MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
KalamMekhar
About
- Username
- KalamMekhar
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,560
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@jpastor can I have 3 artworks?
-
Apologies for being so late. I've been on the road for over a week. I'll get to judging this, I promise.
-
And THAT'S IT! NO MORE ENTRIES! PUT DOWN YOUR PENCILS! Oko will be judging this contest soon, so stay tuned!
-
ONLY 24 HOURS TO GO BEFORE OKO, THIEF OF CLOWNS DESCENDS UPON THIS THREAD TO JUDGE IT! Get your last minute entries in, and also take time to review entries you have already made and check them for minor errors. I'd hate to withhold awarding a card…
-
@Lastjustice: if my entry has split second, can I still submit it?
-
@everyone: Even if you're unsure of a submission, at least give it a day before you delete it, otherwise I won't even know what you deleted because my timezone is many hours away from most of yours!
-
@Revan hmmm, if you say so. although I am quite accepting of humorous cards as long as they're not memes or something like the Homie Sliver @sorinjace mentioned
-
@Revan wait, I didn't even see the card! Could you repost it? And while I said no joke cards, cards with humour are fine, just like you see in actual MtG. I meant no obvious troll or meme cards or cards that look like Un-Cards.
-
The most underrated pizza topping is definitely garlic. And raw green chillies. And of course onions. I can subsist on nothing but pizza with the above three toppings. But I'll need extra chilli flakes too.
-
@Ranshi I thought the most iconic pizza topping was onion. I personally can't imagine a pizza without onion.
-
First entry Edit: changed it a bit
-
@Tommia and no, no need to introduce the OG
-
@Tommia as long as your letter change does not involve or result in a proper noun, it's fine
-
@Tommia there's no issue with your card. I only mentioned avoiding named legendary creatures and 'walkers because they don't really fit the contest well, since you can't possibly edit their names, so your only option is to make different versions of…
-
@Scott_Anderson I like it!
-
@RohanDragoon to answer your question: yes, the card must remind you of the OG without being exactly that.
-
@Scott_Anderson oh no! I'm really sorry. I've even been told that there was an earlier challenge like this that never got judged, so contrary to my initial statement, there appear to be many cards of this kind. Post the card here anyway, I want to…
-
Stupid me, I forgot to mention the REWARDS! Check it out now!
-
It's the first challenge I've hosted since my self-imposed exile from the site, so let's make it memorable!
-
@Revan I really like the flavour, and the card overall reminds me of No Mercy, except that this one is strong in the situations where No Mercy is weak (against a wide board of small creatures) and vice versa (this doesn't do much against, say, a Gur…
-
@Mir-151414 I think there's too much going on with Syr Aeridan. Vigilance and first strike are fine, but then he also comes with at least four 1/1 soldier tokens? That are also lifelinkers? And he does that on death as well? And he's also got Gavony…
-
@Fantastickill7 regarding Wielder of the Lightning Rod, I think your change goes too far the other way and underpowers it. It was just too good for 2 mana. 3 would be perfectly fine; Irencrag Pyromancer costs 3 and is balanced. At 4 it comes down a …
-
@Fantastickill7 left a fav It's a nice combination of abilities with one fuelling the other. Having said that, I think it's a bit too good, especially at uncommon. For a start, I don't think it should have bear stats, since it's already got a very g…
-
Based on Nicol Bolas, Dragon-God's +1. @Corwinnn: that was kinda my concern about it. I'll try to redesign it. @KorandAngels: haha, fair point. What I was trying to convey was that when your planeswalkers throw themselves into the red zone for th…
-
Inspired by Gideon, Champion of Justice's second ability. This is more or less identical, except that any planeswalker can become a creature and not just Gideon, and that they become a Soldier rather than Human Soldier (non-Human planeswalkers matte…
-
@Corwinnn: yikes, didn't notice that at all. I think I made Devotee instant to offset the lack of haste since no red, and...forgot about the whole mirroring thing. Facepalm time!
-
New (although the name says otherwise) Old (again, the name says otherwise)
-
-
Did someone say Bant Bolas? Original:
-
He burns through a lot of books, but eventually finds what he's looking for.