MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Potato13
About
- Username
- Potato13
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,052
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@jpastor , I'll definitely be holding off on that family platter until later. Timezones and all that make 24-hour challenges mildly hard to do on a non-weekend. But for the mystery challenge, here's my card. I realized that there weren't any actual…
-
@jpastor , my card for the Rougarou mystery box. I really wanted to capture the feeling of a blood curse, that regardless of how long you hold it off for, will always exist until the Rougaru dies. Keeping the Rougarou elusive, with ward and avoiding…
-
@jpastor , I'll use the aether vial reward to duel @cadstar369 for the reminder of the deadline. I'd also like another mystery box.
-
@jpastor , well, I'll go with a fun option for my choice; AEther Vial (Experimental Challenge/Prize). Should be enjoyable. And if I can't choose AEther Vial as my prize for any reason, then I'll settle for Shiny Chalice (P.1-100 Random Prize).
-
@jpastor , I choose the third prize from Unknown New Category 1. I'd like to see what the category is. EDIT: Assuming I can pick that prize.
-
@jpastor , The previous mystery box challenge that I chose was "Create an un card with a dessert in the artwork and with an ability that starts with "Choose another player."" I may have slightly misread dessert as desert, but I'm too eager to get b…
-
My thoughts on most of the interesting cards from this page: Tamper with Fate: As of now, could use a tiny power boost. Maybe change the upkeep trigger to an end step trigger? Maestros Initiation: Seems very, very busted, primarily because of con…
-
Clinkclong knows that jewelrys mean good luck - Clinkclong's looteds plenty of jewellers in his pasts. but the ring doesn't feels right to Clinkclong. Still, perhaps the rings was sent by a goblin friends? Maybe it's a pranks? Maybes it's a powerful…
-
I won't post a card - anyone else can post a card instead. I'm more of a feedback person.
-
Reviews on the cards on this current page: Psychedelic Cartographer: A fine card, however DukeOfPork's feedback isn't applicable. A card can enter the battlefield and still require it to be cast - Coal Stoker, Cyclone Summoner, Feasting Troll King,…
-
The ring bores Clinkclong - if Clinkclong wants to look at metal, Hund is there. And the scroll bores Clinkclong, because Clinkclong burnts plenty of scrolls when plunderings and stealings. Clinkclong more interesteds in the fact nobody was at the d…
-
I agree that Cursemage's Path shouldn't be 5-color, although not for the reasons already stated. It feels like a 5-color card for the sake of a 5-color card. The reason why it worked for Sanctum of All was because there was a balanced but small amou…
-
Clinkclong, Cur Rider by Potato13 | MTG Cardsmith "You sees, Clinkclong not wanted to go on adventure. Clinkclong thinks that scavenging life good, eatable birdies and lottsa weapon. But then Clinkclong find dog - Clinkclong try to lick dog, but it…
-
@TerryTags , I should have made it clear that they are two separate Jade Myrs.
-
Thoughts on some of the cards posted on this page: Phantomancy: Seems too powerful at common; consider that in Pauper, most non-Tron decks will have problems trying to kill the 2/2's for 2, and even then most of the removal still puts tron at a te…
-
I dislike Violin because white shouldn't get repeatable card draw unless it asks something of you, or is something an opponent can prevent on its own. The opponent can't prevent the Violin from being tapped and you drawing a card. White also general…
-
My submission for my challenge, "Create a creature flying through lightning with Storm in its name and mana cost equal to the number of spells you cast this turn. It can't have storm itself". Note: Yes, I did use Microsoft Paint to edit the card p…
-
@KorandAngels , I suggest including your reasoning for disagreeing when you reply to someone, rather than just saying a rhetorical question. If I assume what you mean, then even for commander, it's massively overtuned. Compare to one of the more po…
-
Selenia feels massively overtuned when meant for a standard format. It's a 5 mana 3/3 keyword soup creature with a bounce trigger that can't be reacted to, at instant speed, that can return any card from your graveyard to the battlefield and another…
-
My challenge was "Create a Serpent that has two abilities with reminder text for each and is an Un card with precisely 7 mana. Furthermore, it can't have a Serpent in the artwork." I couldn't find the silver border in the card editor, so just preten…
-
For the challenge, "Create a one drop creature or enchantment that has an activated ability that has in the activation cost." Apologies for missing the deadline - I was unfortunately sick yesterday and couldn't make it then. Figure of Fiends by…
-
My opinion on the Hieromantic Decrees - * The first design is fine, but I would cut the last ability out - it feels like a curveball compared to the other two abilities which tax playing cards from non-hand locations and not likely to come up in m…
-
Apologies for being away for so long - school deadlines and all that. For the five favorites I received from the challenge that resolved right after I stopped consistently showing up, give them to the five cards by any cardsmith that are posted afte…
-
@ningyounk , I like the idea of Fire the Catapults. However, I do also have a different idea; it's a rather unusual, but seems like interesting design space to explore. {X}{X}{R} Sorcery or Instant ~ costs {1} less for each creature you control. ~…
-
In regards to the masterwork manarock, I have a solution that could work: TBA - {3} Artifact T: Add one mana of any color. {4}, T: Target creature you control can't be blocked until end of turn. For the red board clear: TBA - {R} Sorcery ~ deal…
-
I'd like to hear about why card draw is overrated - just your thoughts and reasonings on the subject to let me see your perspective better than a broad statement would.
-
Current opinions so far on the mechanics and themes: * Twilight should be a no-go. People absolutely hated Phyrexian Mana, not only for the reason that it was too powerful, but that it laid waste to the color pie. We're going down the exact same p…
-
U/W is far from the worst color combination imo. Looking at modern, both Spirits and Azorious Control - two of the eight most popular decks in modern - use U/W, meanwhile the two most popular W decks in standard also play blue. There are also a bunc…
-
The change from "converted mana cost" to "mana value" seems so... unnecessary. It'll just cause confusion for returning players who attempt to find out what mana value is, and more problems for new players who will be confused as to why converted ma…
-
General advice about custom sets: * Use a design skeleton. That is always the first thing a set needs to do; establish how large the set is. The link to the fundamentals and implementation of a design skeleton is here - [PRIMER] Set Skeletons - Cu…