MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Globert-the-Martian
About
- Username
- Globert-the-Martian
- Joined
- Visits
- 4,729
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
A holiday icon: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/jolly-papa-snobbygrots i might rework this at some point
-
Some say that the scariest spook of them all is the unknown
-
@ShadowReign nice card! It seems balanced enough, and the mechanic of sacrificing creatures for keywords is interesting. It does bother me that on its own it does not benefit from the second ability when you use the cull the herd mechanic, but it st…
-
@jpastor I believe you looked at the wrong page friendo
-
@KorandAngels Should be: (tap): Draw a card. Ruin Haunter deals 1 damage to itself and 1 damage to you. I like The flavor of this, but this is much too powerful for a common, especially for black. (for reference, see Archivist: https://gatherer…
-
@prismgodz the text definitely needs to be reworked. @SPyBondPlays had some good ideas (that do not appear overpowered), but if you want to make it exactly as is, it would be something like this: Rebellious— you may ignore spells or abilities that…
-
For @crawdadswelcome, I tried to mimic some of their common themes, including a marshy setting, obscure/archaic words in the title, and unique custom keywords. All that’s missing is their fantastical art style (and perhaps a duck or two). https…
-
How goes the judging?
-
@SPyBondPlays commented. For mine, see my previous.
-
Nephiteus says NO to burn decks: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/nephiteus-the-final-gasp
-
@Suleman Nice mechanic! I personally prefer the first one. It’s more versatile, and while it’s comparatively harder to keep track of, I don’t think it’s inconvenient enough to be an issue. One nitpick on this particular card is that deathtouch shoul…
-
@pokespriter Hmm… a repeatable land removal effect would be quite powerful, so it would need some hefty balancing. But at turn 10 it probably wouldn’t be worth it for 10 mana each. I think if you removed the mana for the activation cost, and maybe l…
-
(Deleted)
-
Challenge: create a card inspired by a song from the mystery box Spotify playlist Based on Smooth Criminal, by Alien Ant Farm: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/aaf-glib-outlaw
-
@LeBateauIvre I really like this one! Starting at its basic stats, a four mana 2/5 with menace and deathtouch seems like a great investment, as it will likely trigger a two for one, or at the very least a significant removal spell to deal with i…
-
@Temurzoa looks great! I really like the scary synergy. I can’t find anything I’d change. here’s mine: I’m going to remake this one anyway, since I forgot to credit the artist. Should I downgrade it to a sorcery, or is it fine as is? Any other crit…
-
On a lighter note (well, mostly), here’s my second entry!https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cursed-candy-pot
-
Here’s my first entry: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/masked-maniac I assume @sorinjace meant eerie, as in strange or frightening, as opposed to Erie, the city in northwest Pennsylvania
-
@Faiths_Guide favorited. Nice job! I like the designs of both, and your artwork is incredible! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/dormant-champions
-
Alright, I’ll give this a shot. IN probably C for me
-
@Titanium000 The character itself is a fun concept (it personally reminds of Rincewind, the Ill-fated wizard from the Discworld novels), though it’s a tricky one to put into card form. You need to find the balance between the risk and reward. At th…
-
@Zaheer_The_Grim I know you said we don’t have to say anything, but out of respect for the forum I’ll do it anyway. The card seems balanced enough, and I think the repeatable take vengeance effect works well with with its cost and stats. I’d imagin…
-
@brcien I’d imagine this would be an extremely irritating card to play against, but I don’t see anything particularly wrong with it. Nice job! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/woodlands-retribution?list=user
-
Egad! Another blunder! Ah well
-
I decided to give a shot at digital art this year. I’m not the greatest, but I’d like to think I’m not terrible either. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/gorvul-the-twisted In hindsight I think if I were to change it, I would make it start off w…
-
@CS101 I like this one. I’m trying to find something to critique it on, but I keep coming up on blanks. I’d imagine it would be fun to play. Nice job! here’s mine: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/avlor-vengeful-revenant-1
-
@CS101 I love investigate, and seeing a planeswalker based on it is really neat! I like the first two abilities, but I’m not really a fan of the third. At -10 it would likely never actually be able to activate, and in a lot of instances it probably …
-
@stormbreath very cool! Its ability is both interesting and powerful. If I were to nitpick I think I’d shorten the text to “Whenever this creature attacks alone, it gains +3/+2 and must be blocked this turn if able.” Also samurai should be capitaliz…
-
My fourth entry aka Morbid fuel: https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/omen-of-death-5
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/audrey-2-1?list=set&set=52865 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/thwarthog?list=set&set=52865 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/legion-revenant?list=set&set=52865 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/avlor-vengeful-revena…