MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@EnvyReaper Does the card have a reverse side that you can put here as well? It tends to be pretty hard to define the balance of something when you can't actually see all of it, and for all we know then the other side is an overpowered monstrosity t…
-
@Fantastickill7 I've a suspicion that Zatio doesn't fit the conditions of the contest by dint of having a partially black color identity.
-
@Abu_Jafar I'm relatively certain that this is still a thing that's open to anybody. If you want to join, you can probably join.
-
Potentially, in my case. The question of how many others will also be joining will probably prove to be a major factor in my decision.
-
@Abu_Jafar Ah, I see what you mean. Good catch. I think Mir-151414 missed it. Since it'd be kind of messy for people to go back to them now, I'll just provide a few comments myself. Please note that since both cards have the commander set symbol, I'…
-
@Abu_Jafar I don't think you were. Dizzydude commented on yours (assuming you're talking about the Slinn Voda card, which seems to be your most recent thing on the thread). It's possible that he also faved it, but your card doesn't actually seem to …
-
@KorandAngels I don't know, because your comment was so incredibly non-detailed and sparse that I could potentially apply it to almost any card on this thread. Hint hint nudge nudge try and do comments that are slightly more in-depth if you can. Wi…
-
@KorandAngels Pretty sure that you should have been providing an opinion on / giving a favorite to Level20GnollBard's Gambling with the Devil.
-
Well, here's a thing: On a vaguely related note, I find it interesting how many of the entries for this seem to be black or black-red. Perhaps it's something to do with art availability, or perhaps it's just related to the mentality we've all pi…
-
@KorandAngels It looks like you've either rated the wrong card or that you've mentioned the wrong person. Your comment is so lacking in detail that I can't tell.
-
It is indeed a set. You haven't really asked for feedback and I'm certainly not going to trouble myself unnecessarily. I will say, however, that it does appear to contain a small but significant portion of cards that are clearly far too powerful or …
-
Hey, good to hear it. I'd kind of assumed this wasn't going to happen, but I guess I was wrong.
-
@Fantastickill7 I suspect you might've gotten your comments on the Mystery Box and Feedback threads the wrong way round.
-
@Dizzydude The art for Fallen Anarchist was a collaboration between Zoltan Boros & Gabor Szikszai, since you missed the artist. It was was used on the real MTG card Ith, High Arcanist.
-
Since the deadline's been extended, here's another one:
-
Because the edit function was recently given a one hour time period restriction, I can't edit something new into my previous post. However, I'd be most appreciative if you were to ignore the now-deleted Cranial Fixture (it had some issues and I don'…
-
Is it worth pointing out that the eldrazi could travel between planes already? Their whole thing is based around it.
-
@Abu_Jafar The art you've used there is by Raymond Swanland and comes from a real MTG card, Dread Drone. Try to credit art whenever possible, consider not using art if you can't and remember that saying "Pinterest" as the artist is completely pointl…
-
@KingWatherton You can't, or at least there isn't a formatting setup that's deliberately designed for it. You've got to do a lot of work with carefully placed hyphens and other symbols to artificially replicate what a real level up text box looks li…
-
@Level20GnollBard As DomriKade commented, Bloodmane Trader could (and probably should to better fit with what the color tends to do and be) be given a 2/1 statline. It's similar to Abbot of Keral Keep, but different enough that it exists in its own …
-
@KorandAngels The images of both of them are, actually. Faiths_Guide was just collecting the two cards that Level20GnollBard had put up for evaluation into a single comment, probably for clarity's sake and to ensure that people considered both of th…
-
Citizen has appeared on five cards in total. Three are from long ago and suggested that it was a white creature type, while the other two are more recent (Planewide Celebration and Mobilized District) with one of those being green and the other colo…
-
@shadow123 Last Grasp seems fine as a card in terms of balance. My main note about it would be the name, which might be a little too close to the real card Last Gasp. I'd personally be inclined to use something more unique or that makes a little mor…
-
Here's my entry for the tomb:
-
@SpellPiper2213 Through other effects, presumably. Something similar has been done before with Haakon, Stromgald Scourge, which also didn't set up for itself but made up for it through potential power. It's interesting, and also coincides with the c…
-
@Scott_Anderson The answer to there being too many enchantments (and, by the sound of it, artifacts) is probably to replace some of them with creatures, instants and sorcery cards, which should make up the bulk of any typical set. To give an example…
-
@Xero0 Press the </> button, insert the code and fill it in with html locations and image sources or whatever else you're doing, then press it again. Basically, you want to have the </> option turned on so long as you're manipulating ht…
-
First off, apologies for clogging up the comments with random, rambled rule definitions. @KorandAngels Simply having the word black on a card doesn't make the color identity include black. That'd mean that cards with things like "Protection from re…
-
A few initial questions as well as a point about a creature type: - Do you want opinions aimed at particular balance areas, such as limited and standard? Should this set be viewed as though it's a standard set when considering balance? - Are you…
-
@Temurzoa Who needs base power and toughness when you can accidentally ignite the play area?