MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
KalamMekhar
About
- Username
- KalamMekhar
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,560
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ningyounk: wow, thanks for that extremely insightful feedback! You have some very deep insights into card design that one would typically only expect of the actual designers at WotC! Here are my card by card comments, to put things in perspective: …
-
@ningyounk: thank you for the escape route!
-
I realised I have made a horrific blunder in my submission: I have used a non evergreen mechanic in one of my designs, even though the rules said not to!
-
Decided to make a Spirit after playing some Bant spirits in Modern. It is nerfed by its lack of flying (which is bad in the spirits deck), although it could easily cost 4 (and at that point I'd add flying, but for the challenge restriction). This o…
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos: I had to force it somehow, yes.
-
Me and my playgroup were designing skeletons for funny custom cards depicting real world figures. I googled, found this site, and promptly made a creature called Don Vito, the Godfather (it still exists). I would go on to make some cards, most depic…
-
@TheCentreOfTheUniverse: Was looking to make this comment but you beat me to it!
-
...aaaaand results are in! Sorry for taking so long, this is the first extended period of activity I've had on this site for a while now. Without further ado, let's get to the mentions! Before that, a shoutout to @bnew07 for a very well balanced and…
-
For this challenge, I decided to go with the one thing I know best. On the left we have a brilliant Simic neurobiologist who quits them and joins the Izzet, for access to advanced electrical equipment and (un)willing test subjects. On the right w…
-
@Faiths_Guide: Hierarch does way too much. For decks that need the aggro ability, it is also a Birds of Paradise. For decks that need the mana ability, it is also a kind of lord. All this for a single green mana. Not to mention it also has a relevan…
-
@Faiths_Guide Noble Hierarch: "Draft-warping? Ha! Try format warping!" (I have no idea why no one calls for a Hierarch ban.)
-
@Corwinnn: those are some Uncommonly quick reflexes!
-
@Djayhero: last strike looks very odd on a black bordered card. Unless this was specifically meant to be an un-card, I'd avoid it. A 2 drop 1/2 deathtouch is hardly the most powerful thing in the world and it doesn't need the last strike to nerf it.…
-
Anyone playing now?
-
Hell yes! Untap's been adding some great features of late. I'd love to draft against some fellow cardsmiths!
-
I second Dinosaur, although I wouldn't mind ogres either.
-
I decided to give the GDS3 trials a shot, because of the excellent feedback that @ningyounk, @bnew07, and @TheCenterOfTheUniverse are handing out. Here are my cards for Trial 3: Design 1 Teferi the Timeless (mythic rare) 3WU Legendary Planeswalker …
-
Whoops! I missed this completely. Looks like my name was misspelt incorrectly here (it's become a routine occurrence recently), so it didn't show up in the notifs. But no excuses, really, for not showing up. I apologise. I will not submit my cards f…
-
It's a Pirat! Flavour text commemorats one of my favourat rodents. (Okay, okay, I will stop these puns!)
-
Well, it's not exactly bacon, but felt like posting it.
-
@kickash: thank you! I am pleasantly surprised you liked that card!
-
@Scott_Anderson: I think the rules say 1 enchantment with CMC 3-5 and one walker with CMC 5-7
-
( @TenebrisNemo: as someone who's living on an island right now, I have to agree with you. )
-
( @Corwinnn: I blame @TenebrisNemo for getting it stuck in my head )
-
( @Corwinnn: Mariiiiiko waaaalks aloooooooooooooone...)
-
( @TenebrisNemo: I'll write a piece where Vir interacts with someone. But, till then he walks aloooooooone...)
-
@bnew07: I have commented on Lingering Ideal!
-
@DoctorFro: it's from a song
-
( @TenebrisNemo: *facepalm* )
-
My party of elves. Some might be a little shoddily done as I kind of sped through the creation of these five.