MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
DomriKade
About
- Username
- DomriKade
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,970
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
My attempt for @HeroKP based on Panglacial Wurm: Whenever you transfigure a creature, while you're searching your library, you may put ~ from your library onto the battlefield. It's probably worth having a cost since a single transfiguration could …
-
@Faiths_Guide I'm a bit late to the party, but I'll drop in my two cents. I'm partial to Dominaria for the simple nekoru comparison - it'd be feasible to see this as a 'northern' variant on the existing cat dragon paradigm, but if you're looking for…
-
Looking forward to another one of these - it’s great to see how others approach the task! Is there any specific theme or prompt?
-
As someone who really loves counters, I'd caution you to not include more than one counter type in your set if at all possible. Even +1/+1 counters and chip counters would be difficult to distinguish on creatures and can lead to lots of on-board con…
-
@ningyounk Thrilled for the ongoing progress on this set! Are you doing any playtest activities or is that mostly 'in-house?' Also, what's the best way to submit ideas should we come across them?
-
Every now and again I sneak in and provide comments on recent cards and I forget to let you know. @madstokie and @Temurzoa - I dropped some thoughts on your respective card pages.
-
Entries 1 & 2 - Greed and Gluttony respectively
-
Wow! Thanks for the recognition! Congrats to all the other winners and participants as well. Echoing what others have said, @ningyounk - you've run an amazing event. Well done! I have a small set of cards of mine I like but it's most exciting when …
-
Commons (Constraint 1: Exclusive subtype - Dinosaur - Rummaging Raptor) Uncommons (Constraint 2: Named character - Vona's Sargent) Rare
-
I quite enjoyed WAR, but from a judge standpoint it created a lot of opportunities for players to make mistakes. I love complex boardstates but it's not easy to balance or craft in a way that's also fun to play. Time Spiral block ran into this in th…
-
I'll take Ixalan
-
Entries, in order:
-
I couldn't find the more extended discussion on Masterwork in my cursory look through the thread but I had a few thoughts - forgive me if I double back on what you've already done! The more I think about Masterwork the more I think about Soulbond. I…
-
Spirits of Innistrad Spirits on Innistrad historically haven't had a strong factional identity save that you generally want to play some number of them together. I leaned into the practical nature of Spirits by creating a mechanic that reflects thei…
-
@strongbelieves - Glad you're tackling this topic! I regularly find myself turned off of playing EDH simply because cards like the ones on your list bog down the game or eradicate the option for players to do the things they want to do. I'm in acco…
-
I suppose I finally ought to do one of these challenges! I'd like to do WU spirits, potentially branching into B but Ill confirm. If you feel that'd be too close to @Ranshi922 's Orzhov let me know and I'll consider something else.
-
Theros had always been home. Rather, Theros had been Io's home while he was alive and corporeal. Spending countless days in the Starfield of Nyx had robbed much of the joy and familiarity from the plane. Each time the globe rotated beneath him, he …
-
12 for me
-
@DoctorFro - I commented on the card pages.
-
I'll echo @KJMartin - I'm not sure if I've missed the deadline but I'll give it a shot if you'll still have me. As a thief hellbent on proving his worth, Io set about plundering a treasure from the gods. There are many such treasures, but most re…
-
Not me necessarily, but the character I'll be for the trip: Name: Reza Species: Human (presumably) Origin: This is the Planar Bus? Looks a bit slipshod for something that's supposed to handle the ravages of the Blind Eternities. You're sure this c…
-
Entries No. 1-4 Feedback is always welcome - feel free to drop your thoughts on the card page.
-
It's difficult to parse down inspiring cards into a small list. There are several other 'Smiths that have really impacted my time here but I've tried to grab a representative swatch from the different ways I've interacted with this site. I've linked…
-
@Faiths_Guide I'd posit that it doesn't trigger itself. The ability doesn't exist until the card is on the battlefield and your devotion would already be at its new value. There's never a moment where your devotion changes once the ability is in pla…
-
It's almost midnight for me, so... Entry No. 1 - Simic Entry No. 2 - Rakdos
-
@ningyounk The way it's phrased currently, the lands are tapped during the process of casting the spell (CR 601.2h specifically). The person casting the spell would still be acting with their own priority and the opponent wouldn't be able to respond…
-
@Tomigon It seems functional to me, but not fun to play against. If we use Delve as an example (CR 702.65), it would technically read: For each generic mana in this spell's total cost, you may tap an untapped land you don't control rather than pay t…
-
Entry No. 1
-
Entry No. 1 - WB Enchantment I started playing just before Theros block was released so I developed a love for auras as a 'young' player. Armament of Nyx was my inspiration here, a situational attachment that could benefit you or hinder an opponent…
-
I'll throw my hat in the ring.