MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Callous
About
- Username
- Callous
- Joined
- Visits
- 987
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Maringam Done. Not UP, not OP. Not good, nor bad. Average?
-
@Omnipleuvre Done. Interesting card, to say. I could rant on hours on hours about cards like those because they use rarely-touched design space - Interesting link to say at least, thanks for that.
-
@Zicreator I commented, but I don't get the card - Please elaborate in the comment section of the card, thanks.
-
@Omnipleuvre Feel free to bypass my "rules" for now, I thought there would be more responses. Though keep it to one card per response, but feel free to make a new response as soon as I have commented on the most recent one - Helps me keep things c…
-
@zachhammer-huber Please don't advertise your challenges here, it's needless clutter.
-
@BlaizOwlstaff Here's my entry: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ayah-davies-unbridled#.VP8oRZ-Ft2A I didn't find myself much inspired by the two others. Maybe someone else can come up with something good for them.
-
So Ayah is literally an elemental that's an elemental mage? I'm not sure what "your typical mage" really is, but I assume Arcane energies and mostly attuned to ones own purposes without being strictly "good" nor "evil". Sure, can work with that.
-
Not to rain on your parade, but it's super hard to construct cards from just a proper noun - Let's say you asked us to make a card called "Strike from beyond", we would sort of have an idea of where to go from. Do you have any lore you could add a…
-
@Looverse I commented. I liked the card overall but it has a few shortcomings, in my opinion.
-
@FunnyCardsAndStuff I commented. Feel free to discuss my points with me, here or on the cards.
-
My entry: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/with-extreme-prejudice#.VP5MlJ-Ft2A Not sure how I feel about the cards cost reduction clause, but it made sense to me.
-
Bunch of good stuff has already been said, so I'm not going to bother, but here's my perspective on things. Whenever you make a card, ask yourself "Is this card fun for both parties involved/Does this card breed good gameplay"? If no, should prob…