MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
LyndonF
About
- Username
- LyndonF
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,587
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Thank goodness my cards are for Commander, not standard like @bnew07 ...
-
It looks innocuous, but probably covers a lot of situations: - Impulse like effects - Effects that let you look at (and possibly cast) the top card of your library - Scry Imagine getting this on turn 0 and then playing a Temple...
-
I'll take the uncommon design pack and the first common flavour pack.
-
(Here I go again)
-
Congrats to @winners! Considering there are a lot of renowned players here, I'd consider 8th a decent spot. That said, I still have some issues to work on...
-
(looks at all the great entries before me) (sighs) (well here goes nothing...) I'm trying to replace the less-played cards (with low ranks according to draftsim) with some better ones. Here's what I have: White (Instant) Defiant Strike is rarely…
-
@ningyounk @Scaccogaming Having UR be the "huge spells" archetype does seem interesting... Audacious Sparkmage: Trample is at least secondary in red, so it's fine. It also helps make sure increased power from the second ability translates well to…
-
Donuts!
-
A completely different take on this:
-
-
More ideas: --- Serran Vestige CARDNAME enters the battlefield tapped. When CARDNAME enters the battlefield, you gain 2 serran life. {t}: Add {c}. --- Purpose: A land in uncommon slot that contributes to serran life themes. Ref: Crumbling Vestig…
-
For the mechanics, I would definitely keep Songs since they are the most interesting and flavourful ones. Harmonize is actually interesting as well though so I would give it another shot. Rebound is okay, the set seems fine with or without it. As f…
-
@ningyounk Galloping Frosthorn: Definitely agree that it will be a trouble if it just sits back. Maybe make it a 3/1? That may entice the player to not play defense with it too much. Blooming Beauty: Seems good, great art. Ambitious Carver: Doub…
-
@ningyounk Frantic Studies: That's quite clean and interesting! It reminds me of Act on Impulse a lot, so the cmc might need to be adjusted. Serran Ambusher: I really need to remind myself to look through the commons before posting... Serran Fir…
-
@ningyounk the rare looks quite exciting! Its variance is larger relative to other cards (IMHO) since your opponent can also control whether you lose the life. But I guess huge rewards come with a huge risk so it's interesting to see how it'll turn …
-
Some more ideas for blue, and hopefully less pushed this time: --- Opt to Discover 1U Instant Discover. Draw a card. --- Purpose: Push towards UR discover primarily, as well as WU second spell. Ref: Opt, which is a common. But since you can fla…
-
Some ideas for white: --- Serran Revitalize 1W Instant You gain 2 serran life. Draw a card. --- Purpose: Push towards WU second spell. Ref: Revitalize. Decreased to 2 life to avoid triggering Renaissance, which isn't the point (and may be a bit to…
-
A couple more notes on Harmonize: - I double checked the rules and by rule 304.d, an animated Aura will die as a state-based effect. But we can just ignore it and that's probably fine. - If you accidentally animate a land that just enter the battlef…
-
Also, the official card with 31 options is spoiled!
-
Nice! But 104 options isn't enough to beat your personal best though...
-
Seems nice! Some more ideas to throw around: --- CW04 Creature 1W When CARDNAME etbs, Harmonize 2. 0/1 --- CW05 Creature 2W When CARDNAME dies, Harmonize 3. 2/2 --- CW17 Instant 3W Enlighten Exile target creature with power 4 or greater. If C…
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos Yup. That's what the clarification is for. @Aggroman15 Quite interesting! Let me pull out my pencil and paper to check...
-
CLARIFICATION: If the choice offered to the player is done at random, it is deemed to not satisfy the requirements. NOT OKAY:
-
@RohanDragoon That card is quite interesting! I do agree that if it wasn't random, there will easily be optimal choices. Unfortunately, it doesn't give a real choice to the player. This means effects like Crystalline Giant (Mechagodzilla, the Weapon…
-
I'm guessing this is what you meant for Encore: Encore [Cost] (If you cast this spell for its encore cost from your hand, exile it as it resolves, and you can’t cast any other spells this turn. At the beginning of your next upkeep, you may cast thi…
-
Thanks @Corwinnn & @Tomigon for the feature!