MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Platypusburger
About
- Username
- Platypusburger
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,082
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@sanjaya666 , remember there's a submission limit of 3. You can post as many as you like, but let me know which ones you want submitted to the contest.
-
I'm loving a lot of these submissions! @Faiths_Guide , yes, an effect that defines a card's color identity generally applies in all zones. A different question is what happens in the case of a tie for devotion, though.
-
I'd be curious to see what deck lists you make from these. Marie Antoinette Domus Aurea de Curcubeu Mare Angra Mainyu, Corrupted Grail Shared Pain Mischievous Tutor It's a Trap! Atalanta Passionlip Melt Virus Ballet Saint Martha Kiss of Serenity
-
Bazett Fraga McRemitz Fragarach Alter Image Caren Hortensia's Gift Homunculi Guardians The BB Channel Orion (but really Artemis) Cleopatra
-
This is one of my proudest designs. It predicts a possible end to the multiverse caused by the extinction of the Eldrazi.
-
Summoning Ritual Okie Souji Knighthood Curse of Gorgon's Love Goetia Storch Ritter Gilles de Rais Artoria Pendragon (Lily)
-
Tohsaka Manor Matou Mansion Camlann Battlefield The Shapeless Isle Babylon Domremy-la-Pucelle Hot Spring of the Moon Goddess Angra Mainyu, Tainted Land Ainsworth Fuyuki
-
@Corwinnn beat me to the punch! Yeah, hybrid mana in mana costs call for a hybrid border, otherwise use the gold border.
-
Unified Defense Against Goetia Something Precious to Protect The Grail Dialogue Kaleidoscope Arimago Island
-
Excalibur - Morgan Madness Command Seal Aestus Domus Aurea Eyes of the Gorgon Rejecting Oneself
-
Herakles Belepheron Rule Breaker Luminosite Eternelle Photon Ray, War God's Sword
-
Cu Chulainn Elizabeth Bathory Scathach Leonardo da Vinci Semiramis
-
Sorry, I've been pretty busy this week. I'll pick up where I left off.
-
Artoria Pendragon Artoria Pendragon (Alter) Nero Claudius Miyamoto Musashi Nameless, Emiya Ishtar Gilgamesh, King of Heroes Medusa Francis Drake Alexander, King of Conquerors
-
I've started that second look over the set. For your convenience, I'll list the cards where I've made additional comments here. Also, there are asterisks next to places where I think you could put your Lancer tokens, as well. Gudako, Hope of Chalde…
-
I left you a card-specific comment about Medb, but for help with your broader plan concerning tokens, I need a quick refresher on what the different Servant types are, what their color identities are usually, and what best describes their role in yo…
-
Not a problem! Let me know when you've finished all of your edits, and I'll go back over the whole set again real quick to see if there's any little things we missed.
-
The notation goes like this: <*a href=link you want>words you want<*/a*> , minus all the asterisks.
-
@modnation675 , I'm a little at a loss with this card. Do you have any input?
-
Were it just me, I'd print it on plain white paper and just glue the picture to a basic land or a token or whatnot. I may just be lazy in that regard.
-
I like your attitude @RayearthIX ! I'm more than willing to go through your whole set, but it will take a while. If you have a card you want specific commentary on, just let us know, and I'll go to that first.
-
Okay, I'd be happy to give you some feedback. Look to the individual cards for my comments.
-
@mtgcardsmith "We meet again, [insert name here]." Or perhaps, in preparation for Ixalan, "Ahoy there, [insert name here]!"
-
@RayearthIX , what exactly are you looking for? Power-level balancing, wording changes to make the cards fit official Magic rules language, or just rules checks to make sure your cards work as you intended?
-
More steeds!
-
@Faiths_Guide , nope, I can't say that I do. I like the designs, though!
-
I feel like you may be trying to have too many contests at the same time.
-
I had an idea recently about a new take on Soulbond. This contest inspired me to incorporate that concept into a cycle! Here are the first three. Depending on the number of submissions we can have, I may finish the cycle soon.
-
I feel like I missed Tamiyo's second ability. I'm a little concerned about the strength of the ramp with that one. With a discard effect, you could easily have a large-CMC card in the graveyard that you could use to power out a bomb very quickly. Wi…
-
@saveria201 , that's not going to happen. WotC has said that they are not interested in making settings based around cultures that still exist, so anything that ties to Hinduism is off of the table. The best you would get is more Indian aesthetics i…