MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Butters
About
- Username
- Butters
- Joined
- Visits
- 287
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Again I thank you all for bearing with me through these tough times as this contest judging distracted me from the dark times that are happening currently around me. Hopefully, I will stay active, maybe just commenting on a few things here and there…
-
SECOND PLACE...... @Gelectrode ART IS ON POINT!!!! Ult was a bit broken but loved the idea of it. I hope everyone can read when they get your card, because you basically wrote a novel on it. Prize 10 Favourites + 2 sections from the competitions o…
-
THIRD PLACE..... @Corwinnn Simple art let you down in this competition. Flavour was limited but was enough to be realistic. I love vampires so you hit a weak spot there. Prize 10 Favourites + 1 section from the competition will be posted in the "W…
-
Forth goes to...@KJMartin I loved this planeswalker however, your ult is incredibly broken. By turn 6, it would be easier to go back in time to make Hillary president then it would be to beat this ability. Prize 10 Favourites.
-
5th PLACE GOES TO.....@TastyCheez (actually spelt it right this time) Found this planeswalker was a "one show pony" with only life gain being its main attribute. Was formatted correctly and loved the art, hence getting a high rating. Prize 9 Favou…
-
6th Place is.... @dashdo101 Major issue I have with this planeswalker is the wording. The +2 ability is worded incorrectly and therefore, lost points in that area. Prize 8 favourites of any choice. AND THEN THERE WERE 5....ANNOUNCED SOON. Goin…
-
7th PLACE is going to... @kltmtg29 This planeswalker was expensive in abilities and personally, I can't see anyone being able to use it's major neg abilities. The idea of the planeswalker, i enjoyed, just needs a bit more thought put into it. Priz…
-
8th PLACE is going to......@Tutlaschk Unfortunately, in my mind, this Planeswalker was weak and not worth the mana cost. There are spells and creatures that are cheaper and do the exact same thing. Prize: 4 favourites on cards of your choice. A…
-
FINALLY RESULTS ARE IN. Remember results will be delayed and posted position by position just to narrow things down. Firstly, I do have the unfortunate job of DQing those who haven't entered. @TrippleBoggey3 @thenightbringer Due to no entry in …
-
To answer some questions, Prizes, due to my funds going elsewhere because of recent events, have had to go to non-physical prizes. Again, I am not happy with this but there is not much I can do in this situation. Once again, I thank you all for y…
-
Hi All..... I am sorry for the confusion and frustration as I have had a direct family member pass away after an incident that happened. Judging was half completed before this occured but as I hope you can all understand, I have been a bit preoccupi…
-
WELL OVER THE DUE DATE. SO NO MORE ENTRIES ALLOWED. @TrippleBoggey3, @Gelectrode is right, it was decided that you could either post it on here and ask someone to make it for you or PM someone to do so. I will have to take some time to judge so if y…
-
@KJMartin, sorry to be harsh but gotta say no. That defeats the whole purpose of no editing.
-
@Animist, thanks for that idea. So if anyone wants to do that, message anyone who is nominating to help out and do your best. If you are doing it this way, just post a notice on this discussion, especially if it is close to closing, just so I know t…
-
Shoot..... Forgot about mobile......Give me a moment ill think around this.
-
@strongbelieves, it does not work that way, sorry mate. You didn't enter a card which was your choice and you were eliminated in that round. Plus your card is not new so it wouldn't qualify anyway.
-
This discussion is now closed.
-
Sorry for how long this took but as I mentioned, there was a lot to think about and I had the tough decision of DQ'ing 4 cardsmiths who actually entered (most so far). SO RESULTS ARE: THOSE GETTING DQ'd @Lujikul @IanLowenthal @TheFriendlyGeek @M…
-
I leave for 2 days on a small holiday and BAM, the group goes mental. OFFICIALLY CLOSED FOR JUDGING......give me a couple of days, @Arceus8523 has made this job harder then my life currently. RESULTS POSTED SOON.
-
LESS THEN 24HRS TO GO!!!!!
-
@IanLowenthal, no it won't be. Just the 2 before.
-
@IanLowenthal, you will be disadvantages by it when it comes to judging but yes, edit the cards.
-
@Corwinnn, thanks for the clarification. @TheFriendlyGeek, I was getting confused for the fact if you look next to your entries they all say they have been edited from the original post.
-
@TheFriendlyGeek, all entries have edited against them. @thenightbringer, even if that is true, in a comp where "no editing" is a rule, a message to me just clarifying if that is ok is probably needed otherwise situation such as this will occur.
-
same with @thenightbringer
-
@TheFriendlyGeek.......so what happened to NO EDITING. Your 3 entries now no longer count.
-
@Tutlaschk. Sorry mate. I purposely did that so that you had to be careful with your cards. NO EDITING.
-
The normal 3 entries as usual. Sorry @TastyCheez. @KimJongMartin, The competition is ongoing but this is a new challenge. Sorry as well @Lujikul.
-
I know once my no.1 cardsmith contest is done, @VinylVantasy and I are going to create like a season competition where points are given out every round to whoever enters and at the end of the designated time (e.g. 6 months) whoever has the most poin…
-
This discussion is now closed.