MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MagicChess
About
- Username
- MagicChess
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,643
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Terramorphic, yes, I understand; since @ningyounk, @Lujikul, @modnation675, and I are the only original creators who are still active, you don't want to seem like you're trying to take charge. But you are wholeheartedly welcome into the group; we a…
-
@Gelectrode: @Lujikul and I were both excited to work on the story as well. Welcome to the club! I'm glad we have another smith who's interested in writing lore. I think that once we've finished the creative design of the set, and have made some key…
-
@Lujikul, @ningyounk: I think that a kind of contest/festival to "touch" a Muse and gain inspiration is an interesting idea, and if that's where we want to go, I'm totally cool with it. Just pointing out, tough, that the entire point of this set so …
-
@Gelectrode, let the most glorious of tribes prevail! XD
-
@Mellenius, unfortunately you can only make entries for one tribe (or so I've gathered). @IanLowenthal, could you clarify?
-
Really? Huh. I get how one could think that at first sight........... yeah, I've seen a couple undulating, semi-transparent, featureless whales in my day XD
-
Fixed! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/uua-the-faceless-2
-
@IanLowenthatl, oh no! When I remade the card, the stat box went away. Has anyone else had that glitch before?
-
Sounds good! I just wish 'Renascence' were a verb, because we could say "...Renascence only as a sorcery."
-
OOZES, UNITE! THE MIGHT AND BENEVOLENCE AND MINDLESSNESS OF UUA FORMS A BANNER OVER YOU ALL! https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/uua-the-faceless-2 https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/ooze-7
-
@ningyounk, I like your efforts to shorten it, but you'd still need "... and loses all other types" or it arguably would be come an Enchantment Creature - Human Advisor. I think the second one is more smoothly worded, though much more powerful than …
-
Yeeeeeeeesssss! OOZES FOR THE WIN!
-
@KrampisZman, @MrRansom, I will extend this challenge for two days for you. It would be a shame for anybody to forfeit this late in the game!
-
@ningyounk, WHOA!! My mind is blown, and my perception of reality is crushed. All things I before considered true have been altered. I--- Okay, it's not that dramatic, but still. I don't know if the INCREDIBLE COOLNESS is worth the confusion that w…
-
@Faiths_Guide, @MrRansom, @modnation675, @KrampisZman: Only one more day to get your entries in!!!!
-
@ningyounk, yes I like this new distribution much more, especially because it's more balanced now; check it out: 2x Control, both share: U 2x Combo, both share: U 2x Disruptive Aggro, both share: R 2x Beatdown Aggro, both share: G 2x Midrange, both…
-
@everyone My favorite mechanics from the list proposed are as follows: - #14: Rewind (When this creature dies, if it isn't a token, create a token that's a copy of it, except it is an Art.) This wording is incomplete, and I feel that it needs a coup…
-
@modnation675, I don't understand. How is this (Rebirth {cost} (If you cast this creature for its rebirth cost, when it enters the battlefield, return it to it's owner's hand.)) suspend? If anything, it's more like evoke or blinking.
-
@ningyounk, I like your most recent Rebirth idea. I think that is has a lot of great possible interactions, and that it is flavorful and workable. @SpiritDragon, the problem with your idea is that it combos off with itself XD
-
@Faiths_Guide, sounds good
-
@ningyounk, I like your interpretation (my favorite part is UB: "Art stealers" XD), though I do think that RG should include some ramp. The beauty archetype you mentioned could go in one of two slots, in my opinion. GB, as we saw with the elves on L…
-
A little off topic here, but I have an idea (shocking, I know XD)! For another trope, we could say that in this world, in addition to emotion and creativity, writing was also lost for a period of time. However, now that it has been rediscovered, wor…
-
@All_Designers, what do you think of Immortalize or something along the lines of that for @pkfdre 's mechanic? It brings out the "preserved forever in art" aspect, though we lose some of the more renaissance-y feel.
-
@Gelectrode, I like your Horror idea. Maybe possibly maybe a story spotlight as a corrupted Muse (with some changes to the effect so as to be more twistedly similar to the other Muses)? @brcien, what are life counters and what are charge counters? …
-
@ningyounk, it's an interesting idea. Would we maybe want to bring back the untap symbol for this ability? Maybe "[ability name] - {cost}, {ut}: effect"? As for the name, there are several options: we've considered "Rebirth" and now "Renascence," bu…
-
@mithandir91, your simplified version of the blue boon effect is called Fateseal 3.
-
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/moonflower-caverns
-
@ningyounk, thank you for condensing that for the people who don't want to read through that huge block of text XD @pkfdre, what do you mean by "repeatable"? And why would you want to prevent pumping? If it's for balance, you've balanced it plenty …
-
@Gelectrode, yes on both counts!
-
Round Three! @Faiths_Guide vs. @hivelord3 -> Make a red card with cmc less than 4 that lets you cast an instant/sorcery from your hand without paying its mana cost. @MrRansom vs @modnation675 -> Make a card with Afflict from Hour of Devastati…