MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Jadefire
About
- Username
- Jadefire
- Joined
- Visits
- 12,437
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@cadstar369 I was going to suggest a more proactive card with an Empty Transcendence-like effect along the lines of World Queller, but I guess that's off the table if building up to a creature isn't something you want to do (I might end up making th…
-
A Mystery Challenge: Create a creature card with mutate cost higher than its mana cost. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/rampaging-maulhorn Prize 24 - Contraband Cargo successfully earned and cashed in. https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/faiths-bastion …
-
@cadstar369 Making use of empty zones is a great idea. I agree with ShadowReign that the payoff for all that effort should be bigger than a modified Balance. You should be setting yourself up to win with such a sequence of plays, rather than just …
-
@cadstar369 You Search the Room is a well-balanced card. I can see how you have one of the two colours taking the lead in each of the modes. Making the spell a sorcery and adding red to the cost definitely justifies a Catalog + Treasure in Take Yo…
-
The Juggernaut will make a move to level the playing field again.
-
Is the restriction on legendaries and mythics lifted now or was that just for that one encounter?
-
I'll choose the Juggernaut and the Juggernaut will play a card that has a clear advantage against a being of mixed elements.
-
#2 to #4 seem pretty straightforward and distinct from one another. It appears #1 and #5 may have some overlap in the department of novelty. Would it be correct to say that #1 pertains to what a card is and #5 pertains to what the card does and ho…
-
@cadstar369 Giving your opponent control of a token that causes mass looting is a clever way to accomplish that goal. The fact that it's also a group hug of sorts might help the card to not get hated out, though once the Omphalos tokens have been c…
-
@FireOfGolden Yes, that would work too.
-
I don't expect everyone to know this but there are two timing issues that make Animated Armor not work as intended. 1) Wording the first ability as "when" means the Armor has to already be on the battlefield before the attach ability triggers, whic…
-
@cadstar369 It's understandable that if powerful decks is the context you're familiar with, that you'd design your cards to be competitive in that environment. That's probably how power creep happens, since no one wants to make underpowered designs…
-
@cadstar369 Great job with making a Flagbearer lord. The second ability really does double duty in deterring your opponent from casting any targeted spells and being a pseudo-Heroic trigger for copying your own beneficial spells and abilities, espe…
-
@FireOfGolden There's a card older than Warrior's Oath/Last Chance called Final Fortune that does the same thing but at instant speed. There's also a similar card in Boros that does that plus gives your creatures indestructible called Chance for Gl…
-
@smax765 I know what the issue is with your missing apostrophes. Check the bottom of this comment. In short, you'll need to add them back in manually when you're editing your card's text. https://forums.mtgcardsmith.com/discussion/comment/229377#Com…
-
Woodfall Primus will go after Abyssia as well, but its ETB ability will remove Beastmaster Ascension.
-
@smax765 Good battle, you even got a piece of art that looks like Beacon of Immortality. @FireOfGolden Excuse the misinterpretation. Wording the challenge as "at least one" is the same as saying "one or more." Now that you've explained more clear…
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/price-of-diplomacy This was an interesting card to come up with with. Even though it's a mashup of Time Stretch and Worst Fears, it couldn't be blue or black. The theme of diplomacy (E.g., making a deal) and white'…
-
The Blizzard Elemental is going to try to put Pyroclasm on ice.
-
@FireOfGolden Yes, I was thinking of Slaughter Pact and the other Pacts. What I was considering is not exactly like that but it does involve a cost to prevent the undesirable thing, or you can just take it.
-
@FireOfGolden Question for the challenge: does it count if the card lets you do something to prevent the terrible thing from happening, or does it have to happen no matter what?
-
I hate to not claim a prize, but I'm going to have to pass on my remaining challenge. Can I get another mystery box with two challenges?
-
@cadstar369 your mystery box contains: * A Mystery Challenge: Create a card that would make a Flagbearer tribal deck closer to being a reality (using Changelings, if necessary).
-
Also, I accept the challenge from @smax765.
-
@FireOfGolden @Globert-the-Martian Giving a permanent an additional ability does not overwrite any of that permanent's existing abilities. You are thinking of changing a permanent's type, subtype, or colour. When those things are changed, the new …
-
Well, I guess it makes sense to fight wood with fire. Going after the Forestweaver.
-
@TheKeefMan Congrats on breaking the streak. It looks like no perfect season this time around, lol.
-
@atlanticbomber your mystery box contains: * Rain Check for Prize 39 (to be awarded by jpastor later) * A Mystery Challenge: Create a card that interacts with a multicolored spell or permanent.
-
@smax765 your mystery box contains: * A Mystery Challenge: Create an instant or sorcery with Morbid where when Morbid is active, the spell does something markedly better than what it does without Morbid (not just the same thing to a greater degre…
-
@cadstar369 your Navigator's Needle replacement contains: * A Mystery Challenge: Create an unblockable creature with a built-in restriction other than not untapping that prevents it from ever attacking two turns in a row. @Robo_Kitty your myst…