MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Je_Suis_Oluwa
About
- Username
- Je_Suis_Oluwa
- Joined
- Visits
- 881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
THE JUDGING: PART 1 OF 2 Honorable* Mentions *If you're the kind of person that doesn't like everything that doesn't "win" getting an honorable mention, think of these as dishonorable mentions in order for me to provide feedback. Otherwise, imagine…
-
I'm sorry I just realized this, but @Animist you can only submit one card and you have submitted two - which is your final submission? You have a few days.
-
I would call it Arcbound Ravager Wurm personally
-
Venerated Loxodon finally has some friends among his own kind. I promise I'll judge this contest soon, but until I judge, feel free to continue submitting cards.
-
I created this for a different challenge this week, but it works here too-
-
"enchantment with"
-
One more day!
-
TWELFTH PLACE LET'S GO! Seriously, this was a very fun challenge, and I regret not having played from the beginning. Your feedback helped me as a designer. I suggest you do more similar contests in the future.
-
@gamerAwesome101 No it's not. Never mind then
-
(I realized this doesn't adhere to the rules of the contest so do not judge it)
-
There was never a question in my mind that I would make the greatest sea monster of them all: The reminder text for suspend didn't fit, by the way, but here it is: (Rather than cast this card from your hand, you may pay BB and exile it with 10 tim…
-
@KorandAngels but existing factions are allowed, correct?
-
@Red_Tower I mean, every card has a use of some sort. The real bad cards are the ones that are just useless in comparison to others. For example, Divination for 10U.
-
I claim the Vampires of Ixalan.
-
@KorandAngels Well then Venerated Loxodon already has eight! https://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?output=spoiler&method=visual&action=advanced&subtype=+["Elephant"]&set=|["Ravnica:+City+of+Guilds"]|["Guildpact"]|["D…
-
@Temurzoa Charismatic Captain's second ability doesn't actually interact with the creatures that convoked it or care if any creatures convoked it at all. This just happens to have convoke. So unfortunately I can't count it, and I suggest you change …
-
I used thorns. I think this design does a good job of being flavorful while still having abilities that synergize well, but we'll see. (I forgot to list on the card, but this art is by dannii-jo over on DeviantArt.)
-
Yeah, you're right. A lot of these things are judgement calls anyway, so you could go either way.
-
Well I forgot about this contest, so I'll judge it now. As expected, the card quality is relatively high, and I could see many of these cards doing very well at another contest. In fact, I can say that with this contest, there were no cards that wer…
-
Cack is also useful for thinning your deck so you're guaranteed to find your combo pieces. You'd have a bunch of useless cards in your hand, though. Not sure if that makes it good, but it's a use. Now for my submissions-
-
@Faiths_Guide I'll order again, for extra fun: a noncreature spell with 0-3 words of rules text.
-
@pstmdrn: This might not be the cleanest way, but you could say: "Pay 2 life: Add one mana of any color. Use this mana only to pay for colored mana in the costs of Sliver spells you cast."
-
I think return to Theros is coming up personally; it's one of the most popular planes and has not seen a return yet.
-
@MemoryHead, you're correct. I'm replacing fading with haunt. @Red_Tower The steamflogger name is a reference to Steamflogger Boss in that it has abilities that are useless...right now. Also, is there any good way to tie it to Contraptions while s…
-
@kandra127 Exactly, that's why it doesn't have a well-defined one.
-
Many decks already kind of have a planeswalker, tell me what you guys think about this, for a few common standard decks: Mono-Red: Chandra White Aggro: Gideon Izzet Phoenix: Ral Grixis Midrange: Nicol Bolas Gruul Stompy: Domri Mono-Blue: Jace Some …
-
-
Cool - just two days remaining.
-