MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Jadefire
About
- Username
- Jadefire
- Joined
- Visits
- 12,437
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
I'll take Frankenstein_Creation.
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create a creature card with three custom keywords on it. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/loathsome-scavenger I'll go on the ferris wheel next.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ambush-reaper Submitting this for Scarecrows... Boo
-
@FireOfGolden Misdirected seems reasonable as an "upgraded" Negate. While it doesn't technically contain a custom ability, forcing a target change to one of the spell's controller's choice that's controlled by another player is fairly novel and onl…
-
@smax765 I guess I make the cutoff for real cardsmith. I would add to that a balanced common card with a custom ability, since common cards impose lower power limits and will test a cardsmith's ability to create within those limits. https://mtgcar…
-
@FireOfGolden The new wording looks much more concise and presents the information with better flow.
-
@FireOfGolden The rules look fine to me in general. I'm not sure if anyone will take Battle Mystery Cards seriously enough to invoke the official rules for it, but if it helps you understand for yourself how you want it structured and gives you som…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create a removal spell that replaces its target(s) with something that shares a type with them. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/charmed-reversal
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/iluma-guide This can save/blink your own Spirits or be used as temporary removal for your opponents' creatures.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/iluma-guide https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wicked-treat https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/consuming-sepulcher
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/wicked-treat I suppose a Food that can be used both offensively and defensively could fit into GW-On the Hunt.
-
@cadstar369 I think there are several ways you can go with Dorian to make its group hug more beneficial to you while retaining the appeal to keep it around for the other players. This can be done by making the effect not fully symmetrical, but skewi…
-
@FireOfGolden I'm pretty sure I understood the rules correctly. I had to go back and read them again, since it looks like there's very little forgiveness for any mistakes. I'll be submitting all three trials at the same time once they're done.
-
Wow, I'm just now starting to grasp how many prizes let you steal or destroy another cardsmith's creations. Feels bad to have your entries messed with.
-
@cadstar369 The contrast between Locrian and Dorian reminds me of Will and Rowan. They do quite opposite things and seem to have contrasting personalities: one takes something bad from your opponent for benefit and the other gives something good to…
-
Oof, looks like some difficulties following prompts and instructions, R.I.P.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/consuming-sepulcher
-
@FireOfGolden That's a good way to get entries to practice judging. I think to be a good judge, or at least a consistent judge, you have to know yourself. What are the things that matter most to you in a card's design? How do things rank relative…
-
Check which aspects the Mystery Box World Cantina characters focus on and take your best guess.
-
@FireOfGolden Thanks for the review and the suggestions. That would've made a lot of sense if the Cursed Blood-Fang was also a Human when in its weakened state. It never even occurred to me to do that. Good match @smax765.
-
Thanks @StuffnSuch. I came up with the name long before the card and pretty much built the card around name.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/hung-juror Submitting this for the Monster Mash.
-
Will any unfinished Mystery Box challenges transfer here or do they stay in the other discussion?
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cursed-blood-fang https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lycanthropic-fate Submitting this for the Monster Mash.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cursed-blood-fang https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/lycanthropic-fate I wanted to try something less conventional with the transformation mechanic. The front face is an aggressively costed Werewolf with a weakness to th…
-
@cadstar369 your mystery box contains: * Prize 24: Electrocutor⚡ Zap 1 entry. (It becomes yours.) * A Mystery Challenge: Create an artifact for any region, clan, or faction in Magic that's defined by three colours. The artifact should embody the…
-
I believe I left off with a selfie request to WX-L9 (Lex) and claimed a Captured Siren. I think I was supposed to get five more 〽️ from posting the?♀️before the end of the deadline, but I'll leave it to jpastor to account for that.
-
@cadstar369 your mystery box contains: * Prize 31: Memory Wiper⚡ Zap 2 entries. (They become yours.) * A Mystery Challenge: Create a Mercenary with a second class that can recruit and has either an additional triggered or activated ability.
-
That's a super easy thing to miss. Before it was legendary, I had to be informed that two copies of Bloodstained Baroness set to opposite values created an infinite loop.
-
@cadstar369 Thanks for the explanation of the lore around Locrian and the intended asymmetry (but not really) of the second ability. I figured there had to be a good reason for the unusual creature types. Looking forward to seeing this hybrid Croc…