MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Je_Suis_Oluwa
About
- Username
- Je_Suis_Oluwa
- Joined
- Visits
- 881
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Also, please close this thread, mods. Thanks
-
This contest kind of got buried, but I'll try to judge it now. I was a bit unclear with rules; I meant a specific story event not just a top down design. But that's fine, it's my fault explaining it badly. I'm going to give the win to @bnew07 for …
-
Great, thanks!
-
-
A random citizen of Theros. This would probably be part of a cycle of five creatures that have an effect if you control an enchantment.
-
I know it's not a creature, but I had this lying around and figured there was no downside to submitting it. I hope that's OK.
-
@EnvyReaper,@Faiths_Guide sorry, I didn't read the rules closely enough. That's a good summary.
-
Hello, I have a request. I would like a creature from the Abzan faction with an effect that you would want to put in a deck with many high toughness creatures. For example, Kin-Tree Invocation. Thanks a lot
-
-
@Faiths_Guide: I've done a Gatherer search for all the creatures which gain life upon their death. Here's what I got. Colorless: Anodet Lurker Enatu Golem Guardian Automaton Onulet White: Auspicious Ancestor Paladin of Atonement Silent-Chant Zuber…
-
The dark side of white.
-
All Avizoa needed was a small change in stats to make it playable. This card is now pretty snazzy in draft.
-
@Faiths_Guide: The thing with cache is since it's at common, if I'm confused, it means it's not a great mechanic, as it will likely confuse many people. And Demoted Guard didn't confuse me, it's just not black. It's definitely doable in green (High…
-
Colors: I'm happy to play any color, but I gravitate towards white, green, and/or black. Tribes: I'm not big on tribal decks, but my favorite tribe is probably ouphes, because you can yell OUPHE! in people's faces. Playstyle: I like playing aggro …
-
#1: @bnew07: Rix Maadi Hellhound Why It's Snazzy: This card is everything I was looking for when I created this contest. It's a good power level (I think), it's flavorful, it's simple, it's common. It perfectly captures the flavor of the guild of R…
-
5. @Corwinnn: Fight with Courage Why It's Snazzy: This card is an interesting and aesthetically pleasing design. This is properly costed and seems fun to play with. Some Feedback: This might be a bit difficult to understand on first look that it's …
-
@sorinjace, what I meant by my comment was not that Cataract Navigator is boring. It's probably a fairly fun card to play (though I didn't playtest any submission), and seems balanced statwise. What I meant was that there were a lot of cards from Ix…
-
I mean, you're trading a card for a card, and you have to wait until turn 2. No more overpowered than Mishra's Bauble.
-
I'm glad you found my feedback helpful! The Provoke the Beasts thing makes sense, but it might make more sense to have it apply to everyone, similar to Shake the Foundations.
-
HM. @ArmisJoe: Undip Why It's Snazzy: This is an interesting concept of a card that cycles on turn 2 for free. It's an interesting way to have a 56-card deck and would probably see competitive play. Some Feedback: As with Mishra's/Urza's Bauble, th…
-
Thanks for participating, everyone! Everyone will be judged by their best card, but I will try to give every card some feedback. I thought everyone had at least one card that I think is interesting. I've ranked the top five here, but I really think …
-
According to a Mark Rosewater article, "I get request to return to Theros from two groups: the people who love Greek mythology and had fun seeing Magic's version of it, and fans of Elspeth who are interested in what is going on with her." I fall int…
-
Updated "best card per submission": (Note: I'm primarily doing this as a cheat sheet for when I judge later, if you didn't all realize that) @Corwinnn: Fight with Courage @Faiths_Guide: Bramble Druid @ArmisJoe: Undip [previously: Scruple] @ElMagic…
-
I'm happy with the direction this contest is going. The new commons are a lot more of what I was looking for.
-
@sorinjace, thanks for the welcome and entry. I've used Cardsmith on and off for a few years now but I haven't used the forums until now. There is no limit on cards old and new, since I don't want to be unfair to anyone that submits later, but plea…
-
I'm happy with how many people have been submitting entries to my contest, and all cards are very cool, and I imagine they would lead to interesting play patterns. So thank you all. This is my first contest, and I don't want to make anyone feel bad,…
-
The thing with this card is that when your opponent controls the board with this, the game is slow and you probably won't win, but you feel like you have one out. In reality, that one out probably won't save you either. (Shouldn't have power/toughn…
-
I had these lying around:
-
-
Power level is hard to judge, but this seems fine... Challenge: make a life-gain payoff. (e.g. Ajani's Pridemate, Sanguine Bond)