MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
FireOfGolden
About
- Username
- FireOfGolden
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,667
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@spookoops Because five cards were tied out, I think.
-
@smax765 Nah, phasing means "This permanent phases out or phases in before your untap step." I don't think planewalker's ability can be activated before the untap step, so I would say it's fair. While phased out permanent is treated by game as if …
-
@jpastor Please entertain me about how did Earthshaker took so much damage to rating in Cardsmith League than here. I believe that if I learned about that, I would improve my judge system and make it less generous when possible. ? @ShadowReign Yo…
-
@TheDarkKnight1234567 While you wait for response from em, you can challenge for another battle. My recommendation is set your limit to only three battles, but you can go over it, if ya like. (By the way, who said I couldn't be challenged anyway?)
-
(One time counter)
-
@smax765 @jpastor (Spoiler) And winner is... (Spoiler)
-
@cadstar369 Well, I need be carefully with my grammar, do I?
-
@cadstar369 And you could defend that spell only needed a land sacrificed, and Mountains is a subtype to a Basic land. Hence, requirement is met. If I want it to be only a land, not something like a Mountains, I would do something like this; Card …
-
Let's play a quick game! Here's a requirement; Spell must require a land sacificed to cast it. If someone made this; "In additional to cast [Name], sacifice a Mountain." Does they break requirement?
-
Wenkman would take a peek in a small room to see any whether it's useful to him or not.
-
@jaceberlin I already gave a feedback to Asphyixate before submitting a card. Are you saying that I should give a review again before doing so? I agree with you on second ability, but as for light creature, if I rephrase this "Light creatures have…
-
@smax765 No problem! I would like a feedback on this card as well; (Light creatures cannot be target of nonpermanent black cards.)
-
@smax765 Asphyixate is just colorless verison of Lava Coil, but it's common and instant... And targets planewalker as well. I would say everything are balanced. If you make it uncommon, you can have it exile creature/planewalker when it dies to th…
-
Gotcha, thanks! I will remember that next time I make something like that.
-
@LvB @cadstar369 I will go for; Portable Black Hole enters the battlefield tapped. {1},{t}: When this ability is put on the stack, Portable Black Hole gains protection from everything until end of turn. Exile all nonland permanents. I prefer to …
-
@cadstar369 That's what am I looking for! Thanks!
-
@LvB That is the point. This should be once effect, not more than that. My intention was make it inevitable to exile all that no one can stop it. Normally, when someone taps to trigger something, another person can just either counter that or stop…
-
@smax765 While you wait for jpastor to submit a card, you can challenge another person while a battle is going on. I wouldn't go over three battles at once, but if you want, you can.
-
@TheDarkKnight1234567 @Robo_Kitty Would you like to redraw for different requirements, or you just need some time to think of what to make a card? Remember, no rush. This battle have no deadline ?
-
@jpastor Hi there! Smax765 has submitted a card and you haven't for a week. I know you are busy with others, but I just pinging you to remind ya, so you wouldn't forgot about this battle. ?
-
@LvB Okay, thank you for feedback! I will put another card here for feedback, then I will wait until someone posts card to get a feedback. Basically like Nevinyrral's Disk, but exiles all nonland permanents.
-
@jpastor Hit me one box.
-
@LvB So should I reduce the mana cost or alter the second ability to make it balanced? Or it's fine the way it is?
-
@jpastor Nope, until you say it. ?
-
-
@kaoz42 Frenzied Saddlebrute twisted my brain when I read it. So, I had to read it a few time then I finally understood what it means. Basically, all creatures can attack controller's opponents as soon as they entered the battlefield. ? Ink blesse…
-
@smax765 Initiate's Spellpierce is simple and good. The only issue here is rarity itself. A blue called Spell Pierce which costs for one mana. It will counter a noncreature spell and its controller must pay two to keep it. That way is similar as In…
-
@LvB Elf represents Wenkman, Orc represents someone who cares but then is confused by Figure races as they look exactly same (Mostly). Female human represents someone who don't care at all or already met a Figure like Wenkman before.
-
Here's some cards and updated Wenkman; (Spoiler)
-
@jpastor Is it community's turn now, or the Foe have one more turn left?