MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Jadefire
About
- Username
- Jadefire
- Joined
- Visits
- 12,438
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@12SidedGuy Your mystery box contains: * Prize 58: Raincheck. * A Mystery Challenge: Create an "Indentured" creature (i.e., an efficiently costed creature with a drawback that's favourable for your opponent).
-
@StuffnSuch The ability is cool and in the right colour. It's just extremely narrow and doesn't do anything on its own, so it seems overcosted at four mana and needlessly rare at mythical. I would recommend making it a rare and costing it at two t…
-
@jpastor Cool, I'll keep that in mind for the future. I guess the card ideas are going back into the vault for later.
-
A Mystery Challenge: create a flying creature with vigilance and toughness 1. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/sunwreath-firebird Time to claim some prizes: Pocketbook: Trade a favorite on one of my cards, for two favorites of your choice. -I favou…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create an artifact that's a staff. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/spire-of-denagon
-
@cadstar369 I get what you mean. For the longest time I was resistant to posting silver bordered cards. Something about wanting the collection to look more official.
-
A 3-Dimensional Shape - I'll choose octahedron.
-
Nice, same art set. Curating the dueling seven, I see. I guess it won't be a huge deal to fix the missing legendary border, if that's some thing you care to do.
-
@Ranshi You have to copy and paste it. Use this one: https://scheduler.leaguelobster.com/1235910/division-a/january-march-2023/
-
@jpastor I forgot about the crab. In that case, the Statue can go to the next person who posts a Mystery Box card.
-
@jpastor I believe Sculptures are built by you. Don't want you to get too bored with non-cardsmithing activities.
-
@LvB Simply addressing the wording of the card, it looks extremely complicated and in need of a lot of simplification. I'll offer some suggested wording changes while maintaining the flavour of the card. These will be ordered the same way as Arixm…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create the Power Puff Girls. Legendary creature cards. One of you takes Blossom, one of you takes Bubbles, and one of you takes Buttercup. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/buttercup-spicy-brawler Further explanation of the desig…
-
I'll take Buttercup.
-
@CosmicElder I agree that there's enough exiling done in black that you don't need to second guess making Beckon of the Abyss black or have to justify it in any way. The art, name, and flavour go together very well as is. What I actually find most…
-
@12SidedGuy Your mystery box contains: * A Mystery Challenge: Create a Tribal type Kithkin card that receives a bonus from other Kithkin you control.
-
@StuffnSuch Your mystery box contains: * Prize 2: Raincheck. * A Mystery Challenge: Create an Arcbound creature with an ability to gain additional +1/+1 counters.
-
@Zaheer_The_Grim welcome back! This is the last box that you received without a corresponding card, does this look familiar to you? https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/215452#Comment_215452
-
@Tommia That's good to know, you may need significantly fewer than 365 separate challenges then. Here are a few more to get you on your way. 1. A card where you need to note something for later reference. 2. An efficiently costed card whose only d…
-
@cadstar369 Sari Lumenweave is an interesting concept. Selesnya is exactly right for it, as stopping attacking creatures without direct confrontation is very white (E.g., Trap Runner, Kor Haven) and triggering on a blocked creature dealing damage t…
-
Since I see the work has been put into listing out all the creature types that only exist on tokens, I'll amend my original suggestion to say "one or more" to get the most out of that effort. (Also, Army from Amass seems to be missing from the list…
-
Wow, great matches @Ranshi and @theirintheattic! I didn't see that coming. Congratulations to the new Division A champion @12SidedGuy! That one I did see coming.
-
@jpastor Glad to be of service.
-
A card that turns a losing situation into a winning one (E.g., Laboratory Maniac) or a winning situation into a losing one (E.g., Transcendence).
-
I'll choose 4, 6, 15, and 31 from the emergency prompts. 1. A creature with a creature type that currently only exists on tokens. 2. A multicolored Trap card. 3. A card that causes players to vote but doesn't use Will of the council or Council's di…
-
@cadstar369 I can see the whole chaining one enchantment after another playstyle of Myriel to be like progressing through an epic. It works quite well with other "consumable" enchantments as well as removal Auras. Understanding the need to not mak…
-
Thanks @TenebrisNemo for hosting this contest and doing all the work of judging. No doubt it would've been a difficult task to choose from all of the entries. Feel free to put the likes on any of my cards that you enjoyed: https://mtgcardsmith.com…
-
@cadstar369 Myriel, Epic Enthusiast looks like a reasonable card. It seems made to be used with Sagas but can also be tailored to recoup potential card disadvantage from using Auras or enchantment-based removal. Selesnya's the right colour combina…
-
Encounter: A sleek vehicle whizzes past you as you are walking alone at night on the streets of a city. Create 5 cards indicating what happens next. Chapter 1 – https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/222968#Comment_222968 Cha…
-
There's nothing wrong with creating the card and only downloading the image of it at first for the secret Santa and then re-creating them for posting purposes after Dec 27.