MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Faiths_Guide I do wonder whether it might be preferable to work it around "As this spell resolves", though I'm aware that it's less conventional and unsure as to what the precise wording would be. I also feel like somebody did a bunch of cards wit…
-
This seems a little unclear, so I'm going to pose a few questions and an important point: - Is this supposed to be a contest or a set creation? It's got aspects of both (prizes / scoreboard from a contest, but classed and stated as a custom card s…
-
@KorandAngels I'm going to try and do a quick list of potential reasons. These are only what I think might be the main reasons and so could be completely incorrect. - Your contests tend not to be clearly defined. This is certainly one of the main…
-
If you're trying to build a generic food deck without getting into any extra-fancy gimmicks, I'd recommend that the deck is Golgari colors (black-green) because it's the only color combination that got a lot of active food support other than Oko *an…
-
I'm always interested in this sort of thing, so here are my main questions, observations and random things I can write down that I can't really think of good descriptors for: - If the rules dictate that you can only lose by life or sort-of-super-m…
-
For the sake of stating the potentially obvious, I'd recommend that you try to keep this a safe distance away from looking like a redone Alara.
-
@KorandAngels Why? What's wrong with blue as creativity? Give it a break from being the evil "I want everybody to fit my ideas / things perfectly and also I'm the villain" color for a change.
-
Assuming that the set would be balanced and made to the logic of an actual set (draftable and so on as opposed to simply being a heap of a thousand cards) then I don't think it would ever be completed. This community doesn't exactly have a great tr…
-
Sorry about mine. I've been working on too much other stuff to get an entry in (and didn't really have any ideas for the challenge that I thought would be good enough) and just forgot to say that that was the case here.
-
So is this supposed to be a challenge? If so, what are we meant to be creating?
-
A couple of old works:
-
@shadow123 Good round and nice card. I'm sorry to see you go.
-
I'm not totally sure why I used existing art for this, though my best guess would be that I was frustrated by being unable to find art that fits a homunculus at the time.
-
For the sake of asking the question that seems to pop up in every contest: are old cards allowed?
-
@Faiths_Guide I already went over this with DomriKade over on the community discord. For the sake of copy-and-pasting my main arguments directly over: I'd argue that it might be correct in a fashion similar to cards that refer to themselves while s…
-
-
Here's my entry for round 1. Sorry to those it might have inconvenienced by being a little late:
-
@shadow123 I haven't got one up yet because I was slightly late due to being in the bye round. I'll have it up in a few hours at the worst. Sorry.
-
@Norzael There's also me, off in my little bye round. I won't be able to make a card until sometime tomorrow (for me). If that last entry comes in and you want to get the second round moving, feel free to do so and I'll just get my first entry in ma…
-
-
In relation to this whole gender thing, only planeswalkers or the double-sided cards that show a 'walker as a creature on one side and a planeswalker on the other (the five from Origins and the Bolas card from M19) refer to themselves by gender.
-
In relation to this incident, I'd like to request that the results of rounds are presented in a fashion that's a little bit more feedback-and-explanation based, if only so that people can see the justification for why they won / lost and we don't ge…
-
Got beaten to asking that question, but I'd also be extremely interested in the answer.
-
@Norzael I hadn't actively planned to join originally and had just been telling KorandAngels what was happening, but yes, I think I'll join.
-
@KorandAngels Now you wait until there are enough entrants. Once that happens, Norzael will post further rules and what's happening.
-
A combination of an entry and a test to see whether making adventures permanents (as opposed to instant / sorcery spells) is a remotely viable idea:
-
ThatOneCat and I worked on an idea he had that was relatively similar to this (the things were roles, similar to the monarch) and eventually ended up condensing the idea down to four commander precon-style decks (as opposed to a whole new format) be…
-
This sounds fun and I totally agree with you on how cool this card type tends to look. I'll be sure to try and do something for it. On an utterly unrelated note, Coiling Mortality doesn't work. It'd need you to reveal your hand or something to prov…
-
Ah, I see what you mean. I'm a dummy, sorry.
-
There's a difference between "Choose any number" (as appears on Rankle) and "Choose one or more" (as you gave as what it would previously have been the wording). With Rankle, you can choose to have none of the options occur, while the other wording …