvB Phyrexian Cathedral - In a sacrifice deck this land is nuts. It's enter the battlefield is already a Tremble and Innocent Blood in one card and 0 cost so right there it already good. For the most part it's almost like a Phyrexian Altar if yo…
-
@WarriorCatInAhat Oblivion's Touch - wubrg for either one of the effects is over costed and if you have access to all those colours there are just better ways to get that effect. It should be "choose one or both" and then you can justify the diffi…
-
@hileandr Thanks for taking the time to reviewing my cards! Sorry for the anime images but bruh it's actually hard to find art of specific anime characters that are tasteful, fit the flavour and actually have stuff in the background. You'd be su…
-
@hileandr Hi would you mind reviewing these? I'm a Johnny player so I like designing build arounds or cards that are self contained. These are my favorite ones and that I think are most elegantly designed for theme and character. …
-
Here are a few I've designed over the past year that I think would be interesting build around Mill Discard Life Gain Diplomacy? Islands Chaos
-
@hileandr It's rare to see a skeleton tribal card, 4 mana for 3/3 worth of stats is par for the course. Creating skeletons and then milling fits in black graveyard decks but I feel this card should have some graveyard interaction given it self mil…
-
@cadstar369 I like this card, it can be used and abused in so many angles. You can get some amazing value playing it with 0 cost creatures, go wide and upgrade all your guys, have +1/+1 counters so you will have an advantage in combat, a weird wra…
-
@The_333_ It's a Johnny card, it's up to you to set up a board state before you cast it to try and make an extra draw each turn useful. Or somehow make an opponent play it
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/the-frozen-throne-6
-
@SPyBondPlays 5 mana 5/3 is reasonable as most with that statline are 4 but coloured. Having it being crewed balances the trample and menace I guess. Second ability is powerful, not many cards have repeat bounce no questions asked for good reas…
-
@Tonysparks Thanks for holding the contest and for picking my card for 1st place, this is my first 1st placed card for a contest. I'm glad you got the design, I was going for a teacher or a captain whose valiant death galvanized those that looked u…
-
Combine 2 bad ones with 1 good one
-
Entry#1
-
@RandomFandom Interesting card concept but it slows down your deck as you are replacing a draw for 1 damage, plus the logistics of sleeving several token cards and then removing them after the game can be a bit annoying. You should have the token …
-
@GloomyAndSunny1_0_1 interesting card, but you need to work on your wording to streamline what you are trying to get across. There are rules for words like "plays", "target" and "choose" It should look something like this. It still needs to ch…
-
Entry#1 for legendary instant Had an idea of one of your legendary creatures jumping in and saving you
-
@feralitator I had "As long as Moona has a charge counter on it, Moona isn't a creature" not separated due to space reasons. Originally it didn't have an add counter ability but I thought of it later on and I thought it was a really unique way to d…
-
@GloomyAndSunny1_0_1 It's a good card once it's out, but anything is good if it has double-strike, menace and a decent size. However most games are decided by the time you can get to 10 mana, most game end even before that so it's a dead card in you…
-
Entry #3
-
How about the opposite of a curse? A blessing Not exactly the most creative but could have its uses in commander politics. And blessings can be a creative spin on the opposite of the various existing curses.
-
Entry #1 Aura This can be abused but I checked powerful creature abilities like card draw and that at best if you blow all the counters is draw 10. Anything with +X/+X, copying spells or creating tokens are probably biggest plays but creat…
-
Meet his best friend Yeah your card is not balanced but it's more of a card where if you win or if your opponent wins in a game that you played it no one feels they earned the win.
-
Basically enchanted player has cumulative upkeep - tap an untapped permanent, if they can't they lose half their life. It was harder to word since you control the enchantment and I wanted the payment to happen on their turn.
-
@jadefire
-
Inspired by the legendary heroes from the Fate series Entry #1 for Legendary Sorcery Open your armoury and rain weapons down on your enemies. Entry #1 Equipment Sever the ties between the player and their creatures
-
@Yururu I like it, a desperate colour fixer for when you are colour screwed, a land you don't have to put in your deck but a backup that can tutored up to keep you in the game even though it's incredibly inefficient. Not bad choice in draft too, it …