MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Phelgming
About
- Username
- Phelgming
- Joined
- Visits
- 904
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
Wow, I didn't think I'd do this poorly. I was really confident this time. Last time I didn't think I did very well. Well, guess I better step up my game.
-
I present my vertical cycle. I honestly wanted to go a Green one since no one else has posted any Green cards, but it's been a really rough week and I had to scrap my original vertical cycle fairly late into the week. Anyway, I'm still very happy wi…
-
@MTG_Sappy No, but I still might even if I don't enter them into the contest. @bnew07 Unfortunately for me... -_-' ... That's alright, though. I feel like my new designs are shaping up to be better than my previous ones.
-
I'd like to formally accuse bnew07 of being a mind reader/taker. His cards have similar mechanics, flavor, and art as the cards I was about to make (although my cards were going to be White and focus on number of creature you control). Glad I checke…
-
Honored to take second place. I didn't actually think my cards were up to snuff (my formatting was poor across a couple cards), but I will take it. Congratulations to bnew07! Very deserved!
-
Wow, I worked faster than I expected myself too especially considering I'm a little tipsy. Churned out the following cards in like an hour or so (ngl, I gave no thought to what cards they'd replace in M21; I just wanted to make a bunch of common…
-
Cool! Now this is my kind of contest! Been thinking about making one for commons for a while, but never had the time or motivation. I hope to submit my own entries before the deadline. I don't plan to win (I'm more an art critic than an actual artis…
-
Here are my entries. I wanted each one to do something different from the others. Hopefully they all do something interesting. Please see my comments under each card and, if anyone would like, please leave comments (and critiques!) of your own. Than…
-
If I'm not too late, I'd like to submit a few entries later this evening. If I am too late, then my apologies for the pointless post.
-
My nomination is DomriKade's "Viper's Guile". https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/vipers-guile I nominate it as I believe it demonstrates a thorough understanding of both balance and the mechanical depth of the Color Pie. Very typical of DomriKade's des…
-
I think Debnas/UBRG shouldn't be a group/army/faction. It should rather be a category of individuals each striving to take power exclusively for themselves. If each color combination is defined by what it's not, you have to rip every bit of White's…
-
Isn't haste secondary in Green already?
-
@Faiths_Guide My mistake. I was not aware and that's something I could have easily made myself aware of. I got overly excited. As for your card, first, can you not just put X in the loyalty counter display? I don't actually know. I haven't made eno…
-
My mistake.
-
@TenebrisNemo Not going to lie, Dreadful is pretty incredible. It's simple, intuitive, easy to balance, can show up at any rarity, and it's effective; it's got everything a good keyword needs. I could even see it being a real evergreen keyword. I …
-
Am I behated here or something? Serious question. I'm not against "fun" or unserious cards. If I were, I would speak up against squirrels and, lately, porgs (or whatever the meme of the month might happen to be at any given time). My concern here…
-
Someone needs to do something about these things. There are a lot of subpar cards hitting the front page and they're all from the same group of creators and all have the same people favoriting them and they're all fruit dragons. Seems like they're t…
-
I ended up deleting the last one. I made a couple errors on it and I unfortunately couldn't find a way to properly edit planeswalker cards. Anyway, here's the new version with the errors corrected. I apologize for the hassle.
-
@Swegboss12 Thank you! That's the exact feeling I wanted to come through (well, minus the OP part). Admittedly I was unsure about his power level and waffled between making him cost 5 or 6 mana. Edit: If anyone has anything to say, please go ahead …
-
My second entry: See below
-
My first entry:
-
Sooo... I guess this is over, huh?
-
Salvage the Void isn't a good common regardless of whether or not it's balanced. Commons need to be simple in design as per New World Order guidelines. Complicated cards scare off new players and easily understood cards bring them in. Commons are m…
-
@Zombieswithjetpacks I tend to agree with you with the haste as it grants a massive board swing in one turn (possibly more than a 6-drop should be able to accomplish), but as far as its triggered ability goes, I think it's perfectly fine. The way I …
-
Here are my entries: That their weapons meet each other here is a lovely coincidence.
-
Here are my two entries:
-
For Dimension Snare, the wording is actually fine as is. I made sure to check when I made it. Reference Banisher Priest and Banishing Light which only use reminder text. Also reference Quarantine Field which has no reminder text. I suppose I could…
-
Anything that makes White at the very least a good color (not too much to ask for). That said, I dream of a Standard where White is just the undisputed best color (not necessarily to a huge degree; just enough to make it THE best color). I'd joke a…
-
My entries:
-
My entries: Missed the bit about entries having to be new, but, if it helps my position, at the very least this card never received any attention the first time around (it's why I'm submitting this and not another, well-liked card I designed a whi…