MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Jadefire
About
- Username
- Jadefire
- Joined
- Visits
- 12,437
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create an artifact land that generates colored mana. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/cryptic-monolith Completing this challenge earns me Prize 34 - Chest 'o Precious Brews. Can I get another mystery box with two challenges?
-
@StuffnSuch cadstar's wording is the one I'd go with for the most straightforward version, since reminder text doesn't need to follow as strict a set of rules as actual rules text. Otherwise, you can say it like: Relapse (When this card is put int…
-
@cadstar369 Costing Lowlands Runner at 1R and giving it haste is quite strong. Even leaving out the potential for acceleration like Simian Spirit Guide or Rite of Flame, being on the play with this gives you very high potential to become the monarc…
-
Out of curiosity, is Relapse intended to stack (i.e., look for other cards with Relapse going to the graveyard, not just itself)? With the way it's currently worded, if you control two creatures with Relapse and one of them dies, you'll shuffle two…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create a 1/1 creature that has one activated ability, and that ability requires it to tap itself as the only cost. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/myconid-thaumaturgist
-
My Challonge username is Jadefire_wsn
-
I knew there was going to be a juggernaut coming my way but 7-0 vs. Ranshi AND 12SidedGuy? That was unexpected. Great matches @exaltedmarauder and @balloonnation! Congratuations to the new king of Divsion A.
-
@cadstar369 That makes sense that the Sunfall Chaser will connect with your opponent more often than it triggers its own Overkill, but I presume doming your opponent for 5 repeatedly is the preferable outcome rather than using the Sunfall Chaser pri…
-
@cadstar369 There have been several recent creations from different cardsmiths that utilize the trigger of a spell or ability not resolving. Whenever I see this condition with no limit to how many times it can trigger in a turn, my thinking goes to…
-
@TheDarkKnight1234567 if you're gonna go down, make sure you do so swinging, which is just what you did. You had some good ideas, I'm not surprised you held your ground in several of the pairings.
-
Good match @TheDarkKnight1234567! Those blowouts though! Got a real clash of the titans going on in the semis.
-
I'll refrain from picking on anyone, but I'll remain available if someone wants to challenge me.
-
Thanks for overseeing the contest @TheKeefMan. Good match @Robo_Kitty!
-
https://www.mtgcardsmith.com/view/prelate-of-the-spirit-censer I hope I met all the requirements. I guess my chosen zones are the stack and the graveyard. This can be used to upgrade your own creature spells or to downgrade your opponent's. Thi…
-
@TheKeefMan No worries, it's all good.
-
Sounds good.
-
Thanks @Daedalus_The_All_Father. Yeah, it's quite the wall of text. I could've deviated from the official Oracle wording of cards like All is Dust and Altar of the Pantheon to save some space, but I'm a fan of making cards that read and work like re…
-
@TheKeefMan Thanks for the clarification. Just to confirm, whichever zone I choose, the creature needs to able to move cards between the graveyard and that zone in both directions, right? Or is it also a choice between in or out?
-
@TheKeefMan Is my challenge for real? The two challenges are nowhere near comparable in difficulty. I don't even think I fully understand what my requirements are. I hope my understanding of it is wrong because a black creature that can move any …
-
I'll answer the call. Just tell me what I need to do.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/volazzo-fetish-hunter Volazzo lets you maintain your devotion to keep Abathra a creature as you sacrifice your other creatures to her ability. Then you can sacrifice the Trophy tokens to get your creatures back later.
-
Urza's Mine is a bit of a special case, not only because it's a real Magic card, but because it's also part of a set that's intended to be played with each other. We'd need to get on the same page when evaluating a card like this. Is it to be appr…
-
If the four options reflect four real results from the judges, the mean of the four (or the mean of the middle two after eliminating the two outliers) is actually pretty close to the truth.
-
If I were to score this card, I wouldn't land on the exact rating of any of the judges. I think I'd give it something in the range of 87-88, so I guess Judge D? The card is technically flawless in its execution: P/T, cost, and rarity are fully in …
-
Thanks @ShadowReign, much appreciated!
-
I've got an idea brewing too. Trying to not make it a wall of rules text on the card, but we'll see how it turns out.
-
@ShadowReign Elenise totally makes sense now that you've pointed out Briarbridge Patrol. Nice riff on that card. Given that Briarbridge Patrol is a 3/3 monocolor nonlegendary uncommon with the same mana value, do you think there's room to beef up El…
-
What's this about a Fatigue Spheriod now? I guess I'm slower than the effect. A Mystery Challenge: Create a rare creature card with total power and toughness less than its mana value, without using 0 or *. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/allusive-e…
-
@cadstar369 Dash would be an interesting approach to playing with Enlightened. There are definitely more cards than I named that can give an opponent a creature like Varchild, Betrayer of Kjeldor, Xantcha, Sleeper Agent, Beast Within/Generous Gift,…
-
@cadstar369 I figured building up to a creature was a bit of a stretch and also counterintuitive to what the Empty series does, which is why I found it interesting that you previously asked about ending on an enchantment. The only idea I have for u…