MTG Cardsmith Community Forums
Potato13
About
- Username
- Potato13
- Joined
- Visits
- 1,052
- Last Active
- Roles
- Member
Comments
-
@zizick123 , I find Primcast Scholar to be fun. Especially with Sram's Expertise - two-card combo that requires setup. @KEdRuss , the power of Hilde is fine as-is. A 5 mana 2/4 that comes with a 3/3 is only barely better than a Broodmate Dragon, a…
-
Reviewing most cards from October 24-26: @ChoyBoi , Murk Waker is not what I'd call good design, primarily because landwalk isn't good design. There are copious articles as to why landwalk hasn't appeared on any recent cards, I'd recommend finding…
-
'@KEdRuss , Ysolda seems actually fun. I'd love to make some sort of Naya Angels list for Modern with it. As for Angel of Crystal Wings; I don't like Reflect. It feels very narrow as a mechanic and not capable of synergy or fun interactions (Unlik…
-
@zizick123 , just to warn you in case you think it's how the card works, first strike does NOT affect fighting. Each will still deal combat damage to each other as normal, and first strike will do nothing. Also, the card is extremely strange. Black…
-
@KingSumples , Agnate is cool, although I do feel like it is outclassed by other commanders (Edric, Spymaster of Trest). Lovisa on the other hand I don't like for several dozen reasons; Boros being the weakest color combination in Commander makes th…
-
@KEdRuss, Luminarch Gate could safely be 8 colorless. Most Mono-White Weenie decks, which is where this card shines, would struggle to make it worth the price or to get sufficent value with it, especially since it can be a very dead card in some mat…
-
@Choyboi , this is my review for Starsworn Familiar; you created "Empyrial Storm", a weak card. It's extremely odd how the dragons do not have flying. I fully feel like it could cost 6 mana, since while it can be dangerous if flickered, there isn't …
-
@IronCrusher , Roda seems a bit too good. It's a flexible 3 mana 4/5 that can't be countered. @Temurzoa , TImeswipe is definitely too good. I'd recommend removing the ability to cast if for free, since a 5 mana "Better Murder every 2 turns" is alre…
-
@ChoyBoi , Saira could feasibly be a 3 mana 4/4 without any problems. @jicklemania2, Relentless Deathwalker seems very pushed. Compare and contrast to Ravenous Hyena and Morkrut Banshee, the former of which saw vast play in standard, and you'll see…
-
@jpastor , in the case that I must use mtgcardsmith for most cards, I do not wish to recieve another box, as mtgcs feels very stifling on my creativity and efficiency to create good looking cards. I thank you for all the boxes you've given me up to …
-
@jpastor , I wish for another box. As a question, is it fine if I use a non-Cardsmith program to create an image that links to my MTGCardsmith card? Other sites just support Sagas and 4-Planeswalkers, Unhinged card frames and other things.
-
@ChoyBoi , a 3 mana 4/1 with haste and flying is not okay in any format. Giving it a bit extra value in constantly coming back is where I draw the line. Even at 4 mana this is concerningly good for standard, and maybe even better than the bomb that …
-
@Animist , the card would be okay as a 1-drop. The card itself doesn't seem that good even with a format with Cauldron Familiar in it; your opponent will generally attempt to kill the Familiar on an end step, which makes it a decently large dud in a…
-
@jicklemania2 , counter strike is clunky, and even though it isn't your mechanic I still feel a need to critique it. (Base Toughness doesn't synergise with toughness boost, it fights for space with First Strike, Flying and Double Strike as synergist…
-
@jicklemania2 , Harvet frankly seems like a narrow mechanic. It's supporting both aristocrats and tribal themes, two things that have very little mechanic flow outside of Goblins and your newly made Pumpkin tribe. Not only that, but the hoops this f…
-
@jpastor "Your Division 2 Mystery Challenge: Using this artwork by Justin Gerard, create a white permanent with "colorless creature" in its ability text." This is the finale of the contest, and I hope my submission is a good sendoff.
-
@SNAPcreator7 , I look at the airlock through the cameras.
-
@jpastor , my card for the challenge "Create a card with only one ability, but no flavor text." I will say that I wish I could use Mtg.design or Magic Set Editor for these cards, but this is the mtgcardsmith forums after all.
-
@SNAPcreator7 , I go back to the Watcher's station to do some more camera watching.
-
@jpastor , my card. I won't ask for more mystery boxes; I have too much going on. My challenge was "Create a snow creature.", So I decided to make a simple one at common for limited, playable in most decks that can splash snow mana but exceptiona…
-
@SNAPcreator7 , I'm going to try and search around the Left Hall.
-
I agree to @ChoyBoi 's truce, although only through nodding. (Nightmares can't speak.) Afterwards, I check around the Watcher's Station while periodically looking at the camera for the Airlock.
-
@jpastor , My challenge was "Create a black permanent with landfall." So here you go.
-
I'll be searching with ChoyBoi, then.
-
@SNAPcreator7 , my apologies for that. The BREATHING is probably nothing - not like I'd know much about breathing - nightmares don't need to breathe and thus the sound isn't too alerting.
-
@SNAPcreator7 , the figure is probably nothing. Hopefully. I attempt to search the room for anything before bolting to the Watcher's Room and browsing the cameras for a short period.
-
@SNAPcreator7 I'll search for clues around the Radio Room before it becomes occupied by anybody.
-
@The-DM , you see, that's the genius of the design; people see it and they incorrectly think it's useless. The ability allows you to do numerous things: * Trigger Spell-cast effects several time with just the one card, for cards such as "Arclight …
-
My two submissions for this week.
-
A few cards for thought.