MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Tommia Huh, ignite seems neat. I'd like to say, however, that being a 'walker seems to take priority over being a mere whatever-the-heck-else (as seen on assorted Gideons, though I'll admit that none of them are creatures all of the time). I'd sti…
-
@ManaChrome Ooh, nice card idea. I'll put my my vote in for this new commander being balanced.
-
@HeroKP I'd be up for trying to make that.
-
@Arceus8523 Eyy, somebody else who's heard of Lorado!
-
I would be up for this except for the fact that I'm currently trying to work with @EnvyReaper over a DIFFERENT crazy billion-card pipe dream. I'd say that you wouldn't need to give each faction 40 cards. If you think about something like Ravnica Al…
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 Fantastic, now I'm having PTSD flashbacks to being murdered. Also, for the sake of nominating some music at random based on the description of mountains and secrets given by @HeroKP in the opening thing (and certainly not based on…
-
Even though my natural faction is Duxos or Jugralia, I'm probably going to go with Eseria just so that we've got somebody standing for them.
-
I REGRET NOTHING!
-
@iplaypokemongoeveryday That's clearly the wrong response. *Cough* SQUIRRELS ARE GOING TO TAKE OVER! YEEEESSSSSSSSS!!!!!
-
When all else fails, hunt down some really good art and make full art promo cards:
-
-
I'd definitely be in favour of it.
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 Artifact creatures in GW would feel weird unless we made artifacts into a larger theme of the set, so that's probably a good idea. It also means that I don't have to specifically hunt down friendly-looking living statue art for alm…
-
@EnvyReaper I am fully on board with that.
-
Disclaimer: I had nothing whatsoever to do with the making and general design of the following, but it's really neat and also, I suppose, a demonstration of what you've got to beat. http://www.planesculptors.net/set/lorado
-
I'm with @MonkeyPirate2002 on this, that would be a lot less confusing for everybody.
-
@EnvyReaper @HeroKP So we're making an unstable format now?!
-
@HeroKP I left some feedback on Biomancer's Nexus, though it might not be good feedback if the card was made strictly for this format. To everybody, I'll get working on something.
-
@Tommia I haven't played enough WAR to have any really big contributions to make, but all the planeswalkers and stuff seem pretty fun from the limited I've played (less so the God-Eternal cycle). On the subject of the set plan, making creatures wit…
-
@MonkeyPirate2002 That seems like a good suggestion so I've made the change.
-
Opinions, please! I'm primarily after opinions on the mechanic in terms of either red-black or any triple-colour combination that includes red and black (Jund, Mardu and Grixis). Opinions on the card are welcome too, I guess, but it's more of a d…
-
@HeroKP For the sake of pointing out a problem, counters other than +1/+1 and -1/-1 don't exist in the game any more for good reasons. For the sake of pointing out another, Willowseer's Wisdom is in the wrong colour identity for that. @EnvyReaper (…
-
@HeroKP Is that the blue-green faction? Do they have a name, an identity and a general existence now?
-
@EnvyReaper As @MonkeyPirate2002 just asked, a rule clarification on how fealty works would be nice. For the sake of looking like I'm doing something, here are some more random concepts that probably have glaring balance issues. I'm posting them in…
-
@Je_Suis_Oluwa I mentioned Forerunner of the Coalition primarily for the strange potential and I'm also of the opinion that it isn't good enough.
-
@Brainifyer I think that it depends on the creature and what control decks would end up looking like. Slower decks like Carnage Tyrant probably would. Faster ones like Gutterbones probably wouldn't.
-
@Red_Tower You should probably post a link somewhere around here to the set with your cards in it (I can't find one right now). Also, I was considering using Amplify as a mechanic for this so it's cool to see that somebody else has.
-
For the sake of saying what I've just realised I should have said, I'll make some cards and join if others do.
-
@EnvyReaper I can try to get people on board, but being told "We're making a cube with 1500 cards" is a pretty worrying thing to hear.
-
@SammySammyson @KorandAngels At current, tapping a Forest for Dancer in the Trees in relation to its ability will pay for R, not RG. For the sake of explaining, it's like how convoke is worded: Convoke (Your creatures can help cast this spell. Each…