MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Frostbvrn
About
- Username
- Frostbvrn
- Joined
- Visits
- 574
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Speaking of which, here's my village.
-
@FireKing661, I love what you're doing with stretching the prompts. This is what I wanted people doing.
-
You're welcome, @FireKing661. What I try to do for cards made by other people is use constructive criticism to make the cards better, more balanced, and/or worded better. Whenever I do so, though, it's never meant to be "This is better, you should d…
-
@ThePhantomJoker, the stuff feralitator sent is really useful for that kind of stuff, but yeah, you can use a different RPG game for it.
-
Yeah that's fine. If you have multiple ideas for one prompt, go ahead. Really all this is for is to give people ideas for cards every day, and see the differences between cards that are alike because of a theme.
-
True. I was going to make it green at first, but the art said red-white to me.
-
@MemoryHead, yeah. I probably should have worded it as one of the two ways you said. There just hasn't been any landfall lands in the past, and the official wording for Landfall is "Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control" so I jus…
-
@Ranshi, it was mostly just for the flavour of the art. A valley between mountains, farmland or not, would be red-white.
-
Day 1: Landfall Landfall. On a land. MTGCS card here: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/farmland-valley
-
@FireKing661, that's neat! Though, for the X+1 thing, it may be better if it was worded as: "Moss-Rot Lich enters the battlefield with X rot counters on it, where X is equal to the amount of green mana spent to cast this spell plus one." I'm pr…
-
Really, all of these can easily be up for interpretation. They're not extremely specific.
-
@Ranshi, for the request, sure go ahead. For "An utterly awful card", it can be something like a vanilla 3/3 for 5. Pretty much something that is unplayable in almost any circumstance.
-
Yeah of course. The rules aren't tight, they're mostly just guidelines to keep everyone organized.
-
Thanks!
-
Sure, @ThePhantomJoker! If you don't mind though, could you recreate the cards on MtGCardsmith to? That way I'll be able to add your cards to the year 2 set.
-
Sure, go ahead, @Ranshi! There's not really any strict rules for this, it's just for fun. If you want to remake cards for it, feel free to.
-
That's absolutely amazing.
-
Glad to have you! But no, it doesn't happen every year. I did this last year for the first time and some people liked it, so I did it again!
-
I forget how to put them side-by-side, so this works for now lol.
-
I'm back! I see this is being used again.
-
UHg. I have to pick my favourite card I made? Oh, I have no idea. Maybe I should just pick my most popular card, "Goblin Dentist." Yeah, sure. I like it. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/goblin-dentist-10 Now for my favourite made by someone else…
-
Oko, Ascended Ban was your card from .design
-
@Ranshi, I see some of your cards are named differently from the .design ones. Thanks tho!
-
Hey again everyone. The set is right here, and I'll be favouriting all the cards put into this challenge. Set: https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Frostbvrn/sets/47969
-
Thank you all for doing this! I'm glad you all liked it. I'll be doing this again next year (hopefully because something might come up or I might just stop mtgcs but that's highly unlikely.) Tomorrow I'll be making a collection over on my profile wi…
-
Day 30 (missed it yesterday, so here it is): Day 31, "Celebration" (final dayyyyy!): Have a great new years everyone!!
-
WE HIT 100 FAVES ON IDEA BROKER!
-
Day 29:
-
@benw... That doesn't really seem like an un-card
-
Day 28: Land Destruction by eldrazi so doesn't destroy them but turns them to wastes.