MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Congratulations to all of the other winners and thanks to @Je_Suis_Oluwa for going to the trouble of running this and giving everybody feedback.
-
@Corwinnn I'm going to assume that you should close this up.
-
Fatechange in green will have to be carefully limited and might have to be changed slightly (the only card selection akin to it are cards where you look at the top N cards of your library, put one card of a specific type (typically a creature or a l…
-
Right, here's some feedback: White - Card draw is something that has to be trod around carefully in white. One of the color's biggest weaknesses is that it can't draw lots of cards. Consistent card draw on lots of different cards isn't really part …
-
@KorandAngels Revolt triggers if a permanent you control has left the battlefield this turn. The difference between that and a creature dying is huge. The comparison to morbid that's mentioned alongside the unkeyworded ability is far more apt.
-
Assuming that this is a contest, when does it close?
-
Right, here are some random comments on the mechanics: It's good that you seem to recognise how powerful fatebender is in that it's basically fateseal that can be converted into scrying. Be really careful with it, especially those higher-than-ones…
-
@Tommia I pointed this out over on the Discord as well, but I might as well say it here too: you can cascade into this to win instantly. Cards you cascade into are exiled and then, should you choose to play them, they've been cast from exile. Sorry…
-
@KorandAngels First off, yes. It's aimed at commander. Second, you could technically get thirteen counters outside of EDH through reanimation, flickering, blinking, proliferate effects and other such trickery (though you could only do that in legac…
-
-
Is this one actually a challenge that'll get judged or is it just another "Cards go here" thing?
-
First off, here's the timeline that was released of upcoming sets for 2020: Before any of those release, Throne of Eldraine will release. I'll assume that you know what that is and largely leave it be. If you don't, it's a set abut Grimm's fairy …
-
@Fallen_Lord_Vulganos Well, if you're playing against aggro or burn and you've got nothing better to do then you can curse yourself with it for a supply of life-gaining food that might offset all of those Lightning Bolts being aimed at you.
-
@Tommia Yep, just a little busy with the whole being poisoned thing.
-
@ThePhantomJoker Good match. @Tommia Is the artifact that forces me into being an artificer that I made a joke to you?
-
Nice work, everybody, and congratulations to the winners!
-
If you're asking for an argument of why the sword shouldn't use Phyrexian mana, my main one would be this: It's Phyrexian mana. It basically represents selling your humanity to the Phyrexian corruption in return for power. You know, exactly what the…
-
As another thing, are you trying to run this as a contest or as set creation? At current you seem to be trying to do both at once, which won't really work because most people will just make one or two cards and then wait for the overly-far-away end …
-
So if these are based on the flavor of being the resistance, why are you using Phyrexian mana in the ability on the sword? Also, for the sake of saying it, Phyrexian mana is a very powerful mechanic that's generally kind of overpowered. If you inten…
-
Core 2021 was described on the livestream as "Do you like Teferi?" and so I think I'll hold judgement on that particular subject with a side order of distaste. Hey, at least if they make three Teferi cards like they made three Chandra cards in Core …
-
So if the set was actually printed, are you saying that it would appear as a set that people would be able to play in standard? If that's the case, you want to be balancing cards primarily towards the standard format. If you want to do it as an EDH-…
-
Right, assuming you want feedback and opinions, here goes: My first impression is that far too many cards cost far too much mana. It's always nice to see a few big, expensive cards in a set, but the fact that I'm seeing masses of cards that cost se…
-
Right, remind the Phyrexians to call an exorcist before this is over.
-
@ThePhantomJoker Pretty sure that since the challenge asks for exactly one card then there should only be a single entry. Pick one, I suppose.
-
Hmm. Bump. That makes a full eight.
-
@Pepperoni Annihilator only triggers when the card actually attacks, so entering attacking (as it would due to ninjutsu) won't trigger it. Neat concept, though.
-
@ThePhantomJoker Red / black hybrid for blinking? Are you sure you haven't mixed that up with a different effect?
-
@Xioni Just make a faction and some cards to fit the requirements up at the top, then post them here and you're good to go.