MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Potato13
About
- Username
- Potato13
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,052
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@ningyounk , I'm very much against Angels and Clerics. You have to have a mass of both tribes in the set, which is much more restrictive than Humans, and you have to print non-parasitic payoffs for them which is a hard task to accomplish. I do hav…
-
@ningyounk , I have a few other ideas for B/G archetypes that aren't shared with any other colors. 1. Humans. This is a rather plain one; lots of humans at common, and both Black and Green have attempted human synergy in the past (w/B in Ikoria, w/…
-
@ningyounk , I agree with Brash Announcer losing haste, although even that is mildly concerning. For Court Mentor, would it being a 0/2 or a 0/3 with Double Strike be interesting? As for Growling Missionary, I feel it would be better if the card p…
-
@HeroKP , I pick Geothermal Crevice as my landscape, and my Calamity chosen is Paradoxical Haze.
-
I wish to join aswell; while I'm usually against contests, this does seem like a rather innovative contest.
-
@ningyounk , I also did a bit of checking on the wording for the current uncommons. 1. In Memorain should have the text "Put target creature card from a graveyard onto the battlefield under your control with an additional +1/+1 counter on it. That…
-
My thoughts on all of the cards posted so far: @shadow123 , Memory Dismissal is cool but definitely an idea I've seen a few times before and done slightly better, such as on a kicker card or an entwine card. Balanced, but the black cost could be an…
-
@ningyounk , the spot for Surge of Joy is probably best for either: 1. Another 2-Drop. 2. A sideboard card against certain deck archetypes / themes. My thoughts for cards to fill the slot are: TBA - W Sorcery Exile target artifact or enchantm…
-
@Corwinnn , I would be open to volunteer judging - I find critiquing cards and how to break them in each unique format to be a lot more fun than actually creating them myself. I also don't wish to earn any Challenge Points for judging - I find that …
-
@ningyounk , I will also say that instead of having +1/+1 counter synergy, hear me out: Keyword Soup tribal. While the amount of +1/+1 counters in both Green and Black at common are lacking, there are a surprising amount of Keywords - Reach, Deathto…
-
@ningyounk , if you wanted the Abandoned Axe to fit a theme slightly less plastic-ly, the my idea is: Abandoned Axe - R Artifact - Equipment When you look at ~ from the top of your library, you may exile it. Until end of turn, you may cast it with…
-
@ningyounk , My thoughts on the Black cards: 1. Somber Poet feels like a common. 2. Council of Traitors could definitely do with being 3 mana, or making each player discard a card. Not only is giving board clear reassurance really good and the ef…
-
@ChoyBoi , I'd personally swap the equip cost and the actual cost of Heartblood Devourer. I also find the idea of an equipment that does nothing for a creature without requiring deck-specific setups to be weird for limited, and I additionally don't …
-
@ningyounk , sorry for a late reply but I'm evaluating the Blue cards. Oracle of New Horizons seems very efficient; the idea is cool but it should Scry 2 because of the ability for U/W control or pretty much any modern deck to go T1 Fetch-Shock-Orac…
-
@MemoryHead , Keshef is definitely too good for standard. Turning pretty decent cards like Gleaming Overseer, Enter the Godeternals, Bleeding Edge and Lazotep Reaver into powerhouses while being able to play the myriad of Zombie support, on top of t…
-
@ChoyBoi , apologies for mentioning the wrong person.
-
@RandomFandom , I would avoid giving Toshiro haste and flying; or haste in general. I feel like it would be fine as a keyword-less 4 mana 2/2 or a 3 mana 1/2 that only give +2/+0. It's scary for standard at 5 mana as a 4/3 that just says "Deal 14" …
-
Here's three other alternative ideas for uncommons that could potentially be used: CARD NAME - 3W Sorcery Create three 1/1 white CARD TYPE creature tokens with lifelink. Purpose: Fits into 2 or less power and 3 life gained/lost. CARD NAME - 1…
-
@ningyounk , a few thoughts about the cards there: 1. Growling Missionary is definitely a color pie break; White doesn't get those types of 1 mana 2/2's with downsides (Their 1 mana 2/2's generally have some restriction to when or how you cast them…
-
One of the largest knocks against Mtgcardsmith is unfortunately the premium system; I understand that it keeps the people who make the site afloat, but the fact that there's a paywall to edit your cards... is actually quite despicable and seems to p…
-
The issue isn't just the frames. The issue is the card text itself - when you only have two options for text size, and it clips outside of the card most of the time, that isn't a sign of a good site. Every other site looks better because of it. And …
-
Other card suggestions, mostly stuff that always appears at uncommon in a set like removal / ramp / others, and a bit of archetype hate or support for a theoretical standard. CARD NAME - W Instant Target creature you control gains indestructible u…
-
@RandomFandom , I think MSE is computer-only.
-
MtgCardsmith isn't precisely the "Best" card creation site - wonky text, several types of frames missing, a definite lack of customization, eta. Really, it should only be used if a contest on the forums mandates it. I userstand a want to limit MtgCa…
-
A few more card suggestions: CARD NAME - 3GG Creature - INSERT TYPE When ~ enters the battlefield, if you have 30 or more life, ~ becomes your masterwork. Whenever ~ attacks, put a +1/+1 counter on it. If it's your masterwork, put three +1/+1 coun…
-
@joemamajoe , Serran Beauty seems like a dangerous design. Could do some degenerate things with Nourishing Shoal, Children of Korlis, Martyr of Sands and such.
-
Suggestion for an Uncommon card: INSERT NAME - XR Sorcery As an additional cost to cast ~, pay X life. Choose one: *~ deals X damage to target creature or planeswalker. *Discover X times.
-
My thoughts on some of the cards posted recently: @Level20GnollBard , Miser's Bauble is pretty broken in vintage. Vintage is a format defined by free spells (All of the Forces, Moxen, stuff like Hollow One and Hogaak, Mindbreak, Mental Misstep, Dr…
-
@zizick123 , the wording is a bit off. It would be "Whenever a creature dealt damage by Dreadglance Basalisk this turn dies, put a +1/+1 counter on Dreadglance Basilisk." The wording is functionally identical to the card Predator Ooze. There are thr…
-
@ChoyBoi , Summon Mox seems decent. I am mildly concerned at the potential of a storm-style deck utilizing it, Psychic Puppetry and other Arcane cards. It's probably fine, though, but would require playtesting to fully realize the potential.