MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
While I can't claim to know exactly what you're planning for this, I do wonder whether you'd be better off doing this on google docs or something unless you're actively looking for other people's opinions and contributions or whatever. The forum's d…
-
I know this is largely irrelevant, but Verdict of the Winged Ones employs the same flavor text as the real card Divine Verdict in exactly the same context. It probably wasn't deliberate and it's interesting to see the whole "separate groups coming u…
-
@Fantastickill7 - The lack of target is necessary as targets are chosen as you cast a spell, while this is chosen as that part of the effect resolves (and so you can pick cards from among the things it mills as part of the effect). You can see thi…
-
@Fantastickill7 Do you mind if I ask what those wording errors are? It always helps to know where you've made mistakes and even critically rereading it, I can't find anything wrong.
-
@sorinjace Since you haven't written 1st, 2nd and 3rd next to any of them, would I be correct in thinking that Mercyque, Dreaming Duality is third, Malicious Tutor is second and Consortium of Ambition has won? Whatever it is, congratulations to all…
-
@KorandAngels While I see what you're going for, there are a few mechanical and balance-related flaws. I'll try to cover them and how you might fix them as best I can, so here goes: - To quote the rules: ---------------------------- 702.25f When a…
-
An old one and a new one, in that order:
-
Since every Peasant currently in the game either interacts with or has an adventure in Naya colors, I decided to go with the current tribal identity (insofar as about five cards can provide such a thing). Regardless, making the adventure cards is pr…
-
@Temurzoa I've got a sneaking suspicion that you've missed the most recent page. The current cards so far as I can tell are Liwg's Constant Warring and Kholgumas, Plane Killer.
-
@Revan Sort of. You can do things like create a game and then make it friends-only (if the person you want to play is on your friends list) or add an entry password and tell it only to the other person. There isn't a way to directly issue a challeng…
-
@Fantastickill7 I'll keep my comments on the silver-bordered COVID brief, so I'll just say that the word "contagious" (for the mechanic) needs to be italicised and that there should be a space on both sides of the long dash immediately following it.…
-
-
Is the fact that the official MTG thing for dogs is "Hound" relevant, or is this a reference to Ruff, Underdog Champ? Or is it neither, I guess.
-
@TechXT To elaborate on the point made by KorandAngels a little (well, the one that existed before he removed the comment), the wording is almost, but not quite right. It should be something like: Pay 1 life, Sacrifice this enchantment: Target unbl…
-
@KorandAngels A "double combat phase" is probably a reference to cards that give you additional combat phases. To give an example in case you don't know what I mean:
-
@Scott_Anderson It looks like those cards were made using a program separate to Cardsmith called Magic Set Editor (MSE). It gives access to a lot of frames because it's open source, people can create and share templates for it and so on.
-
@TechXT So just to clarify, you're saying that these are being made with the balance levels of a standard-legal set in mind? Also, if you can't find artists, please just leave the box empty or put "unknown" in there or something. It can cause genui…
-
The post's totally acceptable, don't worry about it. Feedback's basically one of the central pillars of custom creation, so it'd be crazy if everybody got annoyed about you asking for it. I'm going to go over each of the cards very briefly, outlini…
-
@DrakeGladis Paying life isn't something red and white do often, especially when they're together (the only example of it as a theme that comes to mind is the white vampires from Ixalan). There are numerous red cards such as Char that deal damage to…
-
@KorandAngels Yes, but the same could be said of all keywords. They do something that you could just write out manually, but if you've got lots of cards in the same set doing that same thing then it's far better to keyword. This Fatecast mechanic, …
-
@Revan I think I probably saw it once (like, 10 years ago or something) but I don't really know anything more of it than a vague story and a few specific scenes.
-
@Scaccogaming I'll start off with a wording fix, then move on to feedback on the concept itself. ----------------------------------------------- Fading 3 (This creature enters the battlefield with five [word, not number] fade counters on it. At the …
-
Time to reference a film that I don't even really know, but seems to fit this pretty well:
-
@Fantastickill7 I'm going to talk briefly about Uncontrollable Inferno, then complain about Havena. Here goes: Uncontrollable Inferno seems relatively fair and relatively safe. My main point with it is that the graveyard ability should have the car…
-
@Liwg Assuming that you missed them, the rules of the thread are that you either provide feedback on or give a favorite to the card or cards the previous person put up, then post up to two cards of your own. It's to ensure that the whole "Actually s…
-
@Bowler218 I think that people are interested specifically in being able to do the old HTML image linking, not just making an image appear. The HTML's a lot easier to resize and manipulate and you can embed a link in it.
-
@ouser94501 You'd have to elaborate on what your idea for the wording would be for me to really be able to comment. It's worth noting that each player only has one exile zone, though, so if you were being literal with that statement then you'll have…
-
@ouser94501 Devoted Leonin's art is by Steven Belledin and it comes from a real MTG card, Leonin Armorguard. Talking about the rebirth mechanic: it's not necessarily a good idea. The purpose of exile in MTG is that it can't be interacted with outsi…
-
@WarriorCatInAhat I've got some feedback for your card and felt it would be easiest to leave it here. Apologies in advance to anybody who thinks I should take my rules criticism somewhere other than a flavor contest, but the point about the artist c…