MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Grimshac
About
- Username
- Grimshac
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,343
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Boomfat Good question. If you make a Planeswalker, the Defender part should be central to the card, so I think the ult and/or the general theme of the card should relate to the whole defender thing, like summoning a 0/4 Wall token for the +1 and t…
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/remove-from-forum
-
Any prizes?
-
My entry: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ethersworn-forcemage
-
@LONEvvolf Okay, dumb question time: Does it have to be a creature? I know you said "make a creature" but I'm wondering if you simply didn't think about other card types at the time. I have this wicked idea for a sorcery, but I'm wondering if I ca…
-
@Angry_Potatoes Contest has been over for 5 days
-
@Kiloken People have been extremely bad at closing out their own contests recently.
-
@Cryptonight OH right, we were talking about Dread summoner and not Ghoulcaller Skaab. Right. Yea, dread summoner is extremely broken - Looks like something really, really old that WotC would've made back in Alpha or The Dark. Not to mention the c…
-
@IanLowenthal I didn't quite catch that last part. And I completely agree on the "broken" thing, by the way. Dread Summoner was one of the best entries in my opinion and shouldn't be removed by any margin. But the first card is still "meh" and i…
-
@Faiths_Guide It was SO EXCLUSIVE that it couldn't even have a conclusion! Imagine that! Didn't you know Weekly challenges last 2 months ?
-
@Biblio Very funny. Those are old cards, and one of them is from Unhinged. You know what I mean. Up to modern standards.
-
@Faiths_Guide Not unless you want to - It doesn't violate any rules
-
@datmtgplayer Both - I did tag you for the message, didn't i? It has to have realistic art that looks MtG-like
-
@datmtgplayer Except your entry is invalid due to the art ._.
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/in-memoriam
-
@Noahtheboah36 @Faiths_Guide Thanks - commented.
-
@Cadstar369 @FatTaft I commented on the entries
-
@MrRansom Seemingly so, lol. Which is odd, because not that many spirit Defenders exist. Maybe it's because it's the easiest to find art for that fits, or because "ghosts" are known to haunt/guard places?
-
@biblio1 @NoahtheBoah36 @datmtgplayer and many others. I thought it was a given, but then again, I did forget to leave it out: Realistic art, please. I don't accept submission with nonMtG-like art. Sorry.
-
@Cadstar369 I commented on your cards, now that I understood the mechanic clearly.
-
@cadstar369 hahahaha. Sorry bro, but when you're as excited as I was when Starfield of Nyx was spoiled, the first thing you do is to make a deck that works around it Sorry @Supermunkie1 alright, thanks, now it makes sense :P
-
@Supermunkie1 but that still doesn't explain to me what it does when it's a keyword on a card ._.
-
@SuperMunkie1 You may wanna write out what Unnatural Thirst does, otherwise the cards fall flat on their bottom :z
-
@Cryptonight There are more than a few entries in the winning list that don't seem to fully qualify nor stand out, so well, I'd say the judging was a little inconsistent. Good contest, anyway. Lot's of entries and it was fun participating.
-
@Corwinnn Thanks for reminding me. UPDATE: Must be new cards, or cards that received relatively low amounts of favorites or none at all. Don't want people to win off of older, already acknowledged cards Try again !
-
@TheClayKnight Now I'm curious. Go for it. Please.
-
Stale. The cardbase is tiny and it has no real "intricacies" that I love in MtG (The stack, for example). Only playing on your turn, you can "go face" and ignore the opposing creatures. Don't know. I tried three times to get into it because it's ver…
-
Bump.
-
@Boomfat Rules and frames never bound me. I have unlimited power!
-
@Faiths_Guide I'm starting to think there isn't going to be one, sadly