MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MagicChess
About
- Username
- MagicChess
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,643
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@IanLowenthal, sorry, what? XD
-
@Faiths_Guide, ve-e-e-ry clever XD
-
@Faiths_Guide AHA! Performer, eh? @modnation675 's divination prowess and numerous pet frogs has led them to the answer before the esteemed moderator! XD
-
@ningyounk, what butterfly idea?? I completely missed that XD I think that it is poignant that the five main characters are Gifted by the Grand Muses, so it makes sense that there has been no mention of the minor ones so far; there's only been two s…
-
@ningyounk, I agree about Julvenia; you just mentioned that you were looking for an older proposal in a previous comment As for Estoria, really? I must have been Portuguese in a previous life XD @Gelectrode, @ningyounk: Ningyounk is very vocal and…
-
@Faiths_Guide Batraquomancy, perhaps? XD "Toad" is an unused subtype...
-
@Gelectrode, with all due respect, it is not solely @ningyounk 's decision to make. Once again, this is a team effort and the original idea is attributed to @OneBigBlueSky.
-
@modnation675, that's fine. I realize that this is a very difficult challenge, so you have no time limit Wait, wha??? How do you know what @Faiths_Guide is going to do?
-
@Gelectrode, wow, I love this new plot outline! I really like how you blended already proposed elements with new ideas to make a cohesive whole. I have a suggestion, though: Earlier, we decided that we wanted the black character to betray the other…
-
@Gelectrode, thanks for understanding and contributing I'll write my own proposal this afternoon when I have more time.
-
@Gelectrode, a couple things: - The Muses (and we're very certain about this) aren't gods and should be as different from gods as possible. Thus, they also don't have concrete goals (such as "reforming the archipelago"), but are rather a mysterious…
-
@Arceus8523, I'm sorry if I'm not being clear enough about this. I do not mean that coin flipping as a recurring theme in itself is too complex; I was merely remarking on the complexity of that particular common card.
-
@Arceus8523, it's not the coin flipping that's the problem; that was just an example It just seems a bit too complex for a simple common.
-
I'm not sure how true this is (XD), but I heard that the first person to hear the Alexander Hamilton theme song though it was "Alligator Malletman."
-
@Arceus8523, you're right that some of the commons and uncommons need to be a little simplified. For example, the first common that comes up in the set (Aeronaut's Enginewear) involves coin flipping, changing of subtypes, and numerous activated abil…
-
@Tigersol, @Arceus8523, claro, what I meant was not that it's too easy to exile your opponent's creatures, but that we don't know exactly the power level, since WotC is hesitant to extrapolate on exile too much. Things got way too complicated with s…
-
The only trouble might be that it is so exile-heavy, something that other cards in other sets may not be able to contend with, as WotC tends to stay away from it.
-
@Arceus8523, @Tigersol, I am super excited to see Blackened Skies here, as a huge fan.
-
@IanLowenthal Okay, that's cool, I-- WHAT???????????????? XD
-
@Corwinn, thank you. Maybe the one I found was inspired by that one? Both are interesting. I saw it first on @TheMechanix's Crystal Sanctuary (https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/crystal-sanctuary-1). @NokiSkaur, what do you think of @Teacup's version? To…
-
@snowyriver21, yes; as @atrus159 pointed out it would have to be, "...cannot be blocked by creatures without..."
-
@TenebrisNemo, this is literally a druid with the Stoneskin spell from D&D XD
-
Here we go! Round Four! This round is going to be a little different, as I'm sure you remember from last season. I'm going to give ONE challenge for all of you to complete in a three-way battle. One of you will be eliminated at the end of the round,…
-
@NokiSkaur, how does the necromancer know that he has an un-ignited spark? As for crystallize, it would be a way to represent the spiraling thing (history swallowed, returned, etc.), because, remember, you don't have to crystallize creatures; it ca…
-
@NokiSkaur, yes; I just didn't understand the explanation XD Thanks for clarifying. Remember to change Spiral to "Spiral (At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the bottom card of your library and put it on the top. Spiral effects are cumulative.) …
-
@NokiSkaur, oh, okay I didn't get the up carrot above "hand"
-
XD
-
@Lujikul, DID YOU FREAKING READ WHAT I JUST WROTE???? You want to be killed, resurrected, killed again, etc. etc. etc.????
-
@NokiSkaur, I don't get Loku's cycle. Could you clarify, please?
-
@NokiSkaur, more like.... :::Commits suicide, resurrects self, kills self again, resurrects self, kills self again, etc. etc. etc. then repeat the process with every Magic card, Magic player, etc. etc. etc. , then set fire to all Magic paraphernalia…