MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
MemoryHead
About
- Username
- MemoryHead
- Joined
- Visits
- 5,188
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@JMGreer41 Unless you're specifically going for an old-card vibe, you've set this up as an aura incorrectly. The correct setup and wording would be: Gaea's Eye 2GGG Enchantment - Aura Enchant land Whenever enchanted land becomes tapped…
-
Well, this looks neat. Congratulations on having built a full set, they're always crazy undertakings and it's nice to see them when they're done. Under the assumption that you might be interested in a little bit of feedback, here's a second opinion …
-
@Scaccogaming Did I ever say Dimir didn't fit? I don't remember that, and if I did then I'll acknowledge that I screwed up badly. Since I was just running off of whatever some Google searches could tell me for knowledge on the subject, thank you fo…
-
@fire12 Oh boy, a color hate card. It doesn't really have any direct equivalents for comparison (they all either cost far more or have certain conditions etc.) and I'm inclined to say that it's relatively balanced, but I'll break down a few points f…
-
Right, I'm going to do some feedback because apparently I just have nothing better to do right now. I'll start off by talking about themes and things throughout all of the cards, then get on to an individual card breakdown if I've got time. In case …
-
@fire12 I'll start this off by saying that I haven't balance-reviewed a card in about three months, so it might be worth taking my thoughts on balance with a few pinches of salt. Anyway, here's a little breakdown: - Most importantly, you have the …
-
@Temurzoa First off, the wording has a few super minor issues. It should probably be: Exile all cards from your graveyard. For each creature card exiled this way, create a token that's a copy of it, except it's a 0/0. For each noncreature, nonland c…
-
-
@The-DM A cube is made up of a collection of cards, most commonly 360 of them. In order to play with a cube, you deal out those cards randomly into lots of 15-card piles (to emulate packs of cards) and then draft those cards. The big pulls of cubes …
-
@Liwg Right, so I'll start by talking about the mechanic: - There doesn't need to be a hyphen between Opportunity N and the reminder text. - In the reminder text, the numerical "2" should be the word "two", and any equivalent numbers should have…
-
I've... actually only made a few Goblins, apparently, and one is a result of this. I thought it'd be more. Ah well, here's a new one and an older one:
-
@The-DM Good characters aren't necessarily known for massive feuds that include summoning the Eldrazi onto the other character's home plane, destroying their ancestral home, and inflicting eternal torture upon their brethren.
-
My username is MemoryHead. My favorite thing I've made myself is really hard to decide, but Ascendant of Fourfold Paths is certainly among them, so it can take the top spot. Similarly, deciding favorite cards made by other people is painful. I'm goi…
-
Umm... ah... Quick, me! Do something! 1) Press the </> button in the comment window to open the HTML editor mode. 2) Copy and paste (or type manually for some unknowable reason) this code:@joemamajoe Clash is already the name of a real mechanic from the Lorwyn block.@Ilmarinen Right then, here's some feedback: - The wording looks perfect. The visuals are basically perfect, though you could just possibly have used an underscore divider line for the flavor text to ensure that the text was perfectly centred (equ…@Scaccogaming Ah, okay. Makes sense, I guess. Regardless, remember that you should probably be trying to prioritise the flavor of the tarot over trying to balance out colors in a set that clearly hasn't been based on color-balance principles anyway.…@Scaccogaming Surely The Sun would fit well as Red / White? They tend to be the most passion / love colors respectively, white relates nicely to fortune along with red's focus on treasure or value, white is enlightenment, so on. I feel like they'd a…@The-DM The vast majority of them are using already-real art. I suspect that the creator just isn't bothered.@joemamajoe The method I use is to type out a tab (the indent you put at the start of lines) using a separate word processor (I use Google documents) and then copy-and-paste that tab onto the start of a line in the Cardsmith editor. You then put how…@LordTachanka123 That doesn't actually stop people from commenting on it. A moderator is capable of setting a thread so that it actually can't have any more comments posted on it, though.@The-DM I hate to be a naysayer, but I kind of feel that combining creatures saw its black-bordered incarnation with the release of mutate in Ikoria. I guess this contest works, but I'm just putting it out there that this borders on another thing th…@LordTachanka123 Okay. In that case, remember that if you're trying to build it properly, the set'll probably need to have a legends-matter theme because that whole mechanic will be worthless without it.*Flashbacks in progress, please stand by* I remember that art, at least. Still just as confusing now as it was back then.@jaceberlin Hergusbergus is making Saga cards by using a program called Magic Set Editor, which tends to get abbreviated to MSE.@jaceberlin Do you specifically want new cards (made after the contest started) and / or new mechanics (invented after the contest started) or is the use of old cards and / or mechanics acceptable? Also, is there any sort of definitive judging date…@LordTachanka123 MonkeyPirate probably posted a card or cards that didn't follow the contest rules, then realised and edited their comment to replace them with that statement.@jaceberlin Just a reminder that you're also supposed to post one of your favorite cards created by another Cardsmith, and that if you're actually interested in the premium then you'll need to put your username from over on the site in the comment a…@jaceberlin Are our entries supposed to be new creations? Presumably I can't just dig half a dozen cards out of one of my finished sets and throw them into here.@spookoops From what I've been able to gather from conversation over on the discord, what this text is supposed to mean is that Falme can block creatures with evasion keywords such as flying, things that have been made unblockable by their own or ot…