MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
ChainsawXIV
About
- Username
- ChainsawXIV
- Joined
- Visits
- 219
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Edit: I totally missed that this was closed already. My bad. Had fun making the cards anyway though, so fun contest. Good luck all! And a few un-set cards, not for consideration, but shared for fun:
-
I hadn't really considered that, but oak was definitely my gut response as well.
-
@sanjaya666 (and everyone else) while you are of course free to comment on people's cards, please keep your feedback polite and constructive. Name calling and pejorative language is not acceptable sportsmanship in this competition, and will result …
-
You need to remove the parenthesis @mlg20555.
-
Cool @bnew07 - I haven't gone through the full sets for each mechanic (that's a ton of cards, lol), but definitely have some suggestions that came to mind reading these. Love to have any feedback or suggestions on mine as well, of course. For the …
-
Some cool concepts there @bnew07 - you want suggestions or anything?
-
You need to remove the parenthesis @Eavae
-
I'd prefer cards be shown in the post @fraziel, since that makes it easier for everyone to browse, but I won't be strict about it. That said, your link isn't working.
-
The concepts for these were broadly pulled from the themes of the different Magic colors. To start with I put together a bit of art direction for Finn where I outlined common concepts, creature types, phenomenon, and so forth, as well as some refere…
-
I love this kind of thing, so this gave me lots of inspiration. Let's kick this off! Narrative-wise, my assumption here is that the remaining guilds will end up on the side of Bolas in one form or another, so I tried to capture that, but I also wan…
-
Some very interesting concepts so far guys! That said, I would recommend some proof-reading - remember that technical quality and attention to detail are part of the criteria for the contest, so stuff like standard rules wording and mechanical viabi…
-
Feel free to reskin your older cards.
-
They're Guilds of Ravnica boosters, fixed the first post - sorry for the confusion. Too much calling it "return to return to Ravnica" I guess.
-
I haven't actually made the avatar yet, so feel free to make suggestions if you like. I'll definitely post it and add it to the first post when it's ready.
-
Dominaria lies at the center of all things, but none more so than history itself. Nearly every entity and event of note in the grand tale of the multiverse pivots upon this axis, and as such it is only fitting that when you pivot this card, you can …
-
Not knowing whether my stuff was missed or just didn't win, I may be biased, but I'd suggest just handing out a few extra awards - if there are stand-out pieces you overlooked, call them out in a post, do some likes and follows, etc. and call it goo…
-
An elegant way to solve for that would be to make these effects "When you cast..." instead of triggering them on entering the battlefield. That does have the added effect of making the effect basically impossible to counter though, so you'd want to …
-
-
A cycle of one mana 0/1 Advisors, each of which changes the basic rules for all artifacts in play. Themed as bureaucrats and business people in the service to various guilds.
-
-
Timely! I've been thinking about what might make an interesting commander for spiders recently after sharing others' disappointment with the legendary spider in the new commander set.