MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
KEdRuss
About
- Username
- KEdRuss
- Joined
- Visits
- 88
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
My first entry:
-
@MemoryHead -- Defender, flying, hexproof [Those keywords go in this order. No definitive idea why, that's just how it is.] Appears to be following an alphabetic order. Works for me. You'll notice that I've changed the "when spell resolves" thin…
-
@zizick123 - Considering that you're adding sacrifice to the cost, I think you can reduce the cost by {1}, or add to the rules that this spell would allow this card to be cost less for each permanent you sacrifice. But that's me. One of my newer on…
-
-
@KrakenSalad - My first feedback is to change the condition of the card draw on the second ability so that it deals combat damage to a player. And maybe adjust the wording: Until the end of turn, Tugsakha, Worldly Ancient loses defender, and it gai…
-
-
And here we go:
-
@zizick123 - I think the wording is a bit muddled and needs better clarity: Whenever a creature an opponent controls dies after being dealt damage by this creature, you may put a +1/+1 counter on Dreadglance Basalisk. Otherwise that's a pretty inti…
-
-
@Potato13 - Yeah, after some consideration, I've changed the rules so that the exiles of Monastery Avenger (new name) is contingent on it staying on the field. I keep forgetting hard exiles usually need a condition so that they're not OP.
-
Hi! Relatively new here. I hope this follows the guidelines: Card is based on a Final Fantasy VII antagonist in one of his final, mutated forms.
-
@TenebrisNemo - That was helpful! Thanks. White Lies is pretty devious, too. Fav'd. Here's a different one (updated -- thanks @zizick123 for recommended card rule wording changes):
-
Third entry:
-
@jicklemania2 - If you lower both the P/T of Witch of Ghost Pack to something in the ballpark of 2/3, I think it would be fine with a reduced CMC {b}{g}{u}. Making it cheaper would make it easier to get value from your graveyard earlier. Keep the ab…
-
-
@TenebrisNemo - I like it! I also love the Hellraiser-esque flavor. I also think adding flash to this wouldn't be terrible, since you're still paying for -1/-1, and it is still likely going to eat a spell once it ETB, anyway. Fav'd. As suggested, t…
-
Entry number one:
-
@Obidiah if this can flicker planeswalkers at instant speed (with an additional loyalty point), I feel this needs to cost more to cast. Or have an additional rule where it would cost more to target planeswalkers.
-
Hey guys! A couple days new to the site and forums and wanted to throw my hat into this friendly competition. 1st entry: 2nd entry:
-
@jicklemania2 - Fair point on Lightblade Defender's problematic hexproof status. I guess what I would need to do is rework the card rule so it can still do what it's intended to do without technically being hexproof -- similar to how Helplessness o…
-
-
@RandomFandom - Thanks! Yeah, I really struggled about the size of the tokens. The logic behind was the design was bred from personal frustrations that big angels like Avacyn, Angel of Hope never stayed on the battlefield long, and almost all the go…
-
Well, since I'm not seeing any newer cards... @KingSumples - Pretty cool concept for a Dimir sac outlet engine. Not sure I'm hip on the second ability. Maybe a mechanic where any creature that leaves the battlefield due to negative counters gets yo…