MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@joemamajoe What would be the reasoning you'd apply to a transforming / double-sided card? Would it count as a single entry, and would the word counts of both sides be added together?
-
Anybody remember Swarmyard? I do.
-
From what I know then you're basically right about the lore. A (largely irrelevant) thing I'd mention in conjunction with the Khans / Dragons idea is the siege cycle from Fate Reforged, which was vaguely similar in that you chose between the two sid…
-
@Alextorrez6 It's a thing where people enter cards every week in the hope of qualifying, and you don't need to have entered for prior weeks. There are still a couple of weeks to go, so yep, you certainly can.
-
Whoo! Congratulations to all of the other winners, and thank you @shadow123 for such a great contest. I really feel like I'll be far more inclined to make low word-count cards in the future, and it spawned a whole bunch of good concepts in my brain …
-
@joemamajoe I'm just going to make some points: - There aren't any wording errors on either of the cards. That's always good. However, I get the sense that the flavor text on External Suffering is just somehow slightly off. At the bare minimum, I'…
-
@fire12 Wait, are you sure that that's a rule? You're the only person I've ever seen invoking it in any way, and it isn't mentioned in any of the rule thingies / previous threads relating to this that I'm aware of (admittedly I have no idea how many…
-
@QuetzalPali Well, here we are again. Wording, then feedback: Partner with OTHERCARDNAME ["Partner with" normally goes at the top, not the bottom] Wurm spells you cast cost {2} less to cast. Whenever a Wurm creature enters the battlefield under yo…
-
I doubt that this pair'll need any explanation of their interaction, so please welcome to the stage:
-
@fire12 Totally agree that two mana for two 1/1 haste creatures and further upside is too good for uncommon, but I've got a suspicion that you've misread Garrison Charge's mana cost (or perhaps confused it with that of Ela's Swiftblade). It's a thre…
-
@QuetzalPali Wordings. Gourthun, then Dalamia: Hexproof, reach, trample [that order, no need for any other than the first to be capitalised] Whenever [not "when"] CARDNAME enters the battlefield or attacks, destroy target enchantment. If you do, ot…
-
@JMGreer41 Wording, then feedback. Stuff in square brackets is notes, not part of the actual wording: Enchant nonland permanent Whenever enchanted permanent [no caps] becomes the target of a spell or becomes tapped, its controller loses 1 [number 1…
-
@East2West Yep, it needs HTML. An example of the HTML I use would be:
The "AAA"s get filled in with the page link and the image address respectively while the "width=NUMBE…
-
@RandomFandom Please don't dredge up threads that are months old (since they're probably no longer in use and vaguely need closing or whatever, not to be bought back to the front to take up space and push out more relevant posts) and especially don'…
-
I get an immediate sense that Altar tokens might need some reworking or something. They're heavily color-locked (all the things that make them are basically going to have to have black on them) and I suspect that they'd also be a pain to design a se…
-
When you say card set, presumably you mean that our entry should be a single "pack" of two or three cards, and that we can only enter one of these packs? Just looking to clarify. Also, is your focus specifically on the default partner (with anythin…
-
@BurningWaffle It seems like you've gotten confused, because spy was one of the mechanics for last week. This week's list of mechanics is near to the bottom of the first page.
-
@fire12 Wording: Archery 3 (This creature enters the battlefield with three arrow counters on it.) At the beginning of your upkeep, CARDNAME deals X damage to you, where X is the number of arrow counters on it. Then, remove an arrow counter from it…
-
@BurningWaffle I don't know whether it's this way for everyone, but I can't see any of the images that you're (presumably) trying to post.
-
@LordTachanka123 At least it isn't negative, I guess.
-
@Crimsonspill Thanks for the feedback. I might have been being overly cautious with Teysa's Demands because I was worried about the sheer number of tokens it could net you (either that or it makes your extortion free). I think I'll keep the Profitee…
-
@fire12 General feedback: - X isn't something that permanent cards "remember" once they're on the battlefield. As such, the ability that defines power and toughness won't be able to "remember" what X was and so doesn't work. - You probably want …
-
@fire12 Fair, and I very much deserved that. I descended into complaining over constructive, and I apologise for doing so. For the sake of atoning for that mistake, a few points that are hopefully less utterly dreadful and more useful: - The card …
-
@RandomFandom Understandable, and it's the one I was most uncertain of as fitting. I'll take it out.
-
@fire12 Cripes, that's a thing. A warning in advance: This is going to get kind of rant-y and pretty critical. Hope you don't mind. I'll start with an attempt at the wording, then move on to balance and stuff: Whenever an opponent taps a land for ma…
-
Here are a couple of new cards: And a couple of old: Hope all of these fit the conditions except the one that isn't here any more because it didn't!
-
I'm no longer willing to do this. I created it in a not-really-mentally-focused spur of the moment thing, and now I'm regretting doing so. Apologies to anybody whose time's been wasted by me doing this, primarily @SNAPcreator7 and @Revan since they'…
-
@TerryTags This isn't an actual review of the card or anything, but since you might not know about it and might be interested for the purpose of a cycle like this, have you heard of Grove of the Burnwillows (and its role in getting Punishing Fire ba…
-
@Crimsonspill No problem, feedback's something I like doing. It tends to help me mull over new ideas vaguely based on whatever I'm cards I'm considering and concepts I'm feeding back on. However, I suspect that this might end up being a lengthy back…
-
@Crimsonspill Wording, then balance and other stuff: Unrelenting (At the beginning of each opponent's end step, if a creature an opponent controls died this turn, return this card from your graveyard to the battlefield with a -1/-1 counter on it.) …