MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Platypusburger
About
- Username
- Platypusburger
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,082
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Tigersol , don't take the cards too literally. If you do, you have to wonder things like how a demon (Razaketh) is almost twice as strong as any of the gods. The Gatewatch loses, but that doesn't mean they die. Besides, Jace has been spoiled as be…
-
@Tigersol , don't get your hopes up. The Gatewatch isn't all going to die. In fact, probably none of them will, except possibly Gideon.
-
@Tigersol , yeah he did. But if he was gonna pop up again anywhere, it would have been in the block that brought back Phyrexians.
-
@Tigersol , you're right. That was the greatest missed opportunity since Mishra wasn't in Scars block.
-
@Latinas , it's a bit of a mistake to call Kaladesh the "Indian block". Rather, it's the "steampunk block", with a little bit of Indian art design for aesthetics. It is quite explicitly not a block that was designed to reflect an ancient culture, li…
-
@syntheticreign , blocking does not tap creatures at all, so your out doesn't work there.
-
@Lujikul , assuming it's untapped, of course. That was unclear of me, but I was referring specifically to a creature like Gelectrode's, with vigilance. @syntheticreign , what makes you think that just because you declared it as an attacker that you…
-
If a creature attacks during another player's combat phase, can it also block during that same phase?
-
It's kinda weird that this turned into an argument about annihilator. (Regardless of its power, I argue against it because it's too anti-fun.) @Mellenius , I see a couple problems, some of which some others have already pointed out. 1. The first i…
-
@modnation675 , wasn't that announcement part of the plan going forward to the no-block model, i.e. not taking effect until after Ixalan?
-
@Mellenius , pretty much every major character in the story has a card that's already been revealed for them. There aren't many good options, except perhaps Hapatra. Personally, I don't expect to see any other walker cards in this set, besides Bola…
-
I have another challenge: make a card representing a mythical creature that is new to you. (In other words, go google a list of mythical creatures from various world cultures, pick one you've never encountered before, learn a little about it, and m…
-
@Karmadragon . Thanks for the contest! I'll take faves on whichever cards you'd like to dispense them to, same as TenebrisNemo. Congratulations to all the other winners and HMs!
-
I'm privileged to bring you a card that I would strangle someone for playing.
-
@Faiths_Guide , @Lujikul , I highly recommend you both look into Vonnegut's books. He's a fantastic author. I always liked Slaughterhouse 5, in particular. Anyway, I challenge you to create a card that can't be cast or played from the hand.
-
-
@Karmadragon , doesn't Rakdos the Defiler count as the Commander for Demon-tribal?
-
I've tried to puzzle through this one before. The key wrinkle is that you're trying to reconcile a 5-variable system (five colors of mana) with a 3-variable system (the three alignments along the order track and morality track). There's no way those…
-
Here's my version of Teferi, who has taken his arcane understanding of time and applied it to more... practical purposes. Original/New Version:
-
Planeswalker sparks at birth? I can only imagine the number of times a baby has accidentally transported itself to somewhere like Grixis because it had a tantrum.
-
@Brainifyer , same as Vyktur, if you please.
-
@modnation675 That would certainly qualify.
-
A spell that interacts with objects in the command zone.
-
What's more, he has a challenge for you!
-
Vorthos is here to test your card knowledge!
-
@Baron-777 , sure thing!
-
@TheAcidicSniper , @HenryTheHatter , @theimmortaldeath , @Faiths_Guide , @Animist , @Credius , @Cybernekit Thank you all for your submissions! The contest is concluded, and the winners are as follows: Best Planeswalker Card: Brigitte Haerkenlaer,…
-
Nice submissions so far, everyone! (Also, bump)
-
Which of these mechanics are you considering random filler? Vehicles and energy were the backbone of the Kaladesh block.
-
Here's a Masterpiece for you!