MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Jadefire
About
- Username
- Jadefire
- Joined
- Visits
- 12,239
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@cadstar Keszi, Loam Reaper looks to be a balanced card. It does have a powerful effect, but the power of it comes incrementally, rather than all at once, which means having to establish (and then maintain) a stocked graveyard to really reap its be…
-
@cadstar369 True, Celestial Interference is a unique card that's entering a novel design space. The only cards that I can think of that have something to contribute to its wording are Benevolent Blessing for the protection part and Disarm and Fulge…
-
Now that I've seen Dorian and Locrian's abilities, I can see the intention behind Celestial Interference. However, the "permanents can't be prevented from being attached..." part of the card isn't necessary because of the way Dorian and Locrian wor…
-
@cadstar369 Dorian and Locrian are an interesting pair and I can see why they were originally created with the Partner with mechanic, rather than Mystic duet. Mystic duet seems like just a functional reprint of Partner that creates a separate pool …
-
@jpastor That sucks what happened with YouTube. That's a pretty heavy-handed approach to a channel that isn't even monetized. I like the short version of the card review.
-
@cadstar369 With a symmetrical third ability for Firestorm Pollen, I think you can make a much better argument for it to only cost two mana. Ah, I missed Hinata, Dawn-Crowned. I was sure Kopala was the inspiration You make a good point with M…
-
@cadstar369 looks like I've missed a lot of card reviews. Let's go all the way back to the first one I haven't given feedback on, Firestorm Pollen, since a lot was said but it doesn't sound like you got a satisfactory reason for the feedback you re…
-
Overdraft Charges Challenge: Create a creature that has a trigger upon blocking a creature. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vesuvan-time-trawler
-
Thanks @Astrophibian!
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/tirza-axis-of-collusion Conspire seems like it was an underused mechanic compared to something like Convoke that similarly lets you choose between using your creature for attacking/blocking or something else. The orig…
-
Congratulations @12SidedGuy, the design is straightforward and elegant.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/torrent-of-thought It may be splitting hairs, but I'm going to consider cost reduction and alternate costs to be different things. In case it wasn't obvious, the effect of Torrent of Thought counts itself when it reso…
-
Congratulations @LvB! The City in Between is a very original concept. @Robo_Kitty if there is a way to go infinite with Pool of Vitality and one other card, I haven't found it yet. But that's kind of how I designed it, to not give anyone a freebi…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create a card for Remy the Rat from Ratatouille. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/murine-gourmand
-
Movie Character/Creature: Remy the Rat from "Ratatouille" https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/murine-gourmand
-
Creature Subtype: Griffin https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/blessed-aegis
-
Thanks @Yururu for hosting this contest and for all your time generating feedback on all the entries. Congratulations to @Mila and @Suleman! Good question about Sunderclaw Duo. The outflanking explanation is quite reasonable, as two creatures wor…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/pool-of-vitality-2 This card has a lower floor and a higher ceiling than a Deserted Temple or a Wirewood Lodge and functions similar to a Reflecting Pool, all in one. But flexibility and trying to find creative ways t…
-
Thanks @Robo_Kitty! The favourites can be applied to any cards you like from my collection. I'll start you a few pages back so you don't have to go through a bunch of cards you've already seen: https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Jadefire/cards?page=9
-
That's great, thanks @kaoz42.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/maned-ravager
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vainglorious-narcissist
-
It seems like there was plenty of interest prior to the hiatus. You may consider checking in with the cardsmiths who wanted matches before.
-
? Double trouble https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/enlightened-brute-1 Rakdos cards often focus on getting larger and more offensive, even sacrificing card advantage for time advantage to kill your opponent faster. This card undergoes the opposite tra…
-
Thanks @Robo_Kitty! Hopefully, your schedule lightens up soon. The three favourites can be applied to any of my cards you like: https://mtgcardsmith.com/user/Jadefire/cards
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create an aura that cares about the power of the creature it enchants. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/brains-over-brawn-3 I've been completely underutilizing this perk, but I'll set my ? perk to the Ornate Skeleton Key⚙️.
-
I'll take prize 89 and Overdraft Charges.
-
Then consider your Prize 14 doubled.
-
@Robo_Kitty your mystery box contains: * Leonitus Prize 21 (Raincheck) * A Mystery Challenge: Create an Aura with a built-in ability that causes it to move around. @cadstar your mystery box contains: * WX-L9 Prize 14 (Raincheck) * A Mystery Chall…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/armored-stegoceratops