MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
FangQuil
About
- Username
- FangQuil
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,063
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Voted!
-
* Circuit Breaker: Challenge 1 or more cardsmiths to receive a random "Circuit" Challenge prompt for an entry. I'll judge and the winner receives a sweet prize. @jpastor I'd be happy for you to pick the other challengers! If you'd rather I choose…
-
Got it, thanks for taking the time to clear things up!
-
Wait, so can you clarify where I ultimately placed? It says 3rd in the bracket, but in @jpastor’s results announcement TheKeefMan is both the Grand Runner Up and 3rd place? I’m definitely missing something lol
-
(Hacker Voice) "I'm IN."
-
Hey @Chipatola! Congrats on your first foray into card design! Here are my thoughts on what you have currently: * The way Transcendent works feels a bit off. For abilities similar to what you seem to want, like Threshold and Domain, the names are …
-
@jpastor I'd love more feedback too if possible!
-
@jpastor Here's my entry for @Hergusbergus's moshpit challenge:
-
@jpastor Great to see the videos again! Love the feedback! Just for fun, here’s some of the context around Vincent: He was the Lord of the Pit to whom Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar was indebted. Instead of her soul, she bet that she could provid…
-
@cadstar369 Cool card! I'm typically not a big fan of cards that mess with exile, both because I don't think it should become the "second graveyard" and because it can have some weird/broken interactions. That said, I think this one threads the need…
-
@FireOfGolden What Sweda and ShadowReign have pointed out is by far the biggest issue with the card, but as they've already covered that, and there is more to speak about, I'll skip it. The card could use a bit of rewording, I'd have it as follows:…
-
Here's a pair:
-
@Sweda Very nice card! Flavor is very on-point, but there's not a lot to comment on design-wise. Seems well-balanced, and the formatting is good, though it'd be nice to see a line between the keywords and the next block of text, and a line separatin…
-
Bump
-
@Globert-the-Martian Cool card! I'm not a big fan of skulk, but I think this card makes good use of it. The decision of whether or not to use a buff spell on this guy, gaining extra advantage from double strike, but opening it up to being blocked wo…
-
@Jonteman93 Two questions: 1. If we make a double-faced card, can we have the transform condition be contingent on an event in the story? i.e. getting bit by a vampire and transforming into a vampire, or dying and coming back as a spirit. 2. If our …
-
Keeping the Poe train rolling!
-
Any Edgar Allan Poe fans? I went with "Harvesttide" instead of "Halloween" to fit in with Innistrad flavor, hope that's acceptable!
-
This one's a bit strange "P" represents a poison counter btw, not especially relevant for this contest, but it's a theme in the set I'm working on that this card is a part of.
-
@Temurzoa Very well-designed and interesting card! Good job including the "and graveyard" clause necessary for the exile effect. I'm still not 100% sure it'd fully work as intended within the rules, since the exile is a replacement effect, there's s…
-
IN - C division, please
-
Thanks for the amazing work @Tomigon!
-
@Tomigon Could you replace the face of this imp... ...with the unit circle
-
This one's kinda weird, but eh Atogatog image links to a list of all the Atogs for context.
-
Here are my entries: Links are embedded
-
Here's my card:
-
My (first?) entry:
-
@jpastor Another box, please!
-
@AboveAndAbout I'll participate!
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos I like it! As you say, it's a pretty simple tutor, so there's not much for me to comment on, but the reference to Dark Confidant is sweet, and the mindgame possibilities with an instant foretell tutor are interesting. If I'm go…