MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Grimshac
About
- Username
- Grimshac
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,343
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
This looks like a great opportunity to promote quality over quantity in general. Please consider your entries twice, guys. GL to both teams! For team nature: http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Grimshac/sets/5497 - I'm aware they are human, but it fits so…
-
@TheClayKnight :O!
-
@Daragonion That definitely looks... better. I'm still conflicted, though. Now it _just_ seems useless, or like a giant gamble. Imagine you're playing Troll Worship and you accidentally exile a Worship ._. Ouch. Perhaps it could exile a card, and …
-
From a competitive point of view, they are either useless or broken, as far as I'm concerned. For the decks that wants to discard and do graveyard shenanigans, they're godsend. For everyone else, they're card disadvantage, which means they would ne…
-
@Mtgcardsmith The editing thing is definitely the most attractive thing on the board. Honest to god. It would help so much, and it would also make people more susceptible to feedback and it would make giving the feedback a lot easier knowing that p…
-
@TheClayKnight Cards don't need to be complex to be worth talking about ! I did my review, btw. Decently long one too. Looks like it is awaiting approval since I may have snuck a "bad word" in there by accident... <.< God damn disqus.
-
@IanLowenthal the link works for me, though? anyone else having trouble? http://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Grimshac/sets/5373 I don't mind you rejecting the banner. It's fine. I wouldn't want to remove the other races, it would just lose so much of …
-
@Azeois Try once more, I'm sure you'll get it right now ! For real though. It's a contest about inventing a _new UB evergreen keyword_ not about making vanilla creatures.
-
@Azeois Read the original post again, you missed a fairly crucial part
-
@IanLowenthal I suppose that's correct. I thought we were making stuff that would be good for zombie tribal. That card would make zombie tribal more competitive than ever, but, as you say, it is not specifically representing zombies. I won't be ch…
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/banner-of-the-deathless?list=user
-
An update from my side: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vile-amalgamation
-
Bump
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/templar-of-the-quiet-moon-1?list=user http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/muse-of-the-moor Just trying to add some utility to zombie tribal
-
Do they have to be mono-black or part black, or are we allowed to branch out? Just wondering seeing as 322 out of almost 380 zombies in printed MtG are black
-
@Seanabit He's asking you to remake an old, but powerful/vastly played magic card from Modern, Legacy or Vintage, I.e. Black Lotus, Show and Tell, Taiga @koover Glimpse of Nature "fix" (I'm aware elves technically broke it and not itself, but mye…
-
@Nicholas_Bolas Well, exactly.
-
bump
-
@ChargingBadger I'm not sure where anger was came to life in my post - More like exasperation. Text leaves a lot up for interpretation by the reader, no doubt, but I was not at any point angry. @Nicholas_Bolas http://shop.tcgplayer.com/magic/khans…
-
@Emmastone Jesus. You don't understand the context of BoP at all, apparently. So you're saying that playing one card that taps for any mana + deals 1 damage to you is somehow "better" than playing a land and a creature, both of whom tap for mana, a…
-
@Emmastone ... Amidst the rambling that was that... interesting little tidbit, did you call birds of paradise "weak" ._.?
-
@Dragonion No trouble, my hope is that people will pay it forward, sooner or later
-
@Daragonion > Link one card at a time [sic]. Decide which you'd like me to look at first and I'll do that !
-
@AlphaOmega @CrucibleofHate Done and done!
-
@Tomigon Done, and thanks, but I fancy it would not be a great conversion rate for me, ahah.
-
Bumpity bump.
-
@Rednaxela @CrucibleofHate Done and done. Seems i triggered the language filter though, so responses might be delayed!
-
http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/kayla-the-capricious-1?list=user Hi.
-
@Nicholas_Bolas I assume "Imaginative" means creative in this case, and not... imaginary draw? Cause' that would be one hell of an abstract subject to work with ^^
-
Here you go: http://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spellscale-serpent Feeling good about that card.