MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Platypusburger
About
- Username
- Platypusburger
- Joined
- Visits
- 2,082
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@Tigersol , fair enough.
-
@Tigersol , didn't he save Chandra and Nissa from the deadlock trap? That's something.
-
@NokiSkaur , some brief answers: 3f. (Minor spoilers): Ajani joins the Gatewatch at the end of the Aether Revolt storyline. He objects to fighting Nicol Bolas on the dragon's own turf, so he doesn't come to Amonkhet with the other five. Presumably …
-
@Tigersol , don't take the cards too literally. If you do, you have to wonder things like how a demon (Razaketh) is almost twice as strong as any of the gods. The Gatewatch loses, but that doesn't mean they die. Besides, Jace has been spoiled as be…
-
@Tigersol , don't get your hopes up. The Gatewatch isn't all going to die. In fact, probably none of them will, except possibly Gideon.
-
@Tigersol , yeah he did. But if he was gonna pop up again anywhere, it would have been in the block that brought back Phyrexians.
-
@Tigersol , you're right. That was the greatest missed opportunity since Mishra wasn't in Scars block.
-
@Latinas , it's a bit of a mistake to call Kaladesh the "Indian block". Rather, it's the "steampunk block", with a little bit of Indian art design for aesthetics. It is quite explicitly not a block that was designed to reflect an ancient culture, li…
-
@syntheticreign , blocking does not tap creatures at all, so your out doesn't work there.
-
@Lujikul , assuming it's untapped, of course. That was unclear of me, but I was referring specifically to a creature like Gelectrode's, with vigilance. @syntheticreign , what makes you think that just because you declared it as an attacker that you…
-
If a creature attacks during another player's combat phase, can it also block during that same phase?
-
It's kinda weird that this turned into an argument about annihilator. (Regardless of its power, I argue against it because it's too anti-fun.) @Mellenius , I see a couple problems, some of which some others have already pointed out. 1. The first i…
-
@modnation675 , wasn't that announcement part of the plan going forward to the no-block model, i.e. not taking effect until after Ixalan?
-
@Mellenius , pretty much every major character in the story has a card that's already been revealed for them. There aren't many good options, except perhaps Hapatra. Personally, I don't expect to see any other walker cards in this set, besides Bola…
-
I have another challenge: make a card representing a mythical creature that is new to you. (In other words, go google a list of mythical creatures from various world cultures, pick one you've never encountered before, learn a little about it, and m…
-
@Karmadragon . Thanks for the contest! I'll take faves on whichever cards you'd like to dispense them to, same as TenebrisNemo. Congratulations to all the other winners and HMs!
-
I'm privileged to bring you a card that I would strangle someone for playing.
-
@Faiths_Guide , @Lujikul , I highly recommend you both look into Vonnegut's books. He's a fantastic author. I always liked Slaughterhouse 5, in particular. Anyway, I challenge you to create a card that can't be cast or played from the hand.
-
-
@Karmadragon , doesn't Rakdos the Defiler count as the Commander for Demon-tribal?
-
I've tried to puzzle through this one before. The key wrinkle is that you're trying to reconcile a 5-variable system (five colors of mana) with a 3-variable system (the three alignments along the order track and morality track). There's no way those…
-
Here's my version of Teferi, who has taken his arcane understanding of time and applied it to more... practical purposes. Original/New Version:
-
Planeswalker sparks at birth? I can only imagine the number of times a baby has accidentally transported itself to somewhere like Grixis because it had a tantrum.
-
@Brainifyer , same as Vyktur, if you please.
-
@modnation675 That would certainly qualify.
-
A spell that interacts with objects in the command zone.
-
What's more, he has a challenge for you!
-
Vorthos is here to test your card knowledge!
-
@Baron-777 , sure thing!
-
@TheAcidicSniper , @HenryTheHatter , @theimmortaldeath , @Faiths_Guide , @Animist , @Credius , @Cybernekit Thank you all for your submissions! The contest is concluded, and the winners are as follows: Best Planeswalker Card: Brigitte Haerkenlaer,…