MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MagicChess
About
- Username
- MagicChess
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,643
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ningyounk, official advice XD Not too shabby. Anyway, here is some feedback: - I think we should drop the "Grand" in the name. It doesn't serve a purpose, and I think 'grand' is portrayed pretty effectively, since they're legends and they buff or…
-
@TenebrisNemo, ten minutes is a long time! Try holding your breath for that long XD ....Of course I'll accept it.
-
Alright, this contest is closed for entries! I will begin judging and announce results soon.
-
@ningyounk, on your emotions: Now that I've had time to look them over more, I think that we should try to incorporate at least one little Muse into every color (a la Joyful Incarnation). For example, Loving Nature and Loving Support could each have…
-
Great work @ningyounk! This really fulfills the major things we were looking for in the Muses: they're not godlike (check), they're not huge game-enders by themselves (check), they represent an emotion (check), and they interact with life in some wa…
-
@Superman101, never underestimate the power of the Dark Side.... That was random XD
-
@Faiths_Guide, @ningyounk, hear, hear! @TezzeretofCarmot21, like I said to @ningyounk, I think that 5 mana is too much for Compose 3 or Compose 1 three times, especially since they die EOT. Four mana should do just fine, as long as the cmc is upped.
-
@ningyounk, great representation of emotions! This is exactly what we needed
-
@Mila, thanks
-
@Faiths_Guide, I'm sure there have been plenty before me, but hey... I entered it first XD
-
@symtheticreign, we changed it for a while, so I wasn't sure which version we had settled on. @ningyounk, I think the costs of the abilities are okay, since the tokens die EOT.
-
Haha I was inspired to do this by @Faiths_Guide's Knowledge-Hungry Thief XD It doesn't have flash or grant flash, but it needs to be given flash to work. @Mila, is this card viable?
-
@ningyounk, your interpretation of my Muses is correct XD I should have said that explicitly... Your version of Salendi is perfect. It supports Compose synergy decks, as well as ramp decks and just red aggro decks that make use of the extra mana. …
-
Still thinkin' about Salendi XD @TezzeretofCarmot21, while this newest Salendi is fine, I don't think it's fair for her to be an art lord and leave the other characters in the dust; nor do I think it's a good idea to have five art lords. A couple q…
-
@modnation675, no problem
-
@TezzeretofCarmot, uh... what he said XD Also, why first strike? I don't get it. Why is it relevant? And @modnation675 wasn't using 'chimera' in the literal sense; rather, they meant a creature that is a hybrid of sorts ("bird fish"). I'm working o…
-
@modnation675, @Faiths_Guide, @nsm91, no worries. This is a really hard challenge! You're all doing wonderfully.
-
Bumpitybumpbump
-
@TezzeretofCarmot, I don't think it makes sense for Salendi or the Art creatures to have first strike. In addition, I think Salendi should support the UR Virtuoso Control strategy more. Right now your card favors WR and BR, which aren't really rele…
-
@ningyounk, it costs 2 psylian life to get one mana, but I see your point
-
And also, let's talk about Virtuoso/Compose. 2 things: 1. While it would add words, I really think the Art tokens should be all colors, because that really feels like art to me. 2. I don't love the name Compose, because it has to do with music rathe…
-
@ningyounk, I see; good point. I wanted to convey the UB Art Thieves theme (obviously). Maybe there's a less literal way to do that? Hmm. I'll need to think about that. @Faiths_Guide, I think we weren't going to use reminder text for psylian life, …
-
The Rogue part of my defining uncommons. I'll do things other than avens, I promise! XD This art was just too good to pass up. For all you fellow D&D nerds out there, one of my characters is an Aaracrokra Way of the Shadow monk that this total…
-
@modnation675, I agree XD It's one of my own flaws.
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21, excellent
-
@TezzeretofCarmot21, unfortunately psylian lifelink is not a mechanic. We considered it, but eventually deemed it unnecessary and difficult to balance. Also, I don't know about the psylian life prevention; it's a very widespread mechanic, and nullif…
-
@Faiths_Guide, good question. We haven't really discussed this. I would guess mostly in green, white, and black, but I'm not sure. @ningyounk, any clarification? @Everyone, I just began working on some of the defining bicolored uncommons. What do y…
-
@Everyone: I'm back! *trumpets herald MagicChess's return as jubilant throngs flood the streets!* ... okay, I'm not really that conceited XD . . . Maybe just a little bit. Anyhoo, on to feedback! @TezzeretofCarmot21, we want to keep the Muses as d…
-
Hmm. I think the best option would be to make Virtuoso a verb, but I (1) really like the name, and (2) have trouble thinking up cool verbs that portray the same vibe. I'll be gone for a few days, so I guess I can shirk and see what you all come up …
-
Bump!