MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Grimshac
About
- Username
- Grimshac
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,343
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Faiths_Guide We could work it into the circuit weekly challenges, so you'd provide art for one weekly challenge a month (bi-monthly?) if you wanted. Also, I can almost guarantee this, most people will be hoping for Tribal art for tribes that can b…
-
@Fabiocbinbutter Alright - Just checking. Since, lorewise, it would make sense for the player to have insanity counters too, though "going insane" doesn't mean a loss in the same way that poison says "ur dead = lose", so I was just wondering
-
When does it end? I might give it a shot but I need a few hours before I'll have time to sit down and think on an entry
-
@Corwinnn I might revive the project somewhere down the line - I believe I still have renders of most of the cards that were entered on my Imgur account
-
So a player him or herself can't have insanity counters?
-
@Suicidal_Deity Np brah, I'll just pair up with Cryptonight then
-
@Corwinnn Do you remember that "crowdfunded" set called Remora I tried to make like a year back? That was basically me attempting to do what you are suggesting, except it didn't have a proper structure and we didn't have the forum back then, so set…
-
Open the floodgates, ayy... Oh the humanity. I can only begin to imagine the entries to this :x
-
Spirit-Mad Berserker Here's a little something for competitively-minded folks. I'm sure that getting that kicker-cost in by turn three should be possible most of the time, and if not, then it makes it a better topdeck
-
Also, Cryptonight No one goes in-depth and explains stuff more closely than Cryptonight. Personally, every single one of my cards have a note in the comment section where I talk about the how and why I do the things I do with cards, if that's th…
-
@DomriKade I think you messed up the links... something is weird - None of the links in your post works, but I can click the original links and such
-
When's the deadline?
-
Uh... in what way? You mean on casting costs and such? Not even WotC does that, and I don't even think Magic Set Editor has that feature unless you're adept at crafting custom symbols. If you meant in general, well, nothing stops you from just wri…
-
You left? Hadn't noticed. Last I checked you were still in the MtG card database
-
New entry, replacing one of the other 5 that I scrapped because it was terrible: Councilerian
-
@DomriKade That would make two of us then ^^
-
@DomriKade That's the spirit.
-
@MrRansom I think that what you are suggesting is a good idea, actually. It is quite the undertaking indeed. We should ask ourselves; what is the purpose of a custom MtG-card site? There are many answers, and they are all correct, but the core of…
-
@Tomigon Oh. I thought those were rules, actually :P Well, glad to hear it. I wracked my brain quite a bit thinking the card up, so at least this amalgamation of a card can serve some purpose, haha. I swear I spent more time choosing which words …
-
@Fraziel07 You would've actually stood a better chance if you had omitted requital from the card I know it sucks to hear now, but I try not to lead people in too specific directions when I comment from a judging position. Requital is just quite s…
-
@Suicidal_Deity Indeed, a healthy amount of realism is required on this subject. Resources, both financially and manpower-wise, are real denominators here. Anyway - If I may paraphrase a tad, in good faith, of course: "People should not look at …
-
@MrRansom @Suicidal_Deity Indeed, and indeed. I personally tell people that if they find stuff they want to favourite, they can do so, but I never force them to actually do it. A favourite should remain a "favourite". Like I spoke to @Cryptonight a…
-
@Suicidal_Deity Indeed! So, anyway, I'm official keywording "Transmogoyf" and "Judge factor (1-4)". I personally like "Don't want to get it" a lot. Describes a lot of situations I've seen on here... well, in life in general, hah. I'm very honore…
-
@Fabiocbinbutter Suicidal and I are the "resident" judges so to speak, Domri and Cadstar asked to sit in, since I was looking for co-judges, but they it was only for this time around, as I am sort of testing the waters for a third judge, so I am ho…
-
@Faiths_Guide Thank you for participating! I'm glad you took the write-up on Subjugating Fire for what it was; Praise... and critique Rebound-contest for the next weekly after the monthly? Deal!
-
@Tomigon Would this card qualify? The Judge It uses some fairly rare words, such as "total", "targeted" and "win"/"lose". Not to mention it does some pretty unconventional things :P
-
The so-called "norod incident" has happened several times before, actually, but it's easy to spot at least. For this idea to work out we'd need some sort of quality-control or a way to "validate" contests, which requires a lot of admin work, which…
-
@Tomgion We had DomriKade and Cadstar369 in on a consultation-basis this time around, and we appreciate their thoughts as well
-
1st entry: a transformation card First side: Abandoned Wreck Transformed side: Dread Captain 2nd entry: Seasoned Privateer
-
About time for us to wrap to this up, sorry about the wait. It took quite a while this time around, because communication between judges can take a lot of time, which is something I will account for next time. Anyway, from the bottom and up! At f…