MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Commando
About
- Username
- Commando
- Joined
- Visits
- 966
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
This is the most recent card I made for the 13th of Friday in November of 2020. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/skittering-horror-3
-
@Ral1000 Thanks. It may be a while until I host another challenge so I can take time and learn how to judge a contest under more fair precedents and rules. I will still participate in any since challenges can be super fun!
-
@Corwinnn I give permission to @Ranshi to rejudge the contest.
-
@TenebrisNemo I will do this in order to make a more balanced form of judging. Thank you for your time and patience and I sincerely apologize for my improper method of judging.
-
@TenebrisNemo Would you like me to make a new process judging these cards that gives everyone a chance? Because I will gladly do it.
-
@shadow123 I'm really glad that you enjoyed this challenge even though my method of judging the cards was flawed. I will take a break from making another challenge so I can improve on making better challenges and better scoring methods so I will be …
-
@Everyone I'm sincerely sorry about how I judged this contest. I am new to making a circuit challenge and should have talked to more experienced smiths and done more research on how to judge a contest. I hope this does not hurt my relationships wit…
-
The circuit challenge has ended. Here are the results of the challenge based on the number of favorites the card had and how mechanically unique they were. I hope you all had fun and if you didn't get top 3 remember, there is always another challeng…
-
@SNAPcreator7 Whoops! thought this was just for Halloween themed cards of any kind.
-
I made a card based on the Iconic Scream series of Ghostface. I didn't know what to change since there was an itch telling me to correct something but I would like a second thought on it. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ghostface-sly-butcher-1
-
Just a reminder for all participants, This forum closes on October 11 at 11:59 standard eastern time. So get your submissions in before it's over!
-
@SNAPcreator7 Thank you this is very helpful information. Is The custom mechanics forum is still open because I have a few ideas?
-
@jicklemania2 nice cards but I have a question, what does the "sharpen" mechanic do?
-
Growth vs. Destruction: the decks would be mono-red and mono-green with a theme. (sorry if you have already seen this idea elsewhere or it already exists.) Red: Would basically be focused around burn damage and hasty creatures but also ramp. Gree…
-
Wow!, these cards are coming along wonderfully. And I think I might already have my eye on a first-place card. Fear not, there are still 26 days before it ends so keep on making cards!
-
I'm new to the forums but I think these cards could get some more attention. Note: Hellar is heavily inspired by Kailia of the vast And Oni Sharpshooter was referenced by Goblin sharpshooter just as a head's up. Here are the links to each of t…
-
@Animist Thank you for submitting a card. I kinda thought this would be a no show but hey, at least someone showed up.
-
@Potato13 Restored back to its formal glory, but I changed its mana cost a bit to "balance" the card. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/molten-simulacrum-3
-
@Potato13 I thought the original card was busted since you were able to use its ability as soon as it attacked and it dealt a pretty good chunk of damage when it died. I will get back my old Molten Silamacrum if that would be a good solution. it is …
-
@Bradster2002 Fixed the card, I still wanted it to do something unique without being too busted. Let me know if I got it right. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/molten-simulacrum-2
-
I'm new to the forum's and would like some opinions. @Temurzoa I like the party creature idea but I'm wondering if they will have different party types like an Elf party, Zombie party, or even a Merfolk party. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/molten-…
-
@Revan yeah that's very helpful thanks.
-
I'm new to the forums and would like to submit a card. I would really love some criticism. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/voracious-eye-horror
-
@Corwinnn thank you for your hospitality
-
I fixed my Bayou so it could make more sense https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blighted-bayou-1
-
I'm new to Cardsmith and would like a second opinion. what does everyone think?